Mohmmd Rez Ghni ,Jonthn M.Young ,Prithwish K.Nndi ,Shmsudeen Dndre ,Christopher C.R.Allen ,**,Nill J.English ,*
a School of Chemical and Bioprocess Engineering,University College Dublin,Belfield,Dublin 4,Ireland
b School of Biological Sciences,Queen's University Belfast,University Road,Belfast,BT7 1NN,Northern Ireland,UK
ABSTRACT The large quantity of marine methane hydrates has driven substantial interest in methane-gas-fuel potential,especially with the qualified success of Shensu(2017)and Nankai-Trough(2014 &17)production trials via depressurisation(blighted ultimately by sanding out),building on an earlier Malik-2008 trial for permafrost-bound hydrate.In particular,obviating deep-water-drilling approaches,such as the MeBO production rig(without such a drill bit),together with blowout preventers,constitutes a tantalising cost-saving measure.Tailored means of addressing sand production by customised gravel packs,wellbore screens and slotted liners with from-seafloor drilling will be expected to lead to future production-trial success.However,despite these exciting engineering advances and a few marinemimicking laboratory studies of methane-hydrate kinetics and stabilisation from microbial perspectives,relatively little is known about the thermogenic or microbial origin of marine hydrates,nor their possible formation kinetics or potential stabilisation by microbial sources as an exponent of Gaia's hypothesis,or within the context of“Gaia's breath”as regards global methane‘exhalations’.Here,for the first time,we elucidate the methylotrophic-microbial basis for kinetic enhancement and stabilisation of marine-hydrate formation in both deionised- and sea-water,identifying the key protein at play,which has some similarity to porins in other methylotrophic communities.In so doing,we suggest such phenomena in marine hydrates as evidence of Gaia's hypothesis.
Keywords:Gas hydrate Microbes Methylotrophs
-(cf.Fig.S3 and Supp.Info.).This surface-fit equation was employed later to calculate the compressibility factor of methane at various pressures and temperatures in the hydrate-formation and dissociation runs from mass balances on thus-inferred gas-phase-number-of-moles data(from the gas-phase pressure),taking into account the temperature-variation of methane absorption in liquid with literature data for Henry's Law constants for methane[17].Knowing the number of absorbed/released moles of methane,in addition to typical methane-hydrate cage-occupancy levels of 90%in the present P/T range[1],allows for the percentage yield to methane hydrate to be calculated.
Preliminary analysis was performed by aligning the sequences against the Refseq(complete)bacterial-,archaeal- and viralgenome database[10].Statistically-significant differences in taxon abundances between sample groups at the class- and genustaxonomic ranks were evident(cf.Fig.2 and Fig.S8).This suggests that the methanol-enriched samples have a much higher proportion of Gammaproteobacteria - specifically Methylophaga(or something relatively close to it);indeed,this is not particularly surprising,given its methylotrophic nature[10].About 30% of the treatment group's and about 50% of the control group's DNA sequences could not be classified using this method,but substantial improvement would result when aligned against a larger database,so as to elucidate functional-gene abundances.See Fig.3 for the novel protein's sequence,which is discussed further in ref.10,including mass spectrometry,cloning and purification.
18 runs were performed under a variety of conditions to assess systematically various putative effects(cf.Table S1),primarily;(i)reproducibility and(ii)ageing,with a further suite of a half-dozen runs to gauge(iii)the effect of methanol levels,given its known effect as a thermodynamic inhibitor[1].Reproducibility was in general good,performed over three independent runs(cf.Table S4 for deionised-water results,as an example).Examining the age of the culture on kinetics of yield(cf.Table 1 and Fig.1),the most obvious effect is a strong promotion in yield for T1 and acceleration of hydrate-formation conditions relative to both seawater conditions and the reference-nutrient sample C1(over double the seawater effect).However,it becomes clear that there is an important age effect:for T1,an“expiration effect”starts within a couple of weeks(akin to an“incubation”for declining promotion):the yield has decreased significantly after 23+12 days.Comparing the aged sample with deionised water(DI),T1 ageing acts as powerful inhibitor,where it reduces the yield of hydrate formation even lower than pure DI.Naturally,deionised water lacks the salt and biological entities that serve to promote homogeneous nucleation even further in marine-sandy milieux.Indeed,this is consistent with the working hypothesis of protein origin of T1's dramatic,time-dependent‘bifurcated’effect(vide infra).For C1,on the right,ageing by 16 days aging also reduces the effect of the nutrition sample on hydrate formation,i.e.,it acts as an inhibitor.However,the dramatic promotion seen for T1 hydrate conversion vis-`a-vis seawater is not as dramatic for C1,nor,by contrast,is the subsequent inhibition for aged samples.In the case of seawater,there is a weak ageing effect,with just a 4%decline in yield over ~3 weeks,and still at a higher level than deionised water.Similar mild ageing effects were seen with further runs in the case of Dublin Bay seawater.

Table 1 Age-of-sample-effect.Yield estimate of hydrate produced during formation,along with dissociation-based estimate.20 cm3 of water was used,with 1 g of chemically-/heattreated sea sand.The hydrate yield is estimated for both formation and dissociation.Intermediate storage of all samples was at 4 °C in a refrigerator.‘BSW’refers to‘Belfast Lough Seawater’,whilst‘DI’denotes deionised water.The dissociation-based yield is typically higher,due potentially to release of some methane bubbles from solution upon heating(which developed during hydrate formation;cf.Supp.Info.,and especially Fig.S6).
Turning to dissociation temperature,as a proxy for thermodynamic stabilisation,to examine potential methylotroph-culture effect thereon,Fig.S7 evinces an apparent trend of a slightincrease(up to perhaps ~1°C)at ~11-12°C when less-aged T1 is used.This is in stark contrast with more aged T1 or deionised water,with DI water showing no age effect.This suggests that the T1 microbial culture confers greater thermal and thermodynamic stabilisation of marine-like methane hydrates vis-`a-vis those produced synthetically in environments bereft of methylotrophs.
Despite measurements of essentially zero methanol(or,at least undetectable above the 1 mM level in the‘T’ cultures or the‘C’nutrient case)prior to hydrate formation,we performed some tests on assessing the ultimate hydrate yield with DI water with the same treated marine sand(in the identical sand-to-water ratio).At 40 and 80 mM(roughly half and similar to the 74 mM used to set up the‘T’microbial culture,respectively,cf.‘Methodology’),the yield at 40 mM did not alter from ~6 ± 2% for pure-DI water,whilst that at 80 mM increased modestly to ~7.5%,although given the estimated yield's uncertainty of ~2%from multiple measurements(cf.Supp.Info.),the 80 mM-versus zero-methanol difference does not pass a 90% twotailed Student's t-test for H1,meaning that it is less probable that methanol concentration has a decisive effect on hydrate-conversion yield in the range studied.In any event,the lack of measured methanol means that this potential variable can be eliminated in rationalising both age-dependent and dramatic effects of the T1 culture at accelerating hydrate-formation kinetics,conversion yield and stabilising hydrate-dissociation condition to higher temperature:whilst young(lessthanafewweeks),hydrate promotionwithrespecttoDIis found,with a decline in hydrate-formation propensity and stabilisation once more aged(acting as ade factoinhibitor).
Naturally,T1's intriguing time-dependent promotion/inhibition‘dichotomy’ is suggestive of potential peptide-based activity underpinning this clear and substantial microbial effect.To elucidate the precise biological origin,we performed Refseq against standard bacterial-,archaeal- and viral-genome database[10].Statisticallysignificant differences in taxon abundances between sample groups at the class- and genus-taxonomic ranks were evident(cf.Fig.2).This suggests that the methanol-enriched samples have a much higher proportion of Gammaproteobacteria - specifically generally redolent of Methylophaga;indeed,this is not particularly surprising,given its methylotroph nature.In any event,we sequenced this earlier in ref.10,and it is shown in Fig.3,with 60%overlap to Methylophaga aminisulphidivorans,not unlike the general porin class.
We have establishedprima facieevidence of microbial enhancement and stabilisation of marine hydrates,mediated by a peptide not unlike methylotrophic porins[10];ref.10 did not discuss seawater and non-purified proteins,nor comment to any extent on measurements suggesting the possibility of thermodynamic stabilisation.Not only does this advance more direct evidence of Gaia's hypothesis[10,18],but,more speculatively,could signal the r^ole of similar peptides in some of the earliest biotic processes in Earth's primordial history[19,20],as pre-biotic peptides formed at deep-sea vents were sequestered by early methylotrophs[14].
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
NE,PKN and MRG thank Science Foundation Ireland for funding under grant SFI 15/ERC-I3142.MRG also thanks the Irish Research Council for a Government-of-Ireland postdoctoral fellowship(GOIPD/2016/365).CCRA was supported by a QUB AFQCC grant funded by Invest Northern Ireland.SD was supported by a Commonwealth PhD Scholarship.JY was supported by a DENI studentship.NE thanks John Osegovic,and all authors thank Timofey Skvortsov,for interesting and helpful conversations.
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.petlm.2021.10.010.