郭海强+姚令侃+郭沉稳+黄艺丹



摘要:针对汶川地震Ⅹ度和Ⅺ度烈度区崩塌滑坡面积与累计频率统计关系呈现不同分布规律的现象,开展了地震峰值加速度从0.075~0.450g的6组振动台沙堆模型实验.实验重现了随振动强度增加,落沙量与累计频率从幂律分布-对数正态分布-正态分布依次转变的现象.数学分析表明,变异系数的减小,是这3种概型依次转变的原因.根据实验观察,随扰动递增沙堆表面颗粒行为呈现不同响应模式:微振动时颗粒活动性消失的概率与活动性分叉的概率在总体上平衡,当颗粒间近邻的相互作用导致连锁反应时才能发生大规模落沙事件,具有最大的不确定性.强振动时大部分颗粒就能独立启动,大规模落沙成为必然事件.据此提出,落沙规模由自组织控制的颗粒链式反应过程,向外力控制的颗粒独立下落过程的转化是导致变异系数减小的物理机制.根据以上认识,随地震烈度增加,汶川地震触发的崩塌滑坡规模与累计频率依次服从幂律分布-对数正态分布的现象,可能是具有普适性意义的规律.
关键词:地震;滑坡;自组织临界性;沙堆模型实验;变异系数
中图分类号:TU435;P694 文献标识码:A
StudyontheResponseMechanism
ofSandpileModelTestswithIncreasedSeismicLoading
GUOHaiqiang1,YAOLingkan1,2,3,GUOChenwen1,HUANGYidan1
(1.SchoolofCivilEngineering,SouthwestJiaotongUniv,Chengdu,Sichuan610031,China;2.MOEKeyLab
ofHighSpeedRailwayEngineering,Chengdu,Sichuan610031,China;3.RoadandRailwayEngineering
ResearchInst,SichuanKeyLabofAseismicEngineeringandTechnol,Chengdu,Sichuan610031,China)
Abstract:Accordingtothephenomenonofstatisticalrelationshipsshowingdifferentdistributions,betweentheareaandcumulativefrequencyoflandslidesinⅩ,ⅪseismicintensityofMs8.0Wenchuanearthquake,6sandpilemodeltestsunderseismicwereconductedwiththeincreaseofseismicpeakgroundaccelerationrangingfrom0.075gto0.450g.Thephenomenonofstatisticalrelationshipswasreproducedbythetestsbetweentheamountandcumulativefrequencyofsandchangingfrompowerlawdistributiontolognormaldistribution,thentonormaldistribution,withincreaseofseismicloading.Bymathematicalanalysis,thedecreaseofthecoefficientofvariationisthecauseofprobabilitydistributionshiftbetweenpowerlaw,lognormaldistributionandnormaldistribution.Observedthroughexperiments,theperformanceofgrainsonthesurfaceofsandpilewillshowdifferentmodelswiththeincreaseofseismicloading.Underweakvibration,theprobabilitythattheactivitywilldieisoverallbalancedwiththeprobabilitythattheactivitywillbranch.Alargescalecollapseoccurswhenthereisachaininteractionbetweenneighboringgrains.Ithasthegreatestuncertainty.Understrongvibration,mostgrainsstartindependently.Alargescalecollapsebecomesacertainevent.Therefore,thescaleofcollapseistransformedfromthechainreactionofunstablegrainstriggeredbyselforganizedeffecttotheindependentfallingofunstablegrainstriggeredbyvibratingforceeffect,whichisthephysicalmechanismofthereducingofCv.Accordingtotheaboverealization,thephenomenonoftherelationbetweenareaandcumulativefrequencychangingfrompowerlawdistributiontolognormaldistributionwiththeincreaseofseismicintensityofMs8.0Wenchuanearthquakemaybeuniversal.
Keywords:earthquake;landslide;selforganizedcriticality(SOC);sandpilemodeltest;coefficientofvariation
自组织临界状态(SelforganizedCriticality,SOC)理论由Bak[1]首先提出,用以解释复杂系统的行为特性.Held等[2]第一次通过物理实验证明了沙堆具有自组织临界性.通过该实验发现当沙堆达到临界角附近时,落下的一粒沙,可能固定在沙堆上、也可能引起小范围沙……