New-generation Migrant Workers' Urban Adaptation:A Case Study of Jianggan District in Hangzhou City

2015-02-06 06:44FeiSUBoLIJianyiHUANGZhimeiLIJiamiaoZENG
Asian Agricultural Research 2015年10期

Fei SU,Bo LI,Jianyi HUANG ,Zhimei LI,Jiam iao ZENG

1.School of Tourism and City Administration,Zhejiang Gongshang University,Hangzhou 310018,China;2.Center for Studies of Marine Economy and Sustainable Development,Liaoning Normal University,Dalian 116029,China;3.College of Applied Arts and Science,Beijing Union University,Beijing 100191,China

1 Introduction

Since the reform and opening up,more and more rural surplus labor forces have left home to the city to seek new development,leading to farmers' frenzied hunt for work in cities[1-2].Migrant workers have made a significant contribution to rural development,urban prosperity and modernization in China[3],but due to the fetters of urban-rural dual system of census register and employment,it is difficult for them to really enjoy the fruits of urban civilization.In recent years,with the inter-generational alternation of migrant workers,new-generation migrant workers have gradually become the main body of migrant workers and play an important role in economic development and urban construction[3-4].New-generation migrant workers usually refer to the rural population working in the city born after the 1980s.They were born after the reform and opening up,with ages between 16 and 30 years[3].Compared with their parents,new-generation migrant workers have stronger sense of rights,awareness of citizenship,and higher career expectations[5-6].Therefore,it is one of the core priorities in new urbanization construction to help them adapt to urban society and make them integrated into city[6].The concept of"livelihoods"is widely used in the study field of poverty,rural development,migrant population[7-8]."Adaptation"generally refers to the reaction after entering into a new environment[9-10],and many scholars have conducted a lot of studies on the connotation,analytical framework,influencing factors and drive mechanism of urban adaptation from different angles[11-15],but there are less studies specifically for new-generation migrant workers' urban adaptation[16-18].Jianggan District is in the center of Hangzhou City,covering an area of about 210 km2.In recent years,there has been rapid economic development in Jianggan District which attracts about380000 people from elsewhere,making it become the main settlement for migrant workers.From the perspective of the livelihoods,this paper takes Jianggan District for example to analyze typical characteristics and causes of new-generation migrant workers' urban adaptation,in order to provide scientific reference for the better integration of new-generation migrant workers into Hangzhou City.

2 Research methods

Livelihood is a means of living,far more than the concept of income[19],and it has now been widely used in research fields of poverty and migrant population.In this study,based on our previous studies[2,4],we divide the livelihood capital of new-generation migrant workers into four categories:physical capital,human capital,financial capital,social capital.(i)Human capital.It refers to the workers' accumulation of knowledge and skills obtained through the investment in education,training,health and other aspects.Education level and training have important significance to non-agricultural livelihoods,so two indicators are used to measure human capital.(ii)Physical capital.It is a long-standing form of production materials after removal of the natural resources in the production process.It is the material wealth as well as the surrounding infrastructure owned by migrant workers.Taking into account the flowing characteristics of new-generation migrant workers,the housing situation in the city is used to measure physical capital.(iii)Financial capital.It mainly consists of cash income,loans obtained from formal and informal channels,and grant aid.The financial capital of new-generation migrant workers is mainly from the remuneration obtained by labor,loans obtained from formal and informal channels,and grantaid.Thus,new-generation migrant workers' cash income,opportunity to have access to bank credit,and opportunity to borrow money from friends and relatives,are used to measure the financial capital.(iv)Social capital.It is the expected collective or economic benefits derived from the preferential treatment and cooperation between individuals and groups.Social capital will be higher if one can get higher interests from the interpersonal relationships,especially from the relationships with friends and relatives,so the number of friends and relatives is used to measure social capital.The new-generation migrant workers' urban adaptation is the constant adjustment by migrant workers on life,work and cultural adaptation after going to city,in order to adapt themselves to the living environment of city.With new-generation migrant workers in Jianggan District of Hangzhou City as research object,the research group conducted a random questionnaire survey and interview in July 2014.450 questionnaires were sent out,and all of them were recovered,with recovery rate of100%.There were 442 valid questionnaires,with validity rate of 98.2%.The content of questionnaire was entered into the computer to form Excel database,and then mathematical and statistical methods and SPSS18.0 software were used for analysis.

3 Results and analysis

3.1 New-generation migrant workers' life adaptation

From Table 1,it is found that for the question"How is your relationship with the locals?",only 12.0%of people opt for"very satisfied";56.2%of people opt for"average";3.6%of people opt for"unsatisfied";1.4%of people opt for"very dissatisfied".During the survey,some people do not want to publish accurate assessment or find it difficult to accurately assess,so they just opt for"average".Through conversation,it can be found that these who say"average"actually do not think the locals are friendly with not much contact,but there is no conflict.They just feel that the birds of different feathers do not flock together[20].Most of the new-generation migrant workers go to city with the help of their relatives,friends or fellow-townsman.The number of relatives and friends in Hangzhou is an important measure of social capital.As shown in Fig.1a,the number of relatives and friends of new-generation migrant workers is not large,and expanding social circle is an important way to enhance their social capital.In the constraints of urban-rural dual system,new-generation migrant workers find it difficult to equally socialize with urban residents,and the original geographical relations are their primary social relations in city.In addition to urban residents' discrimination,it is quite difficult for them to integrate into the urban life[20-21].Judging from the housing(Fig.1b),the new-generation migrant workers solve the housing mainly through house renting and dormitory,reflecting the low overall living standards of new-generation migrant workers.In the survey,it is found that the new-generation migrant workers are more willing to settle in cities than the first-generation migrant workers,and they want to be able to enjoy the benefits of urban residents and incorporated into the urban housing security system to become permanent resident of the city,which also reflects the inter-generational difference in the logic of life[22].However,high property prices in Hangzhou have troubled most of the new-generation migrant workers,and become an important factor that affects their urban adaptation[23].

3.2 New-generation migrant workers' work adaptationWork adaptation is an important aspect of new-generation migrant workers' adaptation to the city[1].From Table 2,it is found that in terms of job satisfaction,the new-generation migrant workers are most dissatisfied with the income,accounting for 18.1%,nearly 2 times of dissatisfaction with the working environment;the satisfaction with relationships with colleagues and superiors is high,and more than half of the respondents are"quite satisfied"or"very satisfied."The new-generation migrant workers live in the environment of reform and opening up,and they lack training opportunities,which makes them lack hard-working quality.They mostly pursue self-enjoyment,and hope to be rooted in the city;they do not want to engage in dirty,tired,poor physical labor.However,high property prices and high consumption levels in city is in stark contrast with their income,which requires them to pay the unbearable economic costs,so they show higher expectation on income.From the income(Fig.1c),the monthly income of new-generation migrant workers is mostly concentrated in 2000-4000 yuan,and the proportion reaches nearly 70%;the new-generation migrant workers with monthly income of more than 4000 yuan account for only 19.2%.Compared with the first generation migrant workers,their income is higher,but lower than that of urban residents.The low economic status has not been effectively improved,and the financial capital needs to be improved.Although they have a strong desire to stay in the city and have attachment for city,they are dissatisfied with their low income obtained through back-breaking work.Unfair treatment reduces their enthusiasm for employment,and they want to get more opportunities,work experience and job skills to obtain higher income[24].

3.3 New-generation migrant workers' cultural adaptation

Cultural adaptation is the inherent basis of individual's mental activity and behavior,and it is necessary to study new-generation migrant workers' cultural adaptation and touch their inner world to help them to be truly integrated into city[25].From Table 3,new generation migrant workers are satisfied with the cultural adaptation,which is inseparable from the urban inhabitants'open mind and tolerant attitude.11.3%of respondents are very satisfied with the city's culture,and only 1.8%of respondents are not satisfied with the city's culture.The degree of satisfaction with customs and cultural integration in the city needs to be improved,and 6.1%of people are not satisfied.Due to the closed environment in the past,new-generation migrant workers' overall quality is low and their life style is conservative,inevitably resulting in the clash with the city's mainstream culture and all kinds of discomfort.Over time,they getacclimatized to the urban environment and are increasingly aware of urban lifestyle.After slowly accepting urban culture,such discomfort will be gradually reduced until it disappears[26].Faced with a better educational environment and educational opportunities,the new-generation migrant worker is no longer synonymous with low education[27].As can be shown in Fig.1d,illiterate new-generation migrant workers account for only 0.2%of respondents;40.8%of respondents have received junior high school or technical secondary school education;29.6%of respondents have the education of junior college and above.This shows that the new-generation migrant workers have generally received relatively formal schooling,most of them complete junior or senior high school education,and even some of them receive junior college education.Although the new-generation migrant workers have high cultural quality,they lack corresponding job skills,becoming a major bottleneck in the smooth adaptation to the urban environment[21].Survey shows that 63.7%of the new-generation migrant workers have not received skill training,indicating that new-generation migrant workers and the society are insufficiently aware of the need for vocational skills training.One of the reasons for some migrant workers and enterprises' neglecting of skills training is migrant workers' occupational instability[28].Compared with the first generation migrant workers,the new-generation migrant workers have higher career pursuit,but they lack toughness and maturity,so in the initial stage of career pursuit,they'll be confused and panicky[26].Despite having cultural knowledge,it is difficult to secure a satisfactory easy job in the city when they do not adapt to the urban culture,finally they fall into the situation of frequent change of job[21].

Table 1 The new-generation migrant workers' life adaptation and satisfaction level in Jianggan District

Table 2 The new-generation migrant workers' work adaptation and satisfaction level in Jianggan District

Table 3 The new-generation migrant workers' cultural adaptation and satisfaction level in Jianggan District

4 Conclusions

In this paper,based on the livelihood characteristics of new-generation migrant workers,we establish the livelihood capital evaluation indicator system for the new-generation migrant workers,and take Jianggan District in Hangzhou City for example to analyze the characteristics and causes of new-generation migrant workers' urban adaptation.The study shows that livelihood capital is closely related to employment,income,and life of new-generation migrant workers,and has an important impact on their urban adaptation.The life adaptation,work adaptation and cultural adaptation of the new-generation migrant workers in Jianggan District are still at a low level,and there is a big room for improvement.Based on the livelihood characteristics of new-generation migrant workers,this paper conducts the exploratory research on new-generation migrant workers' urban adaptation from the perspective of livelihood capital,which not only enriches the city fusion theory,but also has practical significance for the citizenization of new-generation migrant workers in the city.However,the findings of this paper need further in-depth analysis,and the future research focus is to be placed on the exploration of impact of livelihood capital on new generation migrant workers' urban adaptation through binary logistic regression model.

[1]XUCX.Falling to the ground,but taking no roots-The urban adaptability of the peasant-workers of the new generation[J].South China Population,2007,22(4):52-56.(in Chinese).

[2]SU F,PAN XY,LIZM.Evaluation on the identification of migrant workers’living risk and risk resistance capacity in Hangzhou City[J].Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences,2015,56(1):149-151.(in Chinese).

[3]WANGMX,RAN YM,LIUM.An analysis of problems of the new generation of peasant workers into the urban[J].China Youth Study,2012(1):31-38.(in Chinese).

[4]SU F,PANG LF,MA LS.The impactof livelihood capital on the life satisfaction of urban migrant workers in Hangzhou[J].Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis,2014,26(1):241-246.(in Chinese).

[5]LIU CJ.Study on the citizenization of China's migrant farmers[J].Theory Monthly,2006(10):5-12.(in Chinese).

[6]XIA F,CHEN JN.Discussion on the education demand generation of migrant workers in urbanization process[J].Fujian Tribune(The Humanities&Social Sciences Bimonthly),2013(10):166-167.(in Chinese).

[7]LUWY,LIYW,NIJW.A literature review on sustainable livelihood[J].China Collective Economy,2011(3):83-84.(in Chinese).

[8]MA LS,SU F,PAN YX.The research progress of sustainable livelihood of migrant workers[J].Economic Research Guide,2012(28):127-129.(in Chinese).

[9]LEIY.Study on the urban adaptability of new generation of migrant workers[J].Reform&Openning,2012(12):61-62.(in Chinese).

[10]ZHENYQ,JIANGH,ZHURH.An overview of the newest research of urban adaptability of rural migrant workers in cities[J].Development Research,2013(1):102-104.(in Chinese).

[11]Hinkel J."Indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity":Towards a clarification of the science-policy interface[J].Global Environmental Change,2011(21):198-208.

[12]Morse S,McNamara N.The theory behind the sustainable livelihood approach[M].Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht,2013.

[13]S.Morse,N.McNamara.Livelihood into life style[C].Morse S,McNamara N.The theory behind the sustainable livelihood approach[M].Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht,2013.

[14]TolRST,Yohe GW,The weakest link hypothesis for adaptive capacity:An empirical test[J].Global Environmental Change,2007(17):218-227.

[15]Engle NL.Adaptive capacity and its assessment[J].Global Environmental Change,2011(21):647-656.

[16]Sansfa on AP,Brown M,John Graham,et al.Adaptation and acculturation:Experiences of internationally educated social workers[J].Int.Migration&Integration,2013,

[17]Estes RJ.Advancing quality of life in a turbulent world[M].Springer,2007.

[18]LIU JK,LIU Q,ZHAO CY.Service based design solutions-A case of migrant workers’affective links with their families in rural areas of China[J].Lecture Notes in Computer Science,2013(8023):410-419.

[19]SU F,XU ZM,SHANG HY.An overview of sustainable livelihoods approach[J].Advances in Earth Sciences,2009,24(1):61-69.(in Chinese).

[20]LIHY.New-generation migrant workers' integration into the urban society[J].China Business,2010(24):51-52.(in Chinese).

[21]XIAO F,ZOU XL.Study on the problems of acculturation of new generation of migrant workers and its countermeasures[J].Vocational&Technical Education Forum,2012(13):34-37.(in Chinese).

[22]ZHENG ZH.The dwelling condition and development trend of new generation of migrant workers[J].China Youth Study,2011(1):19-24.(in Chinese).

[23]SU F,MA LS,PANG LF,et al.Vulnerability of migrant workers' livelihoods in Hangzhou City and the countermeasures[J].Progress in Geography,2013,32(3):389-399.(in Chinese).

[24]TONG ZB.Career and work adaptation:Urban practice of new generation of migrant workers[J].China Youth Study,2011(1):10-14.(in Chinese).

[25]WANG Y.Research on cross-cultural adaptation of new generation migrant laborers integrating into the city[J].Value Engineering,2012,31(20):321-322.(in Chinese).

[26]ZOU XL.The new generation cultural analysis of influence factors to migrant workers[J].Communication of Vocational Education,2012(10):42-43.(in Chinese).

[27]YU L.Investigation and analysis on human capital of new generation of migrant workers and their employment situation——Taking the case of Zhejiang Province[J].The World of Survey and Research,2010(8):39-40.(in Chinese).

[28]WEIJH,LUO Z,WENG ZL.Effect of human capital factor on the employment of new generation of migrant workers and their income levels[J].Economic Research Guide,2013(9):151-153.(in Chinese).