安芷谊+王冰梅
摘 要 在精英式高等教育阶段,高校以及专业的布局是“和而不同”,实行全国统一高考是相对合理的;扩招后的大众化高等教育阶段,高校以及专业的布局是“同而不和”,扩大自主招生、高校与考生双向选择是必然趋势。实现自主招生公平公正的前提是:建立专业的、中立的高校考核机构,建立科学公正的量化的考核体系,合理分配各种客观指标权重和系数。这样,基本形成一个环路:考生和家长(挑选)—高校(约束)—老师(约束)—学生—用人单位(反馈)—质量考核机构(评价)—高校。在生态学上,循环是最高效、最经济的。
关键词 “和而不同” “同而不和” 高校考核机构社会化 良性循环
中图分类号:G640 文献标识码:A
Ideas to Achieve Ecology of College Survive Competition
AN Zhiyi, WANG Bingmei
(Jiyang College of Zhejiang A & F University, Zhuji, Zhejiang 311800)
Abstract In the elite higher education, college and professional layout is "harmony but different" unified national college entrance examination is relatively reasonable; mass higher education after enrollment, college and professional layout is "same but not harmony" expanded self-enrollment, college and two-way choice of candidates is an inevitable trend. The precondition for self-enrollment fair and impartial: the establishment of a professional, neutral assessment institution to establish quantifiable science fair evaluation system, a reasonable allocation of various weights and objective indicators coefficient. Thus, the basic form a loop: Candidates and their parents (selection) - Colleges (constraint) - Teacher (constraint) - Students - Employers (feedback) - Quality Assessment Agency (Evaluation) - universities. In ecology, recycling is the most efficient and economical.
Key words "harmony but different"; "same but not harmony"; socialization of university examination body; virtuous cycle
前段时间,有个关于高校文理分科和高考方面的全国性大话题引起广泛的关注,新闻1+1的白岩松和央视二套“谈话”栏目几乎同时推出讨论。专家的观点和两个主持人的总结几乎是一致的:文理分科问题归根结底是高考制度问题,高考制度问题归根结底是高等教育体制问题。高考方式应该改革,但全国统考是目前中国相对公平的选拔人才方式。
1 大众化高等教育时代,高校评价机构的社会化和中立性的必然性
1977年之后,大学是每一个中国家庭都有权问鼎、却只有十分之一的考生有权享受的事物,国家对这十分之一的“国家的人”一切全包,进了大学等于进了保险箱,因此,为了体现社会主义公平,必需采取统一高考这种一刀切的办法,裁掉绝大部分人,留下的少数人就成了精英。……