Effects of Different Sowing and Transplanting Time on Quality and Economic Benefit of Tobacco Variety Yunyan 105

2018-04-09 00:37:20,,,,,,*
Asian Agricultural Research 2018年2期

, , , ,, , *

1. Yunnan Reascend Tobacco Technology (Group) Co., Ltd., Kunming 650106, China; 2. Shanghai Tobacco Group Co., Ltd., Shanghai 200082, China; 3. Qujing Tobacco Company Xuanwei Branch, Xuanwei 655400, China; 4. Huahuan International Tobacco Co., Ltd., Chuzhou 233121, China

1 Introduction

Yunyan 105 is a new tobacco variety bred by Yunnan Academy of Tobacco Agriculture Science, and Yunyan 87 and CF965 are respectively taken as female and male parents. It passed the examination and approval by National Tobacco Variety Approval Committee in December of 2012. The plant is turriform, leaf is oblong and green, the angle of stem and leaf is moderate, and layered yellowing characteristic is obvious. Its growth period in the field is about 128 d, and it moderately resists blank shank disease, alternaria altemata and bacterial wilt, with wider adaptability. As long as having corresponding measures for supporting cultivation, new variety could obtain corresponding high-quality and efficient cultivation effect. Sowing and transplanting time plays a vital role in normal growth and development of tobacco and the formation of excellent quality. Therefore, it is one of guarantee measures for obtaining high-quality and efficient cultivation to study suitable sowing and transplanting time of Yunyan 105. There were more reports on screening suitable cultivation measure of tobacco. The research of Lu Yongheng[1]showed that tobacco quality was greatly affected by plantation technique, ecological environment and inheritance, in which the influence of ecological environment was the maximum. Research result of Wang Guohuaietal.[2]displayed that sowing time could directly affect growth period of tobacco, total accumulated temperature and tobacco seedling quality. Li Huietal.[3-5]found that different transplanting time could greatly affect tobacco growth and development, comprehensive quality traits and economic benefit. Fan Caiyinetal.[6]studied the impact of sowing time on tobacco yield and quality in tobacco-planting region of south Hunan. Tan Zidietal.[7]studied the impacts on tobacco yield and quality by different sowing time. Yang Yaetal.[8]studied the impact of different transplanting time on tobacco growth and development and quality traits. Tian Fengetal.[9]studied the influence on agronomic and economic traits of tobacco and usability of upper tobacco leaves by transplanting time. But these researches mostly study the impacts on yield and quality by sowing and transplanting time of tobacco variety with large-scale plantation in the area, and there is no report on the impacts of suitable sowing and transplanting time of Yunyan 105 on its quality and economic benefit. For this, a field experiment was conducted to explore the effects of different sowing and transplanting time on comprehensive traits and economic benefit of Yunyan 105 in Xuanwei, which aimed to screen the most suitable sowing and transplanting time of Yunyan 105 in the region, and provide the reference for large-area popularization and application.

2 Materials and methods

2.1TestmaterialsYunyan 105 was provided by Qujing Tobacco Company. Basic physical-chemical properties of the tested soil were as below: pH 5.99, organic matter 49.48 g/kg, total nitrogen 1.91 g/kg, total phosphorus 2.80 g/kg, total potassium 12.76 g/kg, available nitrogen 165.60 mg/kg, available phosphorus 4.70 mg/kg, available potassium 234.85 mg/kg.

2.2TestdesignThe test was conducted in Reshui Town of Xuanwei City in 2015, and four treatments were set according to different sowing and transplanting time. Treatment 1(T1): sowing on January 25 and transplanting on March 21; treatment 2(T2): sowing on February 4 and transplanting on April 1; treatment 3 (T3): sowing on February 14 and transplanting on April 10; treatment 4(T4): sowing on February 24 and transplanting on April 20. Each treatment repeated for three times, and district in the field was arranged randomly. Transplanting manner of tobacco was seedling transplantation under the film, plantation density was 1 000 plants/667 m2, and each plant maintained 18-22 leaves. Tobacco cultivation, management and control in the test field were conducted according to high-quality tobacco production specification of Qujing City.

2.3Fieldindexesinvestigation

2.3.1Agronomic traits. According to the standard of YC/T 142-2010, each growth period (resettling stage, vigorous growing stage and mature stage), agronomic traits and field growth period of Yunyan 105 were investigated and recorded.

2.3.2Economic traits. After tobacco was roasted and turned wet in each treatment, the proportion of middle and high-grade tobacco, yield, weight of single leaf, average price and output value of Yunyan 105 were investigated according to the standard of GB 2635-1992.

2.4Indoorindexesdetection

2.4.1Physical characteristics. 3.0 kg of X2F, C3F and B2F tobacco samples were respectively selected, and tensile strength, stem content, equilibrium moisture content and foliage density of Yunyan 105 were detected by the methods of YC/T 31-1996, YC/T 142-2010, GB/T 451.3-2002, GB/T 12914-2008 and YC/T 152-2001. Comprehensive evaluation of physical characteristic indexes was conducted by referring to theTobaccoPlantingZoninginChina[10].

2.4.2Appearance quality. According to tobacco appearance quality evaluation standard made by Zhengzhou Tobacco Research Institute of China National Tobacco Corporation, color, maturity, leaf structure, body, oil and chroma of tobacco were scored[11]. Referring to theTobaccoPlantingZoninginChina[10], appearance quality score of tobacco was counted by index sum method, and comprehensive evaluation of tobacco appearance quality was conducted.

2.4.3Sensory quality. Nine smoking evaluation experts from tobacco enterprise, Yunnan Reascend Tobacco Technology (Group) Co., Ltd., and business enterprise were organized to score aroma quality, aroma quantity, irritancy, aftertaste and offensive odor of tobacco smoke by using "nine-score system" according to the standard of YC/T 138-1998. Referring to theTobaccoPlantingZoninginChina[10], score of tobacco sensory quality index was counted by index sum method, and comprehensive evaluation of tobacco sensory quality was conducted.

2.4.4Conventional chemical compositions. According to the standard methods of YC/T 159-2002, YC/T 173-2003, YC/T 160-2002, YC/T 161-2002 and YC/T 162-2002, nicotine, reducing sugar, total sugar, total nitrogen, chloride ion, potassium ion, K/Cl, nitrogen/nicotine and sugar/nicotine were detected. According to the evaluation methods of theTobaccoPlantingZoninginChina[10]and references[12-15], comprehensive evaluation on chemical components of tobacco was conducted. Comprehensive index (I) of conventional chemical component of tobacco was divided into five grades[10]: high (I≥0.75), higher (0.65≤I<0.75), moderate (0.55≤I<0.65), lower (0.45≤I<0.55) and low (I<0.45).

2.5DatastatisticsandanalysisSPSS14.0 statistical software was used for data analysis. Assignment weighting index sum method was used to evaluate appearance quality, physical features and sensory smoking evaluation quality of tobacco[10], and conventional chemical components of tobacco were evaluated by data model of fuzzy mathematics membership function.

3 Results and analyses

3.1GrowthperiodSeen from Table 1, because that the transplantation in T1treatment was earlier, each growth period was advanced somewhat than other treatments. Seen from whole growth period in the field, they were 158, 150, 144 and 147 d in T1-T4treatments. Transplanting time in each treatment differed by 10 d in turn. To central flower blooming period, difference time of growth period in each treatment gradually shortened. The difference of growth period between T1and T4treatments decreased from 40 to 8 d in maturation period of top leaf. It illustrated that earlier transplanting time could not effectively shorten its growth period in the field. Therefore, it was very important to select suitable transplanting time of tobacco.

Table1GrowthperiodofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

TreatmentsTransplantingtime(month/day)Resettlingstage(month/day)Squaringstage(month/day)Centralflowerbloomingperiod(month/day)Maturationperiodoflowerleaves(month/day)Maturationperiodofmiddleleaves(month/day)Maturationperiodofupperleaves(month/day)Growthdurationaftertransplantation∥dT13/215/15/306/86/227/258/27158T24/15/106/46/166/267/288/29150T34/105/186/136/216/308/29/1144T44/205/246/186/247/68/59/4147

3.2AgronomiccharactersSeen from Table 2, in resettling stage of tobacco, both single-leaf area of middle and lower leaves in T1treatment were significantly lower than that in T2and T3, while single-leaf area of upper leaf in T2and T3treatments was significantly higher than that in T1and T4treatments. In vigorous growing period, single-leaf areas of lower and upper leaves in T2and T3treatments were significantly higher than that in T1and T4treatments, while the difference of middle leaf in each treatment was insignificant. After topping one week, single-leaf areas of upper, middle and lower leaves in T2and T3treatments were all significantly higher than that in T1and T4treatments. The difference of plant height in each treatment was also insignificant in resettling period, vigorous growing period and after topping one week; leaf maintaining number in each treatment was 22. In a word, agronomic characters of T2and T3treatments in each growth period were better, that is to say, comprehensive agronomic traits of Yunyan 105 were better when sown in February 4-14 and transplanted in April 1-10.

Table2AgronomiccharactersofYunyan105withdifferentdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

GrowthstagesTreatmentsLowerleavesAverageleaflengthcmAverageleafwidthcmSingle-leafaream2MiddleleavesAverageleaflengthcmAverageleafwidthcmSingle-leafaream2UpperleavesAverageleaflengthcmAverageleafwidthcmSingle-leafaream2Theaverageplantheight∥cmNumberofleavesResettlingstageT131.617.20.035b39.521.80.055b32.616.20.034b37.3±0.8a-T233.521.70.046a42.323.20.062a36.919.10.045a41.5±1.6a-T333.620.70.044a41.322.90.060a35.818.50.042a40.5±1.0a-T433.020.10.042a40.322.30.057ab34.416.90.037b39.7±0.9a-FastgrowingperiodT149.823.80.075b52.324.30.081a51.823.00.076b70.8±1.2a-T253.625.50.087a55.526.50.093a55.725.20.089a75.5±0.8a-T352.625.00.083a54.525.30.087a54.824.70.086a74.3±0.6a-T450.723.80.077b53.324.70.083a52.823.60.079b72.8±1.0a-AftertoppingoneT166.230.80.129b71.527.40.124b69.624.20.107b129.9±2.7a22weekT269.532.30.142a73.430.40.142a71.726.80.122a134.8±3.1a22T370.532.30.145a73.930.80.144a71.926.90.123a130.3±3.8a22T467.230.60.130b72.629.20.134ab69.825.00.111b132.0±1.3a22

Note: Different letters in the same column indicated significance of difference atP<0.05 level.

3.3PhysicalpropertiesoftobaccoSeen from Table 3, the score of physical property index sum of lower leaf in T3treatment was 82.28, which was the highest, followed by T1treatment (81.49), and the score of T4treatment was 72.89, which was the lowest. The score of physical property index sum of middle leaf in T3treatment was 89.20, which was the highest, followed by T2treatment (79.23), and the score of T4treatment was 67.51, which was the lowest. It illustrated that T3treatment obviously improved physical properties of middle and lower leaves. Physical property index sum score of upper leaf in each treatment all exceeded 82, in which the score of T2treatment was 90.40, which was the highest; scores in T3and T1treatments were slightly lower than that in T2treatment, and they were respectively 88.70 and 87.26; score of T4treatment was 82.25, which was the lowest. In a word, T3treatment (sown on February 14 and transplanted on April 10) could make tobacco obtain better physical properties.

Table3PhysicalpropertiesofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

Treat-mentsTobaccogradeThicknessmmStemcontent%Foliagedensityg/m2TensilestrengthNTensileintensityKN/mEquilibriummoisturecontent∥%Fillingvaluecm3/gIndexscoresT1X2F0.10230.3360.662.070.13813.044.5181.49T20.10428.8653.192.400.16013.224.1876.72T30.10527.9458.632.180.14613.143.8482.28T40.09532.1548.892.350.15713.034.8872.89T1C3F0.12630.1256.362.320.15512.124.7775.31T20.11533.8361.791.930.12912.804.9079.23T30.10926.3063.381.870.12414.063.3889.20T40.12332.5769.722.810.18812.794.0667.51T1B2F0.15626.3791.672.400.16013.753.6287.26T20.16725.2786.012.080.13812.474.0490.40T30.14826.5979.222.110.14013.254.4988.70T40.15227.8886.472.410.16112.903.5082.25

3.4AppearancequalityoftobaccoSeen from Table 4, tobacco was all orange yellow from each part in different treatments, leaf’s maturation degree was good, and index sum score was 8.5-9.0. Middle and lower leaves were loosed, while upper leaf was more loose. Lower leaf was slightly thin, with moderate chroma and oil; middle leaf was moderately thick, with moderate chroma and oil; upper leaf was slightly thick, with strong chroma and oil. Seen from index sum score of appearance quality, appearance quality of lower leaf in T2-T4treatments was slightly bad except T1treatment, but the index sum score of each treatment was similar (7.75-7.90); index sum score of middle leaf in each treatment all exceeded 8.00 (8.06-8.23) and was similar; appearance quality index sum score of upper leaf in each treatment was 7.57-7.85, with little difference. It illustrated that appearance difference of leaf from the same part in different treatments was little, while appearance quality of leaf from different parts in the same treatment had certain difference.

Table4AppearancequalityofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

TreatmentsTobaccogradeColorMaturityLeafstructureBodyOilColorintensityIndexscoresT1X2F9.09.08.56.54.55.57.90T29.09.08.56.04.55.07.80T39.09.08.56.04.55.07.80T49.09.08.56.04.05.07.75T1C3F9.08.59.09.06.04.58.22T29.08.58.59.06.54.58.19T39.08.58.59.06.55.08.23T48.59.08.58.56.04.58.06T1B2F8.58.57.56.06.56.57.69T28.58.57.06.06.56.57.62T38.58.57.06.06.06.57.57T49.08.57.56.56.06.57.85

3.5ConventionalchemicalcomponentsoftobaccoSeen from Table 5, comprehensive index score of tobacco from each part in different treatments was 0.39-0.73. According to chemical component comprehensive index of tobacco (I), coordination of conventional chemical component of tobacco from each part in different treatments was divided into five grades[10]. Comprehensive index score sequence of lower leaf was T2>T3=T4>T1, and comprehensive index score of T2treatment was 0.59, which was the highest, and coordination of each chemical component reached moderate level; comprehensive index scores of T3and T4treatments were both 0.50, and coordination of chemical components was lower; comprehensive index score of T1treatment was 0.39, which was low. Comprehensive index score sequence of middle leaf was T3>T2>T4>T1. Comprehensive index score of T3treatment was 0.71, which was the highest, and coordination of chemical components was in higher level. Comprehensive index score of T2treatment was 0.53, which was moderate, while comprehensive index scores of T1and T4treatments were respectively 0.45 and 0.50, which was lower. Comprehensive index score sequence of upper leaf was T1=T3>T4>T2, and they were respectively 0.73, 0.73 and 0.66 in T1, T3and T4treatments, and coordination of chemical components was higher; comprehensive index score of T2treatment was 0.58, which was moderate. Seen from comprehensive index of conventional chemical components of tobacco, different sowing and transplanting time affected whole coordination of tobacco chemical components, and the impact on middle and lower leaves was obvious. Coordination of conventional chemical components of lower leaf in T2treatment was better, and comprehensive index was 0.59, which was in moderate level; coordination of chemical components of middle and upper leaves was better in T3treatment, and comprehensive index scores were respectively 0.71 and 0.73, which was in higher level.

Table5ComprehensiveindexofconventionalchemicalcomponentsofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

TreatmentsTobaccogradeX2FC3FB2FT10.390.450.73T20.590.530.58T30.500.710.73T40.500.500.66

3.6SensorysmokingevaluationqualityoftobaccoSeen from Table 6, the index sum score of lower leaf in T1treatment was 6.63, which was the highest, and smoke feature showed as better aroma quality, sufficient aroma quantity, stronger concentration, lighter offensive odor and better aftertaste, followed by T2treatment (6.32); index sum scores of T3and T4treatments were both 6.13, which was the lowest. Index sum score of middle leaf in T3treatment was 6.63, which was the highest, and smoke features showed as better aroma quality, sufficient aroma quantity, stronger concentration, lighter offensive odor, smaller irritancy and better aftertaste, followed by T4treatment (6.55). Index sum score of upper leaf in T3treatment was 6.73, which was the highest, and smoke characteristics showed as soft and delicate aroma, sufficient aroma quantity, lighter offensive odor, strong concentration, slight irritancy and better aftertaste. Therefore, comprehensive sensory smoke evaluation result showed that sensory quality of lower leaf in T1treatment was better, while sensory quality of middle and upper leaves was better in T3treatment.

3.7EconomictraitsoftobaccoineachtreatmentSeen from Table 7, ratio of high-grade tobacco, ratio of moderate-high-grade tobacco, yield, single-leaf weight, average price and production value of tobacco with different sowing and transplanting time were respectively 53.96%, 75.03%, 167.30 kg/667 m2, 13.60 g, 25.53 yuan/kg and 4 271.17 yuan/667 m2in T3treatment, which was the highest, followed by T2treatment, and they were respectively 52.37%, 74.23%, 163.20 kg/667 m2, 13.10 g, 25.12 yuan/kg and 4 099.58 yuan/667 m2, and each economic index in T1treatment was worse. It illustrated that T3treatment (sown on February 14 and transplanted on April 10) could make tobacco obtain better economic benefit.

Table6SmokingqualityofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

scores

Table7EconomictraitsofYunyan105withdifferentsowingandtransplantingtime

TreatmentsRatioofhighgradeleaves∥%Ratioofmid-highgradeleaves∥%Yield∥kg/667m2Singleleafweight∥gAveragepriceyuan/kgProductionvalueyuan/667m2T150.4372.49161.1012.5023.723821.29T252.3774.23163.2013.1025.124099.58T353.9675.03167.3013.6025.534271.17T451.1171.77158.7012.8024.843942.11

4 Conclusions and discussions

The research result showed that it was suitable to sow Yunyan 105 on February 4-14 and transplant on April 1-10 in Xuanwei City. Different sowing and transplanting time affected whole growth period of tobacco at different degrees. With the sowing and transplanting time postponed, growth period of tobacco gradually delayed, but the delaying time gradually shortened, causing that growth period in the field also shortened. It was similar to research result of Yao Xianhongetal.[16-17].

Research results displayed that single-leaf area from each part in different treatments had significant difference in each growth period (P<0.05), while plant height had insignificant difference (P>0.05). Tobacco growth was the best in T2and T3treatments. It was similar to research result of Wang Dingbinetal.[18-19], and illustrated that earlier or later sowing and transplanting could cause adverse influence on field tobacco growth.

The research results of tobacco physical properties, conventional chemical components and sensory smoking evaluation quality displayed that appearance quality of tobacco from the same part in different treatments was equivalent. In each treatment, physical features, coordination of conventional chemical components and sensory smoking evaluation quality of middle and upper leaves in T3treatment (sown on February 14 and transplanted on April 10) were better, and the economic benefit of the treatment was obvious. It illustrated that the most suitable sowing and transplanting time made that physical properties, internal quality and economic benefit of tobacco could be sufficiently embodied.

The research results showed that ratio of middle-high-grade tobacco, yield, output, and single-leaf weight all showed the trend of rising firstly and then declining with the sowing and transplanting time postponed, which was consistent with research result of Hu Zhongshengetal.[20-21]. When sowing and transplanting time was early, temperature was lower, which could make that growth and development in tobacco seedling period and field period were inhibited, causing tobacco yield and quality decline. When sowing and transplanting time was later, tobacco may suffer high temperature stress in prior and middle periods of filed growth, making tobacco seedling grow too quickly and affecting dry matter accumulation of tobacco. In latter period of growth, tobacco could not normally mellow and become yellow, finally causing economic benefit of tobacco decline. It was consistent with research result of Kong Dejunetal.[22-23].

[1] LU YH. Research advance in effects of ecological conditions on tobacco leave quality[J].Chinese Tobacco Science,2007,28(3):43-46.(in Chinese).

[2] WANG GH, GUAN CY, CHEN SY. Studies on ecological characters of rape[J].Acta Agriculturae Universitis Jiangxiensis,2001,23(2):174-177.(in Chinese).

[3] LI H. Effect of transplanting period on the growth, yield and quality of flue-cured tobacco.[J].He’nan Agriculture,2002,13(11):15-18.(in Chinese).

[4] ZU CL, XU JN, YIN FS,etal. Study on the effects of transplanting date on flue-cured tobacco in Southern Anhui[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2004,32(5):969-970.(in Chinese).

[5] HUANG TY, YANG SG, ZHOU BY. Forecast for tobacco transplanting date in the Northern Fujian Province[J].Journal of Guangxi Meteorology,2010,3(1):57-59.(in Chinese).

[6] FAN CY, ZHAN L, YANG HC,etal. Effect of different sowing date on tobacco yield and quality in Southern Hunan Province[J].Crop Research,2013,27(6):592-596.(in Chinese).

[7] TAN ZD, GUO HY, CHEN JJ,etal. Effects of sowing date on tobacco yield and quality[J].Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2012,20(5):556-560.(in Chinese).

[8] YANG Y, ZHU LS, ZHU JX,etal. Influence of transplanting period on growth and quality of flue-cured tobacco[J].Crop Research,2011,25(2):179-183.(in Chinese).

[9] TIAN F, CHEN QF, SHAN HT,etal. Effects of transplantation date on agronomic properties, economic characters and usability of upper leaf of flue cured tobacco[J].Crop Research,2010,24(3):184-191.(in Chinese).

[10] WANG YT, XIE JP, LI ZH. Chinese tobacco planting area[M].Beijing: Science Press, 2010.(in Chinese).

[11] CAI XJ, WANG XM, YIN QS. Preliminary study on quantitative analysis of flue-cured tobacco appearance quality indices[J].Tobacco Science & Technology,2004(6):37-39.(in Chinese).

[12] LI B, LIU CK, YAN QF,etal. Analysis of chemical components of flue-cured tobacco in Enshi tobacco-growing areas of Hubei Province[J].Acta Agriculturae Jiangxi,2010,22(5):12-14.(in Chinese).

[13] LUO H, DENG XH, ZHANG GL,etal. Characteristics of chemical components and usability of flue-cured tobacco leaves grown in main tobacco-producing counties of Shaoyang City[J].Journal of Hunan Agricultural University,2009,35(6):623-627.(in Chinese).

[14] LI XT, YA P, HE YS,etal. Characteristics and spatial distribution of chemical components in flue-cured tobacco leaves from Lincang tobacco growing areas in Yunnan[J].Tobacco Science & Technology,2013(1):53-57.(in Chinese).

[15] JIANG SP, ZHANG ZY, ZHENG SF,etal. Effect of different harvesting maturity on tobacco quality with optimized leaf structure[J].Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences,2013,42(11):40-45.(in Chinese).

[16] YAO XH, ZHANG GC, WANG QM,etal. Study on the best transplanting stage of Honghua Dajinyuan in high altitude area[J].Guizhou Agricultural Sciences,2012,40(3):107-109.(in Chinese).

[17] CHEN AG, DAI PG, CHEN ZY,etal. Study on the suitable transplanting period for the fragrant tobacco leaf of variety Honghuadajinyuan[J].Straits Science,2009(12):37-40.(in Chinese).

[18] WANG DB, YANG L, LI HX. Preliminary test of best transplanting period optimization on tobacco in different ecological regions[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2008,36(28):12290-12293.(in Chinese).

[19] XU Q, ZHOU ZQ, WU CB. Influences on the growth, yield and quality by the different transplanting times of cigarette seedlings[J].Fujian Science & Technology of Tropical Crops,2003,28(3):8-10.(in Chinese).

[20] HU ZS, YANG CJ, SHI X,etal. Comparison on meteorological conditions of growth periods,yield and quality of flue-cured tobacco in different transplanting dates[J].Journal of Meteorology and Environment,2012,28(2):66-70.(in Chinese).

[21] WANG X, SHEN HH, LI CY,etal. Study on suitable seeding and transplanting time of flue-cured tobacco variety K346[J].Chinese Tobacco Science,2001(3):42-44.(in Chinese).

[22] KONG DJ, PAN WJ, XIONG J,etal. Effects of transplanting period on tobacco yield and quality in high-altitude region[J].Guizhou Agricultural Sciences,2012,40(12):61-65.(in Chinese).

[23] MA BN, XIONG J. Study on the relationship between tobacco leaf quality and tobacco leaf quality in low latitude and high altitude area[J].Modern Agricultural Sciences and Technology,2008(24):161-162.(in Chinese).


登录APP查看全文