单冷试验用于前庭功能筛查的可行性分析

2020-08-29 13:39:07张姝琪黎志成岑锦添李凌伟王心怡顾晶曾祥丽
新医学 2020年8期

张姝琪?黎志成?岑锦添?李凌伟?王心怡?顾晶?曾祥丽

【摘要】目的 探討单冷试验用于前庭功能筛选的价值及在临床评估前庭功能的可行性。方法 回顾性分析以眩晕为主诉的149例眩晕症患者的温度试验结果,分析患者温度试验结果与单冷试验结果的相关性及单冷试验的灵敏度和特异度。结果 149例眩晕患者男90例、女59例,年龄22 ~ 70(中位数46)岁。根据文献研究报道,以温度试验半规管轻瘫(CP)值为20%作为正常参考值,得出温度试验与单冷试验结果呈线性关系(r = 0.872,P < 0.001)。以CP值≥20%为温度试验的异常标准,温度试验作为金标准,受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线分析,单冷试验正常者的ROC曲线下面积为0.894(95% CI 0.833 ~ 0.939,P < 0.001),通过约登指数确定临界点为20%,单冷试验结果大于20%为异常,灵敏度为84.62%,特异度为84.54%。结论 单冷试验在前庭功能筛查的可靠性高,是一种灵敏的筛查工具,在临床中结合眼震电图将单冷试验作为筛查工具,将缩短患者检查时间及减少不适感。

【关键词】温度试验;单冷试验;前庭功能;眩晕

Feasibility analysis of monothermal caloric test in the screening of vestibular function Zhang Shuqi, Li Zhicheng, Cen Jintian, Li Lingwei, Wang Xinyi, Gu Jing, Zeng Xiangli. Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, the Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou 510630, China

Corresponding author, Zeng Xiangli, E-mail: zxiangl@ mail. sysu. edu. cn

【Abstract】Objective To explore the value of monothermal caloric test in the screenig of vestibular function and the feasibility in the clinical evaluation of vestibular function. Methods The caloric test results of 149 vertigo patients presenting with vertigo as the main complaint were retrospectively analyzed. The correlation between caloric test results and monothermal caloric test results were analyzed. The sensitivity and specificity of the monothermal test were analyzed too. Results Among 149 vertigo patients, 90 cases were male and 59 female, aged 22-70 years old with a median age of 46 years old.According to literature review, the CP value of caloric test of 20% was regarded as the normal reference value, and the results of caloric test and monothermal caloric test showed a linear relationship (r = 0.872, P < 0.001). The CP value of caloric test of ≥20% was considered as the abnormal standard and caloric test was used as the gold standard. The area under ROC curve for patients with normal monothermal caloric test results was 0.894 (95% CI 0.833-0.939, P < 0.001). The shreshold value of CP was determined as 20% according to the Youden index. The CP value of monothermal caloric test of > 20% was regarded as abnormal result. The sensitivity was calculated as 84.62% and 84.54% for the specificity. Conclusions Monothermal caloric test yields a high reliability in vestibular function screening. As a sensitive screening tool, the combined use of monothermal caloric test and electronystagmography can shortern the examination time and mitigate discomforts of vergito patients.

【Key words】Caloric test;Monothermal caloric test;Vestibular function;Vertigo

以眩晕为主诉的患者目前在耳鼻咽喉头颈外科门诊中,大约占有10% ~ 15%,眩晕发作不仅影响工作,生活质量也遭到严重的破坏。判断患者外周前庭功能状况是眩晕症诊疗的重要依据。针对外周前庭功能的检查方法有许多,其中温度试验是评估平衡障碍或眩晕前庭功能的主要方式。在临床工作中,随着眩晕患者的增多,检测时间长,检查效率低,可能导致患者无法及时行前庭功能诊断,从而影响评估前庭功能障碍及后续的治疗管理。

基于评估诊断测试和减少时间成本效益,目前许多研究正在建议推广单冷试验作为温度试验的筛选预测方案,有学者研究提出单冷试验结果阴性,即提示双侧前庭功能正常,而当阳性时,才需进行冷热试验以确诊。但对其研究成果一直存在争议[1-3]。单冷试验在前庭诊断的准确性相同条件下,可以减少花费的时间和患者不适感。……

登录APP查看全文