陈文昊
(北京大学法学院,北京100871)
正当防卫认定标准主观化——一场英美刑法引发的革命
陈文昊
(北京大学法学院,北京100871)
[摘要]正当防卫在英美法系中与大陆法系中大相径庭。本文首先分析英美法系中正当防卫的类型,梳理出防卫人身与防卫财产两类,从而可以与大陆法系中正当防卫成立条件比较。英美法系中正当防卫的成立均采用主观标准,以行为人为视角,以“真诚而合理”为纽带,构建正当防卫成立体系。英美法系的主观化标准的引入有利于弥补大陆法系正当防卫现有理论的不足。以防卫限度为例,行为过当说、结果过当说、二重标准说均具缺陷,捉襟见肘。大陆法系框架下的正当防卫构造在其他问题上也存在诸多问题,因而英美法系主观标准的引入对问题的解决颇有裨益。
[关键词]正当防卫;主观标准;正当防卫必要限度
[Abstract]Justifiable defense in common-law system and civil-law system differ too much.The paper analyses the types of justifiable defense in common-law system to conclude the difference of defense of body and defense of property,and compare them with justifiable defense in civil-law system.In common-law system,the standard of justifiable defense is subjective,with the angle of doer and the standard of”honest and reasonable”,they establish the system of justifiable defense.The subjective standard in common-law system makes up the weaknesses in civil-law system to analyze justifiable defense.For example,in terms of limit of defense,the standard of action or the standard of result or the double standard all have problems.The construction of justifiable defense has other problems in civil-law system.The introduction of subjective standard in common-law system has benefits to solve problems.
[Key words]justifiable defense;subjective standard;limit of defense
确定英美法系中正当防卫的类型是分析其成立条件的前提。
美国刑法将正当防卫分为自身防卫(selfdefense)、防卫他人(defense of others)、防卫住宅财产(defense of home and property)及执法防卫(defense of law enforcement)[1]P69。该分类以模范刑法典的规定为脉络展开[2]P46-52。有学者将执法防卫排除出正当防卫的范畴予以讨论[3]P136,是基于对执法防卫类似于大陆法系法令行为的考虑。英国刑法则规定公共防卫与私人防卫[4]P169,前者类似于美国刑法中的执法防卫。有学者打破形式上的分类,依据目的将正当防卫实质地划分为三类:一是为了保护自身和自己的财产;二是为了保护他人人身与财产;……