A review and research on comprehensive characterization of microscopic shale gas reservoir space

2019-01-13 07:44:38YuruYangXiaohenLiuHuiZhangGangyiZhaiJiaodongZhangZhifangHuShujingBaoCongZhangXianghuaWangXiaoYangZhengzhuangLiuTingXieJuanChenLiyuFangLijuanQin
China Geology 2019年4期

Yu-ru Yang , Xiao-hen Liu , Hui Zhang, Gang-yi Zhai , Jiao-dong Zhang , Zhi-fang Hu , Shu-jing Bao , Cong Zhang , Xiang-hua Wang , Xiao Yang, Zheng-zhuang Liu , Ting Xie , Juan Chen , Liyu Fang , Li-juan Qin

a Oil and Gas Survey, China Geological Survey, Beijing 100083, China

b Unconventional Petroleum Geology Laboratory of Oil and Gas Survey, Ministry of Natural Resources, China Geological Survey, Beijing 100094, China

c SGS-CSTC Standards Technical Services Co., Ltd., Beijing 100176, China

d School of Energy Resources, China University of Geosciences (Beijing), Beijing 100083, China

ABSTRACT

In this paper, substantial domestic and foreign research results of microscopic shale reservoir space were systemically reviewed, the research history consisting of simple observation and qualitative classification,quantitative research, the combination of qualitative and quantitative research successively as well as the characteristics of each research stage were summarized. In addition, the current problems existing in the characterization methods of shale reservoir space were also analyzed. Furthermore, based on massive actual detection of typical core samples obtained from more than 50 global shale gas wells and relevant practical experience, a comprehensive characterization method of combining qualitative with the semiquantitative characterization was put forward. In detail, the indicators of the qualitative characterization include pore combination type and organic-matter microscopic morphology type, while the core elements of the semi-quantitative characterization include the percentage of the organic-matter area and the plane porosity of the pores of different types. Based on the reference of the naming and classification of rocks,the three-end-member diagram method was used to characterize microscopic shale reservoir space. This is achieved by plotting the three end-member diagram of 3 kinds of first-order critical reservoir spaces, i.e.,organic-matter pores, matrix pores, and micro-fractures, in order to intuitively present the features of the microscopic pore combination. Meanwhile, statistic histograms of organic-matter microscopic morphology type and the plane porosity of different types of pores were adopted to characterize the development degree of second-order pores quantitatively. By this comprehensive characterization method, the importance of both pore combination and the microscopic morphology of organic matter were emphasized, revealing the control of organic-matter microscopic morphology over the organic-matter pores. What is more, high-resolution FE-SEM was adopted to obtain semi-quantitative statistics results. In this way, the features of pore development and pore combination were quantified, not only reflecting the types and storage capacity of the microscopic shale reservoir space, but also presenting the hydrocarbongenerating potential of organic matter in shale. Therefore, the results of this research are capable of providing in-depth microscopic information for the assessment and exploration and development of shale gas resources.

Keywords:

Shale

Shale gas

Reservoir space

Research status

Types of pore combinations

Oil-gas exploration engineering

Longmaxi Formation

Niutitang Formation

Shahejie Formation

Yanchang Formation

China

USA

1. Introduction

Shale gas, the natural gas reserved in organic-rich shale, is a relatively clean and efficient energy and has become an essential unconventional natural gas resource presently. In the United States, high attention was paid to, and numerous Research and Development (R&D) was conducted on shale gas in the 1970s, commercial exploitation became available in the late 1990s, and then autarky of shale gas was gained and the global energy resource pattern was changed accordingly soon (Dong DZ et al., 2012; Zou CN et al., 2017). China began to assess geological conditions of Chinese shale gas and carried out pilot tests in R&D of shale gas in 2005 based on the experience of the US. So far, the industrial capacity of shale gas has been formed in Sichuan Basin and large-scale fundamental survey and assessment have been conducted in the surrounding areas of Sichuan Basin (Dong DZ et al.,2016; Ma YS et al., 2018). In recent years, owing to efficient development in shale gas R&D, the research on the microscopic structure of shale reservoirs has been greatly promoted. As the highlighted progress, the research was shifted from the mm/μm scale into the nanometer scale(Loucks RG et al., 2009, 2012).

The widely developed micro/nano pores in shale are not only the occurrence and accumulation space of shale gas in reservoirs but also the seepage channels during shale gas development. Besides, the aperture and fissure structure of the pores not only affect the occurrence state of the gas in the pores but also greatly influence the interaction between the pores and gas/fluid molecules. Furthermore, the development degree of the pores directly restricts the seepage and exploitation of shale gas (Loucks RG et al., 2012; Curtis JB et al., 2002). With the advancement of research and understanding of shale, it has been gradually realized that micro-nano pores are also related to the hydrocarbongenerating potential of the shale (Loucks RG et al., 2014).Therefore, the research on microscopic shale reservoir space also affects the formation theory, resource evaluation, and exploration and development of shale gas.

As the dominant power, China boasts of the recoverable shale gas resource of nearly 10×1012-25×1012m3(Zou CN et al., 2017) and various types of shale gas reservoirs, including the Lower Paleozoic marine-facies shale in Sichuan Basin,more ancient Sinian-Cambrian marine-facies shale reservoirs in west Hubei, north Yunnan and Guizhou, and west Hunan etc., Late Paleozoic and Mesozoic transitional-facies shale reservoirs in Yangtze region, and continental-facies shale reservoirs in Erdos Basin, Bohai Bay Basin, and Songliiao Basin (Dong DZ et al., 2016; Ma YS et al., 2018; Li HH et al.,2017; Chen XH et al., 2018; Song T et al., 2017; Jiang CF et al., 2013). Meanwhile, marine-facies shale gas has been recovered industrially in Sichuan Basin, and assessment and exploration at different degree have been made for different types of shale reservoirs in other areas. Since shale gas is formed in an unconventional and continuous way, the extent to which reservoirs are understood restricts the assessment of the resource and exploration and development of shale gas and the assessment of the final economic recoverability.Meanwhile, the characterization of nanopore structures,development law of the pores, and the effect of pore development on shale oil and gas aggregation have gradually become critical issues and difficulties in shale reservoir research. In this paper, a comprehensive characterization method on shale gas reservoir space was put forward aiming at the hot spots of current research and the actual demand for shale gas exploration and development in China. For this purpose, previous research results were reviewed and collated.Furthermore, numerous actual detection results on microscopic reservoir space of different types of shale reservoirs were obtained with typical core samples of more than 50 global shale gas wells. The comprehensive characterization method emphasized the importance of pore combination and microscopic morphology of organic matter in the structure research of nanopores is shale and the facies significance in the understanding of shale formation theory.The method revealed the features of the microscopic structure of shale reservoirs from the aspects of genetic type micro/nano pores, occurrence means of pores, and pore combination types. Furthermore, it combined intuitive qualitative analysis and semi-quantitative statistics. It is expected to offer new ideas to current and future research in shale reservoirs.

2. Research progress and status of microscopic shale reservoir space

In 2007, Loucks RG (2009) proved that micro/nano pores dominate shale reservoir space during his research on shale Barnett for the first time. Then during the same period, other scholars validated that a vast majority of nm-scale pores developed in organic-matter particles in organic-rich shale in Barnett, Woodford, Horn River, and Marcellus Formation,and concluded that pore system in organic-rich shale was dominated by organic-matter pores (Roger MS et al., 2011;Gareth RC et al., 2012; Loucks RG et al., 2014). In 2011, Zou CN et al. (2011) discovered and described organic-matter micro-nano pores in shale in South China for the first time and further classified shale reservoir spaces. It can be concluded that the research methods of the microstructure of shale gas reservoirs is transformed from observation and description into systematic classification and further to the combination of qualitative and quantitative analysis throughout the research history. This has promoted the application of more microscopic information into the assessmenst of both resource potential and exploration &development potential of shale gas.

2.1. Research methods and means

In the early period of shale gas exploration and development, conventional polarizing microscopes and conventional scanning electron microscopes (SEM) were customarily applied to qualitative description of the development features of pore throats in unconventional dense reservoirs globally. With the advancements of both research and electron microscopy technology, field emission scanning electron microscopes (FE-SEM) with higher resolution are universally applied to shale reservoir characterization (Loucks RG et al., 2012; Shuai Q et al., 2012; Zhang PP et al., 2014).It can now be concluded based on the research results of recent years that the methods for detecting shale microscopic pores include qualitative observation and quantitative testing.The qualitative observation mainly aims to observe microareas, intuitively characterize pore structure and morphology on the micro-nano scale, and obtain fine-grained images of pore structures with high-resolution equipment such as FESEM, focused ion beam scanning electron microscope (FIBSEM) and atomic force microscope (AFM). The quantitative testing is designed to quantitatively analyze the porosity,aperture distribution, and specific surface area of the shale reservoirs by adopting the techniques including Mercury Injection Capillary Pressure (MICP, for 100-950 μm pores),low-pressure N2 adsorption (for 0.35-200 nm pores), and He porosimetry.

Currently, high-resolution FE-SEM combined with argonion polishing technology used in preparing polished shale samples has become a dominant and gradually mature technology in the research on the pore types, shapes, sizes and distribution of shale pores.

2.2. Progress and status

2.2.1. Qualitative observation and classification

Before 2007, high-resolution SEM had not been deeply applied to the research on shale reservoirs. Only optical microscopes were used to observe samples on the slice scale or ordinary SEM was adopted to observe the samples in low magnification, thus failing to develop the concept of micronano pore structures of the shale.

In 2007, Loucks RG et al. (2009) put forth the concept of organic-matter nanopore (i.e. organoporosity) for the first time. Furthermore, by qualitatively observing the microscopic pore types in typical shale in the United States such as Barnett, Woodford, Haynesville, and Marcellus, they determined 6 types of shale pores, i.e. pores between the flocs of clay minerals, organic-matter pores, pore inside faecal pellets, pores inside fossil clasts, pores inside particles, and micro-fracture, thus promoting the understanding and initial classification of microscopic pores in shale. In China, the research on the structure of shale micro-nano pores started relatively later. Liu SG et al. (2011) and Nie HK et al. (2011)conducted initial research and simple description of the shale reservoirs in Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin by the means used to investigate conventional oil and gas reservoirs.Up to 2011, Zou CN et al. (2011) detected the micro/nano pores in shale in China the first time. Meanwhile, some scholars tried to further investigate organic-matter pores by combining the argon-ion polishing technique and SEM (Jiao SJ et al., 2012).

With the breakthrough made in exploration and development of marine-facies shale gas in Sichuan Basin, a large number of scholars represented by Chen SB et al.(2012), Wang YM et al. (2012), and Yu BS (2013) focused on in-depth description of pore types of typical shale in Longmaxi Formation of Sichuan Basin in China, and classified shale pores based on their respective views. Among them, Yu BS (2013) upon learning the research results of microscopic shale structure in the United States, proposed a comprehensive occurrence-structure classification scheme of shale pores in 2013, which was widely recognized. Since 2014, many scholars in China (Wang XZ et al., 2015; Jiao SJ et al., 2015; Guo XS et al., 2014; Jiang ZX et al., 2014; Wang YM et al., 2014; Zhang H et al., 2015 ; Pang HQ et al., 2017;Cai X et al., 2016) has extensively investigated structures of micro/nano pores dominated by organic-matter pores. During this stage, the scholars including Jiao SJ et al. (2015), Wang YM et al. (2014), Zhang H et al. (2015), Guo XS et al. (2014),and Pang HQ et al. (2017) broke through the appearance description, initiated and gradually enhanced the research on the genesis of organic-matter pores based on occurrence classification. Based on this, they carried out more scientific assessment and classification of micro/nano reservoir space of shale gas. Meanwhile, the scholars of the United States represented by Loucks and Reed further investigated the organic-matter microscopic morphologies and the development features of organic-matter pores in shale with high-resolution FE-SEM. Then they discussed the hydrocarbon-generating potential and storage capacity of the shale by focusing on the organic-matter microscopic morphologies and the development features of organic-matter pores on nano scale (Loucks RG et al., 2014). This further advanced the understanding of shale microscopic field and promoted the application of microscopic research results.Furthermore, it further revealed the importance of organic matter and organic-matter pores in the research on shale reservoir.

2.2.2. Combination of qualitative and quantitative research

With gradual investigation and exploration and evaluation of shale gas in China, many scholars conducted quantitative research on pore structure based on pore occurrence and qualitative classification by means of experiments such as mercury injection pressure, liquid nitrogen adsorption, and CO2adsorption. For instance, Jiang ZX et al. (2016), Chen SR et al., (2015), Pang HQ et al. (2017), Zhao DF et al. (2018),Liu YW et al. (2018), and Yang WX et al. (2018) conducted quantitative assessment of pore diameter, specific surface area, and pore volume of micro/nano pores in shale to different extent. However, the quantitative research conducted by these scholars were all focused on quantitative characterization of whole core media, thus failing to discriminate between organic-matter pores and matrix mineral pores. Most notably, it lacks quantitative statistics and structure features description of organic-matter pores. During this stage, some scholars initially adopted the concept of plane porosity of organic-matter pores. For example, Nie HK et al.(2014) and Gen YK et al. (2017) respectively made statistics of the plane porosity of different types of micro/nano pores by point-number recording method; Wang YM et al. (2014) and Sun YS et al. (2016) managed to use a mathematic model and image processing software to make statistics and calculation for different types of pores quantitatively. In 2018, Bai MG et al. (2018) and Zhao DF et al. (2018)managed to quantitatively research the micro/nano pores in organic-rich shale of Longmaxi Formation in South China by processing core images with digital image processing software. They obtained the parameters such as organic-matter plane porosity, pore number developing in per unit area of organic matter, and aperture interval distribution of organic-matter pores. This remedied the shortcomings of conventional means such as mercury injection pressure and liquid nitrogen adsorption,deepened the research on development features of micro-nano pores in shale gas reservoirs, and further revealed the development features of micro-nano pores.

With the application of high-resolution detection instruments and the advancement of detection technologies,the analysis scale is decreased further. Therefore, the complexity of the microscopic features of shale reservoirs,especially the difference in the development of organic-matter pores, can be revealed in a more explicit manner. The difference in the development directly affects shale reservoir quality, and furthermore the development mechanism and the control factors of organic-matter pores directly affect the formation theory and resource assessment of shale gas, thus driving the researchers to think in a more in-depth way.

3. Exploration of comprehensive characterization methods of microscopic shale reservoir space

As fine-grained sedimentary rock, shale acts as both hydrocarbon source rock and the reservoirs for shale gas.Therefore, it is unpractical to study the gas reservoir space in the same way as conventional reservoirs.

Some conclusions are determined in this paper based on massive detection practices. The concepts on pore structure that are customarily used for conventional reservoirs and also have been applied to the description of shale reservoir space many years ago, such as intergranular pores and intragranular pores, are not suitable for the characterization of shale reservoir pores. Unlike conventional reservoirs research focusing on framework grains, the research on shale reservoir shall concentrate on the development features of organicmatter pores. The organic matter occurring in shale is not only microscopic organic hydrocarbon-generating ingredient but also the occurrence carrier of shale gas. As revealed by highresolution detection, the organic matter features complex microscopic occurrence morphology and the organic-matter pores tend to concentrate on the organic matter with a specific type of microscopic morphology. Therefore, the microscopic occurrence morphology of organic matter is a key factor affecting and controlling pore development, and the research on organic microscopic occurrence morphology shall be the first priority. In addition, it is common that the reservoirs with a high content of organic (TOC) or high porosity feature low gas content. This tends to be hard to explain with conventional analysis means. Also, quantitative detection of micro-fractures in shale reservoirs is absent in most researches. However, for dense shale reservoirs with lowultra-low permeability, micro-fractures expose a significant impact on the permeability and further affect the exploration assessment and subsequent development. Concern for these problems tends to be absent or insufficient in previous researches. According to massive actual detection, these problems are easy to be explained with the current highresolution detection means and on a micro-nano scale. The key is how to characterize the development features of microscopic pores in shale reservoirs as accurate and intuitive as possible. This is a significant and meaningful topic.

Therefore, according to substantial measured and statistical results achieved from more than 500 core samples that were collected from more than 50 shale gas wells in two regions of the United States and the shale in China including marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin,transitional-facies shale of the Carboniferous-the Permian of the Later Paleozoic in Lower Yangtze Region and Northern South China, continental-facies shale of the Mesozoic in Erdos Basin and Songliao Basin as well as the Cenozoic in Bohai Bay Basin, it is concluded in this paper that shale reservoirs are mainly dominated by 2 first-order pores (i.e.,organic-matter pores and matrix pores). The matrix pores are divided into different secondary-order pores according to the components and diagenesis such as inter-crystal pores (joints),and interlayer pores of clay minerals associated with recrystallization of clay minerals, inter-crystal pores associated with authigenic siliceous matter, contraction joint and residual formed owing to diagenesis. Different types of shale produce different pore combination, which is subject to factors such as organic-matter content, organic-matter microscopic morphology, rock components, and diagenesis.Different pore combination enables each type of shale to be characterized by its distinct shale reservoir space, and thus constitutes the critical content of the characterization of shale reservoirs. Therefore, in this paper, based on the intuitive characterization of the microscopic pores in shale reservoirs and according to the actual application effects, it is proposed to comprehensively characterize the features of shale reservoirs by the means of combining qualitative and semiquantitative analysis with pore combination as the focus. This means to effectively integrate the development degree into the influencing factors (or genesis) of the pores based on intuitive presence of the features of microscopic pores in shale reservoirs, and manage to accurately and objectively reveal the hydrocarbon-generating potential and future potential of the shale, in order to provide more in-depth information for the assessment of exploration and development of shale gas.

Having considered the role of micro-fractures in shale, it is proposed to plot the three end-member diagram of the organic-matter pore, matrix pore, and micro-fracture with former two as main elements and the latter as supplementation. In this way, the primary characterization of shale reservoirs is formed. The conventional three endmember denomination method for sandstone (SY/T5368-2000 Rock Thin Section Appraisal Industry Standard, Petroleum and natural gas industry standard of the People’s Republic of China) is referred to in the characterization method proposed.For the parameter statistics of the secondary-order pores such as the plane porosity and its percentage, and the area percentage of the organic matter with different microscopic morphology, the statistics are obtained from the detection with high-resolution FE-SEM and displayed in histograms, in order to supplement the content of primary characterization of reservoir space. For the statistical approach, conventional ocular estimation or point-number recording statistics of plane porosity for clastic reservoirs universally used in China and abroad is referred to. Meanwhile, the semi-quantitative statistics of micro-fractures come from thin section examination.

3.1. Description of shale reservoir space types

According to the practice in global shale gas exploration& development, the identification of shale pore type constitutes an important part of reservoir research (Loucks RG et al., 2012; Zou CN et al., 2011; Yu BS, 2013; Ma YS et al., 2018). Presently, despite sufficient researches on shale pore type, there is no uniform research standard available in China and abroad, causing that the presentation forms of the research results vary much with different scholars. Based on actual detection for many years and substantial actual inspection results of the shale of different types, different ages, and different regions, it is concluded in this paper that the concepts of intergranular pore and intragranular pore that were previously used to describe shale are not suitable for the qualitative analysis and description of nanopores. The reason is that only a few of terrigenous clasts exist in shale and accordingly, there are no or very few intergranular pores or intragranular pores between or in terrigenous clasts. As revealed by actual detection, the pores developing in shale reservoirs mainly include organic-matter pores, inter-crystal pores (authigenic or related to recrystallization) of matrix minerals, diagenetic fractures, micro-fractures, and residual pores. The development degree and structure of the organicmatter pores vary with different morphologies of the organic matter. The matrix pores are formed under the control of rock components, sedimentary facies, and diagenetic manifestation. The micro-fractures in shale share similar development features with those in conventional reservoirs.Therefore, the semi-quantitative statistics of the microfractures are obtained with conventional thin sections by detection with optical microscopes, and here, it will not be repeated again. The focus of this paper is to discuss the organic-matter pores and matrix pores in shale.

3.1.1. Organic matter and organic-matter pores in shale

Organic-matter pores in shale refer to the pores that form due to the release of hydrocarbons as the organic matter matures; and as the important component in shale, organic matter acts as not only the hydrocarbon-generating subject but also the most important storage carrier of shale gas (Loucks RG et al., 2009, 2014; Fishman NS et al., 2013; Zou CN et al.,2017). As a result, organic-matter pores in shale reflect both the hydrocarbon-generating potential and the storage capacity of shale. Therefore, shale reservoir researches shall give priority to the research on organic-matter pores and consider the meticulous characterization of matrix mineral pores, in order to completely reveal the features of shale reservoirs and manage to reflect the economy of subsequent exploration as objectively and accurately as possible (Curtis ME et al., 2012;Milliken KL et al., 2013). According to the actual detection of the samples obtained from more than 50 wells, the most directive factor that controls the development of organicmatter pores is organic-matter occurrence morphology followed by the organic content (TOC), components of matrix mineral, and the organic-matter evolution phase. However, no regular evidence for the relation between the 3 secondary factors and the development of organic-matter pores was discovered in the detection of more than 50 wells.

3.1.1.1. Morphological features of organic matter in shale

As revealed by massive actual detection, whether in marine-facies shale, transitional-facies shale or in continentalfacies shale, the organic matter mainly features 3 occurrence morphologies, i.e. interstitial or interactive, organic-texture,banded or irregular cloddy shapes (Figs. 1a-h).

Generally, organic-texture organic matter and banded/irregularly cloddy organic matter are distributed between deposited clay-size clasts and are called“sedimentary organic matter” (Loucks RG et al., 2014). As biological clasts, organic-texture organic matter generally keeps the organic-texture morphology. According to relevant researches, banded/irregularly cloddy organic matter is the microsome polymer, colloidal matter, or bituminite matter that forms owing to degradation of deposited original organic materials. Subject to sedimentation and early burial and diagenesis, banded/irregularly cloddy organic matter generally shares the directional feature consistent with sedimentary clasts, and there are few or no authigenic minerals in its surrounding area, as shown in Figs. 1b, 1d-h.The interstitial/interactive organic matter features late filling and injection or differentiation. The organic matter filling in authigenic mineral crystals features the morphology that is consistent with the occurrence space, and the matrix minerals in contact with the organic matter possess a nearly completely automorphic boundary of authigenic crystals (as shown in Figs. 1a, 1c, 1h). Therefore, the organic matter of this morphology has the characteristics forming during the late diagenetic stage and high-evolution period of the organic matter. Loucks et al. called the authigenic minerals “lining” of organic matter (Loucks RG et al., 2014) and called organic matter existing therein “migrated organic matter ”. The interactive organic matter grows interactively with matrix minerals such as clay or siliceous matter. As a result,“granitoid texture” in magmatite forms, and the minerals along the boundary and in contact with the granitoid texture features semi-metamorphic or xenomorphic boundary, as shown in Fig. 1a. Such interactive organic matter is common especially in marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin. It is believed that interactive organic matter is the product of respective recrystallization and thermal evolution between the matrix minerals and the organic matter during the diagenetic period. Additionally, interactive organic matter also features the migration. Therefore, the interstitial organic matter and interactive organic matter are both equivalent to “migrated organic matter” (Loucks RG et al.,2014). As shown by the detection results of all the samples,large numbers of micro/nano pores extensively developed in interstitial/interactive organic matter; while in organic-texture and banded/cloddy organic matter, very few or no pores developed and only few contraction joints developed in the contact part between the organic matter and the matrix minerals (called inter-component gap by some scholars such as Zhang H et al., 2015, 2018). In this paper, meticulous detection and statistics of pore development feature are conducted for the organic matter of different microscopic morphologies.

Fig. 1. Different morphologies of organic matter in shale. a-Interstitial/interactive organic matter in marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin; b-banded organic matter in marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin; c-interstitial organic matter in transitional-facies shale of Gufeng Formation in Lower Yangtze Region; d-bioclastic-texture and banded organic matter in transitional-facies shale of Gufeng Formation, Lower Yangtze Region; e-irregularly cloddy, bioclastic-texture and interstitial organic matter in continental-facies shale of Yanchang formation, Erdos Basin; f-irregularly crumby, banded, and interstitial organic matter in continental-facies shale of Shahejie Formation, Bohai Bay Basin; g-interstitial, irregularly cloddy, and bioclastic-texture organic matter in marine-facies shale in Eagle Ford, the US; h-interstitial and irregularly cloddy organic matter in marine-facies shale in Barnett, the US.

Fig. 2. Organic matter of different microscopic morphologies and the development features of the pores in it. a-Interstitial organic matter of marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin and the pores in it; b-interactive organic matter of marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin and the pore in it; c, d-organic-texture organic matter in marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin,with no or very few pores developing; e-organic-texture organic matter and interstitial organic matter in transitional-facies shale of Gufeng Formation, Lower Yangtze Region, with no pore developing in the former and pores developing in the latter; f-organic-texture organic matter and interstitial organic matter in transitional-facies shale of the Mesozoic, northeast Sichuan, with no pore developing in the former and pores developing in the latter; g, h-interstitial organic matter and cloddy organic in continental-facies shale of Yanchang formation, Erdos Basin, with pores developing in the former and no pore developing in the latter; i-interstitial organic matter and irregularly cloddy organic in continental-facies shale of Shahejie Formation, Bohai Bay Basin, with pores developing in the former and no pore developing in the latter; j-interstitial organic matter and organic-texture organic matter in marine-facies shale in Eagle Ford in the US, with pores extremely developing in the former and no pore developing in the latter; k, l-interstitial organic matter and organic-texture organic matter in the Sinian marine-facies shale of Doushantuo Formation in Hubei and Hunan, with pores developing in the former and no pore developing in the latter.

3.1.1.2. Organic-matter pores in shale

As revealed from core detection, whether marine-facies shale in Eagle Ford and Barnett in the US, or the shale in China including the marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and its surrounding areas, the transitional-facies organic-rich shale of the Late Paleozoic in Lower Yangtze Region, the continental-facies organic-rich shale in the Mesozoic in Erdos Basin and in the Palaeogene Shahejie Formation in Bohai Bay Basin, the vast majority of organic-matter pores developed in interstitial/interactive organic matter. Besides, owing to different eras (new and old), sedimentary conditions (marine facies, continental facies, etc.), and diagenetic conditions (compaction,diagenetic stage, wind oxidation, etc.), interstitial/interactive organic matter features different development degree of pores and different aperture, and generally bears spongy or bubblelike pore structure (Figs. 2a, 2b, 2e-g, 2i-k); while for the organic-texture organic matter and banded/irregularly cloddy organic matter, few of even no pores developed (Figs. 2c-f,2h, 2j, 2l), and most of the organic matter of this morphology features the development of contraction joints (Figs. 2d-f, 2l).

According to the detection with high-resolution FE-SEM,the aperture of the organic-matter pores with spongy or bubble-like structures is generally 10-300 nm. In the shale of Longmaxi Formation in China, the organic-matter pores developing in interstitial/interactive organic matter are generally 10-150 nm in equivalent spherical diameters.Among them, the ones developing in interstitial organic matter feature spongy structure with a general aperture of 10-150 nm; while the ones developing in interactive organic matter feature bubble-like structure with the general aperture of 30-300 nm. In Barnett shale in the US, the organic-matter pores developing in interstitial organic matter universally feature bubble-like structure with the aperture of 10-300 nm.In the most ancient shale gas reservoir in the world, i.e. the organic-rich shale of the Sinian Doushantuo Formation in west Hubei, China, spongy pores developed in interstitial organic matter with aperture sizes less than 30 nm.

3.1.2. Matrix minerals and matrix pores

The pores of another type in shale are those developing in matrix minerals. Most scholars divide them into intergranular pores, intragranular pores, micro-fractures, etc. However,according to massive actual detection, it is believed that the shale is mainly composed of clay mineral and felsic matrix with a grain size of less than 0.03 mm (less than 0.005 mm generally). No normal intergranular pores and intragranular pores can be detected by conventional optical microscopes.Even with the mode Inlensduo of secondary electrons of FESEM, only the particle texture of the clasts can be discovered.For most shale with high-degree diagenesis and intense recrystallization and the shale with authigenic minerals developing universally, it is hard to present intergranular pores indeed. Therefore, based on actual detection with FESEM, the pores in matrix minerals are divided into intercrystal (or intra-crystal) pores (mainly including those in authigenic minerals), interlayer pores (joints) among lamellar clay minerals, intragranular pores (the corroded pores in a small number of particles such as the aggregate consisting of feldspar and carbonate minerals), diagenetic contraction joints, and residual pores, as shown in Figs. 3a-j. It is argued that the development degree and structural features of the pores in matrix minerals are controlled or affected by sedimentary and diagenetic conditions. As revealed from the results obtained from actual detection of a large number of shale samples in China and the US, the matrix pores in marine-facies shale mainly include inter- (intra-) crystal pores of authigenic quartz (silicon) or inter- (intra-) crystal pores of micritic carbonate minerals. For example, in the shale of Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin in China, matrix pores are mainly inter- (intra-) crystal pores of authigenic quartz.Furthermore, the matrix mineral pores in transitional-facies or continental-facies shale mainly include inter-crystal pores/joints of lamellar clay minerals or inter- (intra-) crystal pores of micritic carbonate minerals followed by diagenetic contraction joint and residual pores, and the inter- (or intra-)crystal pores of authigenic quartz are the scarcest. Generally speaking, the aperture of the inter- (or intra-) crystal pores of authigenic quartz and carbonate minerals is smaller and generally 10-50 nm according to the detection with FE-SEM;the aperture of the interlayer pores/joints of lamellar clay minerals is usually greater than 50 nm while the aperture of the residual pores is much larger and usually 100-1000 nm.

In addition, few intergranular or intragranular pores are visible in some authigenic minerals, for instance, inter-(intra-)particle of pyrite, rutile, and apatite. However, these pores can be ignored since only a tiny number developed and the content of hosted minerals such as rutile and apatite is low.

3.2. Features of pore combination in shale and comprehensive characterization

In this paper, a total of more than 10000 images of the structure of micro/nano pores in various kinds of shale reservoirs were obtained from FE-SEM detection of all the samples. They are all processed in terms of qualitative classification of pores, semi-quantitative statistics of plane porosity, and semi-quantitative statistics of the organic matter with different microscopic morphologies, in order to fully reflect the development degree, structural feature, and influencing factors of the pores in various kinds of shale reservoirs. As revealed by the detection and statistical results,the shale of different types, eras, regions, and components feature quite different types, distribution, and texture of the pores. These differences in pores are generally reflected by the difference in pore combination and pore development degree, which constitute the core content for the characterization of shale reservoirs. The distribution and development degree of organic-matter pores is subject to the microscopic occurrence morphology of the organic matter,while the types of the matrix pores are controlled by the matrix composition.

3.2.1. Features of microscopic pore combination in shale

As indicated by the statistical results, the universal and typical combinations of the microscopic pores in shale include“organic-matter pore+authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+micro-fracture” and “authigenic (recrystallization)matrix mineral pore+organic-matter pore+micro-fracture” or“authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+residual pore+organic-matter pore”. Among these combinations, the organic-matter pore is the main type in the first one, and the matrix mineral pore is the main type in the latter two ones.

Details of the combinations are shown in Table 1 and Figs. 4a-i.

Table 1. Features in microscopic pore combinations in different types of shale reservoirs.

The microscopic pores in various kinds of shale are described as follows. As for marine-facies shale reservoirs,the typical pore combination is “organic-matter pore +authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+microfracture”. For instance, in both the shale of the Early Paleozoic Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and its surrounding areas in China (Fig. 4a) and the Carboniferous-Permian shale in the US (Fig. 4i), the micro/nano pore storage space of shale gas is dominated by organic-matter pores.Furthermore, nearly all of the organic-matter pores developed in interstitial (or interactive) organic matter and a small number of inter- (intra-) pores of authigenic minerals are present. In the marine-facies shale reservoirs of Longmaxi Formation in China, the matrix mineral pores mainly include inter- (intra-) crystal pores of authigenic quartz (siliceous matter); while in the marine-facies shale in the US, the matrix mineral pores mainly include inter- (intra-) crystal pores of carbonate minerals. As for the continental-facies shale reservoirs, the typical pore combinations include “authigenic(recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+organic-matter pore+micro-fracture ” and “authigenic (recrystallization)matrix mineral pore+organic-matter pore+residual pore”, fully reflecting the extensive development of matrix mineral pores and relatively weak diagenetic compaction. For example, in the shale of Shahejie Formation in Bohai Bay Basin (Fig. 4h)and the shale of Yanchang Formation in Erdos Basin (Fig.4g), the reservoir space combinations dominated by organicmatter pores are present in individual horizons owing to the high content of organic matter. In such continental-facies shale, the development range of organic-matter pores is also restricted by the distribution of interstitial organic matter. As for the transitional-facies shale, the combination “organicmatter pore+authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+micro-fracture” developed, and the combination“authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+organicmatter pore+micro-fracture” or the combination “authigenic(recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+residual pore+organicmatter pore” is also commonly present. Such transitionalfacies shale features massive organic-texture organic matter(also known as a morphological component in organic petrology). However, the development degree of the organicmatter pores is still restricted by the distribution of interstitial organic matter, such as the most Carboniferous-Permian shale in China (as shown in Figs. 4b, 4c, 4f). For organic-texture organic matter, only a small number of weak pores developed in them. Therefore, it can also be indicated from substantial actual detection results that organic-texture organic matter makes no or few contributions to hydrocarbon generation,although it can increase the TOC of shale. In addition, in the ancient Cambrian and Sinian shale reservoirs in China, the typical combination is “authigenic (recrystallization) matrix mineral pore+organic-matter pore+micro-fracture”. Compared with the shale reservoirs of Longmaxi Formation, such shale reservoirs feature similar structure and combination, but are more affected by organic content (Figs. 4d, 4e).

Fig. 4. Types of microscopic pore combinations in shale of different eras, different types and in different regions. a-Longmaxi shale: “organicmatter pore + inter- (intra-) crystal pore of authigenic quartz” combination; b-transitional-facies shale of the Permian in Lower Yangtze Region:“organic-matter pore + inter- (intra-) crystal pore of authigenic quartz” combination; c-transitional-facies shale of the Permian in Lower Yangtze Region: “matrix pore + organic-matter pore” combination; d-marine-facies shale of Niutitang Formation in Yunnan, Guizhou and Guangxi: “organic-matter pore + matrix pore” combination; e-marine-facies shale of Doushantuo Formation in Hubei and Hunan: “organicmatter pore + matrix pore” combination; f-transitional-facies shale of the Mesozoic in southeast Sichuan: “matrix pores + very few of organicmatter pores” combination; g-continental-facies shale of Yanchang Formation in Erdos Basin: “organic-matter pore + matrix pore(intercrystal)” combination; h-shale in the Cenozoic Shahejie Formation in Bohai Bay Basin: “matrix pore (inter- and intra-crystal) + organicmatter pore” combination; i-shale in Eagle Ford, the US: “organic-matter pore + matrix pore (intra- and inter-crystal pores of carbonate)” combination.

3.2.2. Comprehensive characterization of shale reservoir space

As indicated by the actual detection results mentioned above, the reservoir space for shale gas to occur is mainly restricted by organic-matter microscopic morphology,organic-matter content, and the components and diagenesis of the matrix minerals. The most significant feature of the reservoir space for shale gas is the combination relation of the pores. Micro-fractures are critical to migration and aggregation of shale gas and the reformation of reservoirs.Therefore, as mentioned above, besides the organic-matter pores and matrix pores, the shale micro-fractures shall be included in the characterization content.

The variables for three-end-member characterization of pore combination include plane porosity of organic-matter pores and matrix pores obtained from detection with FE-SEM and the micro-fracture percentage obtained with common optic thin sections. This characterization method is known as the three-end-member diagram based on the reference to the classification and naming of sandstone, and this means constitutes the primary core content of the characterization of shale reservoir space. Besides, owing to the important effects of the microscopic morphology of organic matter, rock components, and diagenesis on the pores, the characterization is supplemented by two kinds of statistical histograms of the microscopic morphology of organic matter and the percentage of the area of secondary-order pores, aiming to present the development degree of shale reservoir space and the effectiveness of the reservoirs more intuitively.

By applying the three-end-member characterization method to the marine-facies shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and its surrounding areas, the transitionalfacies shale of the Carboniferous-Permian in China, the continental-facies shale in China, and the marine-facies shale of the Carboniferous-Permian in the US, the characterization results and the statistical histograms of the microscopic morphology of organic matter are shown in Fig. 5 and Fig. 6 respectively. As indicated from the results, in the shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and the shale in Eagle Ford in the US, the organic-matter pores account for more than 80% of the total pores and more than 90% of organicmatter microscopic components are present in interstitial (or interactive) form, fully reflecting the excellent hydrocarbongenerating potential of the shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and the shale in Eagle Ford, the US. However,the difference between the shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin and the shale in Eagle Ford in the US can is further revealed from the statistical histogram of plane porosity of the secondary-order pores (Fig. 7). In detail,though they share the same organic-matter content and similar organic-matter microscopic morphologies, the total plane porosity of the pores in the shale in Eagle Ford in the US is up to 12% while it is 8% in the shale of Longmaxi Formation in the Sichuan Basin. Besides, the development degree of organic-matter pores of the shale in Eagle Ford in the US is higher than that of the shale of Longmaxi Formation in the Sichuan Basin. Therefore, the shale in Eagle Ford in the US features better storage condition and higher reservoir quality compared with the shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin. For transitional-facies shale of the Carboniferous-Permian, or the continental-facies shale of the Mesozoic and the Cenozoic in China, the organic-texture organic matter accounts for 50% or greater and thus the organic-matter pores only account for less than 30% of total pores. The pores in such shale are dominated by the matrix pores, especially by the residual pores and diagenetic fractures. As a result, such shale features poor hydrocarbon-generating potential in spite of ideal reservoir space. Thus it is intuitively revealed that the gas content of such shale is poor or even zero and that organic-texture organic matter features poor or no hydrocarbon-generating potential although the microscopic components of the organic-texture organic matter can improve the TOC of shale.

Fig. 6. Comparison of organic-matter microscopic morphology among the different types of shale. a-Shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin (16 wells); b-shale of the Carboniferous-Permian in Lower Yangtze Region (11 wells); c-shale of Shahejie Formation in Bohai Basin and shale of Yanchang Formation in Erdos Basin (7 wells); d-shale in Eagle Ford Shale, USA (3 wells); e-shale in Barnett and elsewhere, USA (13 wells).

Fig. 7. Statistics and comparison of subdivided pore types among different types of shale. a-Shale of Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin(16 wells); b-shale of the Carboniferous-Permian in Lower Yangtze Region (11 wells); c- shale of Shahejie Formation in Bohai Basin and shale of Yanchang Formation in Erdos Basin (7 wells); d-shale in Eagle Ford Shale, USA (3 wells); e-shale in Barnett and elsewhere, USA (13 wells).

The following results can be clearly obtained from comprehensive characterization results. The marine-facies organic-rich shale features the highest content of interstitial/interactive organic matter and the highest development degree of pores, and the pores are dominated by organic-matter pores. The strata rich in interstitial/interactive organic matter rank as the most favorable payzone (usually known as “dessert”) for the shale gas reservoirs. The continentalfacies organic-rich shale features comparatively high development degree of pores, the pores are dominated by matrix mineral pores with a few organic-matter pores, which only developed in interstitial organic matter. In addition,limited “dessert” for shale gas reservoirs developed in this kind of shale and is controlled by the microscopic morphologies of organic matter. The transitional-facies organic-rich shale features low development degree of pores,the organic-matter pores are also controlled by the content and distribution of the interstitial organic matter, and the “dessert”for shale gas reservoir is much limited. The presence of substantial organic-texture clasts in the transitional-facies organic-rich shale makes no or very few contributions to the capacity of the reservoirs in hydrocarbon generation and storage besides increasing the TOC content of shale.

It is certain that the characterization method proposed faces some shortcomings or other issues. It is expected to be improved progressively with the advancement of research and understanding.

4. Discussions

4.1. Questions raised

The question to be discussed here is why so many factors need to be considered for the characterization of shale gas reservoir space. During the usual actual detection, we often encounter the following questions:

(1) Some shale reservoirs with high TOC feature few organic-matter pores and low gas content, why? (2) In general, the porosity and parameters of pore structure of the whole core can be easily obtained by the method of conventional quantitative analysis, such as negative-pressure pore permeation, and nitrogen adsorption. Therefore, is it necessary to characterize the development features of organicmatter pores and matrix mineral pores respectively? (3) The detection with high-resolution FE-SEM is prone to be linked with the semi-quantitative statistic under the optical microscope. So, is it practical to apply the geological statistic methods to the semi-quantitative characterization of the microscopic reservoir space of shale gas? (4) Why is the interstitial organic matter repeatedly emphasized in this paper?

4.2. Verify and discuss

To clarify these questions, we have made a lot of statistics of actual detection results of various kinds of shale by combining the results of gas content testing of wells, TOC detection, analysis of digital core system, for example, and initially came to some relevant conclusions. It is these conclusions and new knowledge that drive us to think and put forth the preceding comprehensive characterization method on shale gas reservoirs.

4.2.1. The relationship between gas content and TOC

On the first question, as revealed by actual detection,nearly in all detected samples, the organic-matter pores only or mainly developed in interstitial/interactive organic matter.Furthermore, according to the statistical results of the gas content of multiple wells obtained in the drilling field, the gas content detected is significantly positively correlated with the percentage of interstitial organic matter. All these indicate that interstitial/interactive organic ranks as the most important hydrocarbon source or gas-generating parent materials, and that the shale rich in interstitial/interactive organic matter ranks as the best shale gas reservoirs. However, other shale reservoirs rich in organic-texture or other structural organic matter (mainly including coal clasts, coal streak, and shell of lower organisms, i.e., animal fossil) feature high TOC but low or no hydrocarbon-generating potential. As a result, only very few organic-matter pores are present and the gas content obtained from good detection is very low or zero. That is,organic-texture organic matter only contributes to the increase of TOC, while makes few or no contributions to hydrocarbongenerating potential of the shale. Therefore, a suitable characterization method of shale gas reservoirs enables to objectively and accurately explain the phenomenon that relevant reservoirs with high TOC feature scare gas content.This is also a convincing explanation for the fourth question mentioned above. That is greatly important to describe the microscopic morphology of organic matter (that is to identify microscopic components).

4.2.2. Visualized high resolution detection should be considered in all media quantitative analysis

On the second question, it is believed that conventional means can be used to characterize basic information on shale reservoirs, such as Mercury Injection Capillary Pressure(MICP), low-pressure N2 adsorption and He porosimetry.However, it is impossible to distinguish the organic-matter pores from mineral pores through blocky samples testing conducted by a physical quantitative method. As a result, the tested results tend to be inconsistent with actual conditions.For example, some reservoirs that enjoy good physical properties according to the analysis result of the pore permeation test actually feature poor gas-bearing property. As indicated by detection with SEM, the pores in such reservoirs are dominated by matrix mineral pores. Therefore, for largescale shale reservoirs, detection results obtained with high resolution SEM shall be referenced to determine “shale gas dessert horizon” and locate the horizons rich in organic-matter pores for consequent evaluation, exploration, and development. In this way, the effectiveness of geological work can be ensured.

4.2.3. Semi-quantitative method can be applied to shale reservoir characterization

On the third question, it is believed that the semiquantitative statistic method can be completely introduced into the detection of shale reservoir samples with FE-SEM.FE-SEM can unambiguously reveal the organic matter, matrix components, and micro/nano pores in shale. For all fabrics,the semi-quantitative results can be obtained by visual estimation under high-resolution SEM, or the quantitative statistics can be achieved by relevant digital core processing software. In this paper, the globally prevailing three-endmember method was adopted to plot area percentage diagram of the different types of pores based on the reference to theRock Thin Section Appraisal Industry Standard. Furthermore,the multi-element histogram analysis was employed as a supplement. The conclusions and data obtained by three-endmember characterization are consistent with the actual conditions and therefore. They are scientific and highly credible and worth to be widely implemented.

4.2.4. What is the interstitial organic matter

On the fourth question, though there are not enough evidence and simulation tests to demonstrate the forming principle of interstitial organic matter, the significance of microscopic morphology of organic matter has been confirmed above. Among the massive literature consulted in this paper, the research on mudstone and source rock in the 1970s-1990s provided great inspiration. In the academic results about oil source rock achieved by Chinese scholars such as petroleum and natural gas geochemist Fu JM et al.and Xiao XM et al. (Fu JM et al., 1975,1977; Xiao XM et al.,1990, 1992, 1993), based on thermal simulation test of organic matter, it is clearly pointed out that the fluid amorphous organic matter generating in the thermal evolution process of organic matter is liquid hydrocarbon or the mixture of liquid hydrocarbon and polycondensated kerogen.Meanwhile, it is stated that “In argillaceous oil source rocks,organic matter exists in two forms: (1) Pure morphological organic matter with form (e.g. exinite), (2) Disperse organic matter in clay minerals (called amorphous body in enriched kerogen). These 2 forms of organic matter constitute the oil source rock as a whole objectively, but they are different to a certain degree microscopically”. The specific identification means and research significance of the microscopic difference are not further discussed in the achievements. It can be argued that such microscopic difference can only be fully described with the high-resolution instruments of today.As revealed by considerable experience of actual detection of today, in addition to the difference in morphology, the abovementioned 2 microscopic components also are different in characteristics of pore occurrence, which can reflect the hydrocarbon-generating potential and storage capacity of shale. Meanwhile, the above 2 scholars also emphasized,“morphological organic matter contributes little to the forming of liquid hydrocarbons, while the amorphous body in mineral bitumen matrix is the overwhelming organic matter form after hydrocarbons generation”. This is very consistent with the knowledge obtained from detection with high-end instruments currently. At present, with the argon-ion polishing technology used in preparing polished sections and highresolution FE-SEM technology, the nanostructure of such organic matter can be discovered, and the structure and morphology of liquid hydrocarbons after further gas generation in the higher evolution phase can be clearly characterized. Therefore, based on previous research achievements, it can be confirmed that the interstitial organic matter is a derivative of an original organic or kerogen. Going further, it should be liquid hydrocarbons, i.e., petroleum generating in the evolution of kerogen, and currently, it presents in the form of bitumen or pyrobitumen hosting pores owing to gas generation. Through this research and comprehensive evaluation, it is believed that more progress should be achieved based on previous achievements, and the means different from those used to research and portray hydrocarbon source rocks shall be adopted to characterize shale that acts as both source rock and reservoir in a more indepth manner.

As the research content of shale gas reservoirs, all the content mentioned above, including characterization method of the microscopic pores in shale reservoirs and questions raised above are very complex and very important. Especially for the interstitial/interactive organic matter that can reflect the hydrocarbon-generating potential and reservoir capacity,its presence and enrichment endow the shale with future potential and economy. Therefore, the characterization and semi-quantitative statistics of the microscopic morphology of the organic matter are emphasized all through the paper(quantitative analysis standards of the microscopic components under the optic microscope are available for coal,but not available for shale). It can be noticed that, since 2018,some scholars have been already involved in the research on the microscopic morphologies of organic matter in shale and achieved knowledge with high value of practical application,such as the description of the microscopic components and microscopic morphology of organic matter and relevant research achievements obtained by Zhang H et al. (2018) as well as the classification of organic-matter microscopic morphologies and relevant research achievements gained by Wang XZ et al. (2018).

5. Conclusions

(i) In this paper, the three-end-member characterization method of microscopic shale reservoir space with pore combination as the focus was proposed based on systematical summarization of previous research achievements and massive actual detection. The core positions of organic matter and organic-matter pores in shale reservoirs were emphasized,the microscopic morphology types of organic matter in shale and the control of these types over the formation of organicmatter pores was portrayed, and the critical position of the interstitial/interactive organic matter in storage and hydrocarbon generation was pointed out.

(ii) Semi-quantitative statistics of microscopic reservoir space in shale can be made with high-resolution FE-SEM.The semi-quantitative statistics can not only offset the shortcoming of the whole-core analysis of being unable to distinguish the organic-matter pores from matrix pores but also intuitively reveal the pore development degree and the economy of some shale reservoir, thus providing more indepth microscopic data for the assessment of shale gas exploration and development. This comprehensive characterization method that combines both qualitative and quantitative analysis should (or will) become a research direction or effective characterization method of reservoir pace of shale gas in the future.

Acknowledgements

This study was supported by the National Scientific and Technological Major Special Project titled “Research on Evaluation Method and Exploration Technology on Shale Gas Resources” (2016ZX05034), “Shale Gas Basic Geological Survey Project in South China” (121201229000160021)initiated by CGS, and the inter-governmental cooperation project titled “China-USA Cooperation Research Project of Carboniferous-Permian Shale Reservoir Evaluation Technology” (2017YFE0106300). The authors are also grateful to experts and anonymous reviewers for their valuable suggestions and comments on the manuscript.


登录APP查看全文