Transport of cadmium from soil to grain in cereal crops:A review

2021-03-17 09:05:46JianFengMARenFangSHENandJiFengSHAO
Pedosphere 2021年1期

Jian Feng MA,Ren Fang SHEN and Ji Feng SHAO

1Institute of Plant Science and Resources,Okayama University,Chuo 2-20-1,Kurashiki 710-0046(Japan)

2State Key Laboratory of Soil and Sustainable Agriculture,Institute of Soil Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008(China)3State Key Laboratory of Subtropical Silviculture,Zhejiang A&F University,Lin’An 311300(China)

(Received March 3,2020;revised March 20,2020)

ABSTRACT Due to rapid urbanization and industrialization,many soils for crop production are contaminated by cadmium(Cd),a heavy metal highly toxic to many organisms.Cereal crops such as rice,wheat,maize,and barley are the primary dietary source of Cd for humans,and reducing Cd transfer from soil to their grains is therefore an important issue for food safety.During the last decade,great progress has been made in elucidating the molecular mechanisms of Cd transport,particularly in rice.Inter-and intraspecific variations in Cd accumulation have been observed in cereal crops.Transporters for Cd have been identified in rice and other cereal crops using genotypic differences in Cd accumulation and mutant approaches.These transporters belong to different transporter families and are involved in the uptake,vacuolar sequestration,root-to-shoot translocation,and distribution of Cd.Attempts have been made to reduce Cd accumulation in grains by manipulating these transporters through overexpression or knockout of the transporter genes,as well as through marker-assisted selection breeding based on genotypic differences in Cd accumulation in the grains.In this review,we describe recent progress on molecular mechanisms of Cd accumulation in cereal crops and compare different molecular strategies for minimizing Cd accumulation in grains.

Key Words:barley,gene knockout,gene overexpression,genotypic difference,maize,rice,transporter,wheat

INTRODUCTION

Cadmium(Cd)and Cd-bearing minerals are widely used in modern industry and agriculture(Clemens and Ma,2016).However,Cd is highly toxic to plants and animals(Zhao and Wang,2020).High Cd contents in soil can inhibit plant growth through strong interactions with the sulfhydryl groups required for protein structure and function and interferences with the homeostasis of essential elements such as calcium(Ca)and zinc(Zn)(Clemens and Ma,2016).Excessive intake of Cd causes kidney failure,osteoporosis,and osteomalacia in animals(Bertin and Averbeck,2006;Nawrotet al.,2006).Regulation of Cd release has mitigated heavy Cd contamination,but low and moderate contamination of soil is increasing due to metal mining and smelting activities,application of phosphate fertilizers with Cd impurities,contaminated sewage sludge and waste water,sewage effluents,and agricultural runoff(Williamset al.,2009;Meharget al.,2013).In China,7% of farmland was reported to be contaminated with Cd,according to a recent nationwide survey(Wang Pet al.,2019).The level at which Cd becomes toxic differs between plants and humans;plants growing on soil with Cd levels insufficient to inhibit growth can still accumulate it in edible parts in sufficient quantities to threaten human health through ingestion(Clemenset al.,2013).Greater concern has therefore been paid to the toxicity of Cd to humans than to Cd phytotoxicity.

Over 50% of all calories consumed in the human diet are derived from cereal crops such as rice,wheat,maize,and barley,and these crops amount for correspondingly high portions of dietary Cd.For example,Cd intake from rice accounts for about 40%-50% of total Cd intake for populations consuming rice as a staple food(Shimboet al.,2001;Grantet al.,2008).From mid-1950s to mid-1960s in Japan,an affliction known as the Itai-Itai disease caused weakening of the bones and renal tubular dysfunction and was attributed to consumption of rice grown on Cdcontaminated soils(Horiguchiet al.,1994;Kobayashiet al.,2009).The safety threshold of Cd content in cereal grains has been set to 0.4 mg kg−1for rice(0.2 mg kg−1in China),0.2 mg kg−1for wheat,and 0.1 mg kg−1for maize and barley by the Codex Alimentarius Commission,a joint office of the United Nation’s Food and Agriculture Organization and the World Health Organization(Codex Alimentarius Commission,2006).However,cereals produced on Cdcontaminated soil often exceed these limits.Therefore,it is imperative to restrict the transfer of Cd from soil to cereal grains for human health.During the last decade,some progress has been made in understanding the mechanisms of Cd transport in plants,particularly in rice(Clemens and Ma,2016;Wanget al.,2018;Zhao and Wang,2020).In this review,we focus on the transport systems of Cd in cereal crops and discuss approaches for reducing Cd accumulation in cereal grains.

AVAILABILITY IN SOIL

The average Cd content in soil ranges from 0.07 to 1.1 mg kg−1(Kabata-Pendias and Pendias,1984),but highly contaminated soils exceed this range.Soil solutions with Cd concentrations between 0.2 and 6µg L−1are considered uncontaminated,and those with Cd concentrations as high as 400µg L−1are considered Cd-contaminated(Kabata-Pendias and Gondek,1978).However,soluble Cd concentrations in soil solutions rarely exceed 1µmol L−1(Smolders and Mertens,2013).The chemical forms of Cd that occur in soil are CdS,CdSO4,and Cd complex with organic chelates.These forms vary with soil conditions.For example,under flooded conditions,Cd is precipitated with HS and forms CdS,which has a low solubility.In upland soils,Cd is present in the form of CdSO4,which has a high solubility.The availability of Cd in soil is determined by several factors including soil pH,organic matter content,cation exchange capacity,and Eh(Brownet al.,2004;Antoniadiset al.,2008;Römkenset al.,2011;Pietrzykowskiet al.,2014).Soil pH and Eh have the greatest influence on Cd availability;Cd solubility in soil decreases with increasing soil pH(Araoet al.,2009;Huet al.,2013;Huet al.,2015).As shown in Fig.1a,liming is very effective in reducing Cd accumulation in rice grains.The exchangeable Cd content in soil increases with increasing Eh under oxidative conditions.When Eh increases from 0 to 300 mV,Cd concentrations in soil solutions increase from 0.2 to 0.8µg L−1(Honmaet al.,2016).Flooding and liming are therefore effective approaches for reducing Cd availability in soil and,thereby,Cd accumulation in grains(Fig.1a,b).

INTRA-AND INTER-SPECIFIC VARIATIONS IN ACCUMULATION IN CEREAL CROPS

Cadmium accumulation varies widely between plant species.In cereal crops,rice typically accumulates more Cd than wheat,barley,and maize.For example,in a Japanese survey,Cd content in polished rice is 2.5-fold higher than that of wheat flour(Shimboet al.,2001).Similar trends were reported in China,where the average Cd content in rice grains is 3-8 times higher than those of wheat and other cereal grains based on an investigation of tens of thousands of samples(Songet al.,2017).These differences in Cd accumulation partially attribute to differences in expression level,transport activity,and tissue-specific localization of transporters for Cd uptake,as described in the next section.

There is also a wide variation in Cd accumulation between different cultivars within a species.For example,a 13-fold difference in shoot Cd content was found in 146 accessions from a rice core collection(Uenoet al.,2009).In barley,the grain Cd content ranged from 1.6 to 102.9µg kg−1dry weight when 100 accessions of barley collected from different regions were grown under the same field conditions(Wuet al.,2015).The leaf Cd content varied from 16.6 to 128.4 mg kg−1in 269 maize accessions grown in a nutrient solution containing a high concentration of Cd(Zhaoet al.,2018).Genotypic variations in Cd accumulation in wheat have also been reported(Zaidet al.,2018).These genotypic differences have been used for quantitative trait locus(QTL)analysis,gene isolation,and breeding program,as described below.

TRANSPORT SYSTEMS IN CEREAL CROPS

Transfer of Cd from soil to the grains involves several steps,including uptake by the roots,vacuolar sequestration in the roots,translocation from the roots to the shoots,and distribution to the grains(Clemens and Ma,2016;Wanget al.,2018;Huanget al.,2020).All of these steps require various different transporters.

Transporters for uptake in roots

OsNramp5 and HvNramp5 are responsible for the transport of Cd from the soil solution to the root cells of rice and barley,respectively(Sasakiet al.,2012;Wuet al.,2016).Homologs of OsNramp5 and HvNramp5 are present in maize(ZmNramp5)and wheat(TaNramp5A and TaNramp5D)(Suiet al.,2018).Nramp5 belongs to the natural resistance-associated macrophage protein transporter family and transports manganese(Mn)as well as Cd(Sasakiet al.,2012).In rice,OsNramp5 displays polar localization at the distal sides of both the exodermis and endodermis of mature roots(Sasakiet al.,2012)(Fig.2a,c),while HvNramp5 is localized in the epidermal cells of root tips without polarity(Wuet al.,2016)(Fig.2b).This difference in tissue localization could contribute to the high degree of Cd accumulation in rice.Rice basal roots are characterized by Casparian strips at the exodermis and endodermis and by the formation of aerenchyma(Maet al.,2006;Yamaji and Ma,2007).A recent study showed that both Casparian strips and polar localization of influx and efflux transporters are required for efficient Si uptake in rice(Sakuraiet al.,2015).By contrast,in barley root tips,Casparian strips are usually weakly developed at the endodermis,and there is no detectable aerenchyma.Therefore,Cd taken up through HvNramp5 at the epidermal cells in barley is radially transported to the stele symplastically with lower efficiency than the rice uptake system(Fig.2).

In addition,the expression level and transport activity ofNramp5homologs vary between cereal crops.The expression level ofOsNramp5in rice was 4-5 times that ofTaNramp5AandTaNramp5Din wheat orZmNramp5in maize(Suiet al.,2018).The expression level ofNramp5was 4-7 times higher in rice than in barley(Wuet al.,2016).OsNramp5 from rice displayed greater Cd transport activity than wheat or maize Nramp5 in yeast trials(Suiet al.,2018).These differences in expression level and transport activity likely also contribute to the higher Cd accumulation in rice.

Transporters such as OsIRT1,OsIRT2,OsNramp1,and OsCd1 have also been implicated in Cd uptake in rice(Nakanishiet al.,2006;Lee and An,2009;Takahashiet al.,2011;Yanet al.,2019).However,knockout ofOsNramp5resulted in complete loss of Cd uptake(Sasakiet al.,2012),indicating that OsNramp5 is the primary transporter of Cd in rice and the contribution of other transporters is relatively small.

After Cd is taken up by Nramp5 in the root cells of rice,it must be transported from the exodermis and endodermis cells toward the xylem vessels for subsequent translocation to the shoots,implying the existence of an efflux transporter localized at the exodermis and endodermis.The putative cation/Ca exchanger OsCCX2 was recently reported to function as an efflux transporter of Cd in rice(Haoet al.,2018),possibly working cooperatively with OsNramp5 to release Cd from the root cells towards the root xylem vessels,although further evidence is required to confirm this role.It is unknown whether a similar transporter is required for Cd uptake in other cereal crops.

Transporters for vacuolar sequestration in roots

After Cd is taken up into the root cells by the influx transporter Nramp5,a portion is sequestered into the vacuoles,while the remaining portion is released to the xylem for subsequent translocation to the shoots.In rice roots,the vacuolar sequestration of Cd is mediated by OsHMA3,a member of the heavy metal-transporting ATPase family(Uenoet al.,2010)(Fig.2c).OsHMA3 was isolated using a large QTL for Cd accumulation on the short arm of chromosome 7,with a mapping population derived from a cross between anindicavariety with high grain Cd(Anjana Dhan)and thejaponicacultivar‘Nipponbare’with lower grain Cd(Uenoet al.,2010).OsHMA3 is localized at the tonoplast and displays transport activity for Cd and Zn(Uenoet al.,2010;Miyadateet al.,2011;Caiet al.,2019).In barley,wheat,and maize,there are homologs of OsHMA3(Wuet al.,2015;Zhaoet al.,2018;Zhouet al.,2019),but their roles in Cd accumulation remain to be investigated.

Transporters involved in root-to-shoot translocation

The root-to-shoot translocation of Cd is mediated by OsHMA2,a homolog of OsHMA3 in rice(Satoh-Nagasawaet al.,2012;Takahashiet al.,2012;Yamajiet al.,2013).OsHMA2 is localized at the plasma membrane of the pericycle of the roots(Fig.2c).It has shown an influx transport activity for both Cd and Zn in yeast(Yamajiet al.,2013).In maize,a gene on chromosome 2 responsible for a QTL of leaf Cd accumulation may be associated with homologs of OsHMA2 and OsHMA3(Zhaoet al.,2018),but their roles require further investigation.Recently,OsZIP7 and OsCAL1 have also been reported to be implicated in rootto-shoot translocation(Luoet al.,2018;Tanet al.,2019)(Fig.2c).OsZIP7 is localized at the plasma membrane of the root parenchyma cells and shows transport activity for Cd and Zn(Tanet al.,2019).OsCAL1encodes a defensin-like protein and is expressed in the root exodermis and the xylem parenchyma cells(Luoet al.,2018).This protein can bind Cd and may facilitate its efflux to the apoplastic spaces(Fig.2c).

Transporters for distribution to the grains

Cadmium is distributed to the grains at the reproductive growth stage.Node I has been shown to play a crucial role in the distribution of mineral elements,including Cd,in rice(Yamajiet al.,2013;Yamaji and Ma,2014).In rice,the transporters OsHMA2,OsLCT1,OsZIP7,and OsCCX2 have been implicated in the distribution of Cd to grains(Fig.3)(Uraguchiet al.,2011;Yamajiet al.,2013;Haoet al.,2018;Tanet al.,2019).In rice nodes,OsHMA2 is localized at the phloem of enlarged and diffuse vascular bundles(EVBs and DVBs,respectively)(Yamajiet al.,2013).OsHMA2 is involved in reloading Zn and Cd from the intervening parenchyma tissues into the phloem of DVBs(Fig.3).OsZIP7 appears to play a similar role in the intervascular transfer of Zn and Cd in the nodes(Tanet al.,2019),and OsLCT1 also appears to be involved in the inter-vascular transfer of Cd(Uraguchiet al.,2011).OsLCT1 shows an efflux transport activity for Cd,potassium(K),magnesium(Mg),Ca,and Mn,but not for iron(Fe),Zn,copper(Cu),and sodium(Na)(Uraguchiet al.,2011,2014).OsLCT1is expressed around the EVBs and DVBs in node I at the reproductive stage.OsHMA2is highly expressed in the nodes throughout reproductive growth,but expression ofOsLCT1in the nodes is only observed at the ripening stage(Uraguchiet al.,2011).Higher expression ofOsLCT1is observed in the leaf blade than in the nodes at each reproductive growth period(Uraguchiet al.,2011).These differences indicate that the Cd translocation pathway mediated by OsLCT1 is different from that mediated by OsHMA2.OsLCT1 may be involved in efflux of Cd from the phloem within the nodes.On the other hand,OsCCX2is also highly expressed in the xylem region of the enlarged vascular bundles in the nodes and may participate in the release of Cd from these cells(Haoet al.,2018),although further functional characterization is required.Regrettably,no similar transporters involved in the distribution of Cd have been identified in other cereal crops.

Fig.3 Transporters involved in Cd distribution in rice nodes.Different transporters are shown in different colors.For details,refer to the text.EVB=enlarged vascular bundle;DVB=diffuse vascular bundle;PPC/CC=phloem parenchyma/companion cell.

TRANSGENIC APPROACHES FOR REDUCING ACCUMULATION IN CEREAL GRAINS

To reduce the transfer of Cd from the soil to the grains of cereal crops,several approaches have been tested,including soil dressing,application of amendments such as biochar,liming,water management,and phytoremediation(Murakamiet al.,2007;Araoet al.,2009;Ibarakiet al.,2009;Yuet al.,2014;Chenet al.,2018;Liuet al.,2018).Liming and biochar application decrease Cd availability in soil by increasing the soil pH,thereby decreasing Cd uptake and accumulation in rice grains(Cuiet al.,2011;Suksabyeet al.,2016;Chenet al.,2018;Zhanget al.,2019)(Fig.1a).Flooding at the grain filling stage effectively decreases Cd accumulation in rice grains(Araoet al.,2009)(Fig.1b).This effect is also attributed to decreased Cd availability in soil due to formation of CdS,as described above.Phytoremediation utilizing rice cultivars with high Cd accumulation has been reported to be effective in mitigating low to moderate levels of soil Cd(Murakamiet al.,2009).Cultivation with a high Cd-accumulatingindicavariety‘Choukokoku’for two years resulted in a 38% reduction of total soil Cd content(Murakamiet al.,2009).However,these approaches are not cost effective and are time consuming.As a sustainable approach for remediation of Cd-contaminated soils,transgenic attempts have been made to breed crop cultivars with low Cd accumulation,particularly in rice.

Because OsNramp5 is a major transporter for Cd uptake(Sasakiet al.,2012),knockout ofOsNramp5has been found to be very effective in reducing Cd accumulation in rice grains in several studies(Ishikawaet al.,2012;Sasakiet al.,2012;Tanget al.,2017;Liuet al.,2019;Yanget al.,2019).For example,knockout ofOsNram5in rice resulted in a remarkable decrease of Cd accumulation in the brown rice(Sasakiet al.,2012)(Fig.1c).A rice mutant with loss of function ofOsNramp5generated by ion-beam irradiation showed nearly undetectable Cd in the grains of rice when grown in a Cd-contaminated paddy field(Ishikawaet al.,2012).Knockout ofOsNramp5using the CRISPR/Cas9 system also resulted in a 90% reduction in grain Cd content in hybrid rice(Tanget al.,2017),but contradictory results on rice yield have also been reported.In several studies,knockout ofOsNramp5resulted in significant reduction in growth and yield(Sasakiet al.,2012;Liuet al.,2019;Yanget al.,2019),likely due to the concurrent role of OsNramp5 as a transporter for Mn uptake(Sasakiet al.,2012);knockout ofOsNramp5therefore also resulted in decreased Mn uptake,growth inhibition,and grain yield loss due to Mn deficiency.By contrast,two studies reported that knockout ofOsNramp5did not reduce yields(Ishikawaet al.,2012;Tanget al.,2017).The exact reason for this inconsistency is unknown,but one possibility could be different mutation points in the OsNramp5 protein and different growth conditions.Knockdown ofHvNramp5also significantly reduced Cd accumulation in barley(Wuet al.,2016),but the effect ofNramp5knockout on Cd accumulation in wheat and maize has not been examined.Knockout ofOsCd1decreased Cd uptake and accumulation in rice,but the rice yield was negatively influenced becauseOsCd1is also involved in Mn uptake(Yanet al.,2019).

By contrast,over-expression ofOsHMA3in rice has consistently been reported to significantly reduce Cd accumulation in the grains,without yield penalty.The expression of nativeOsHMA3is quite low in rice roots(Uenoet al.,2010),and over-expression of functionalOsHMA3increases vacuolar sequestration of Cd in the root cells,resulting in decreased root-to-shoot translocation of Cd(Uenoet al.,2010;Sasakiet al.,2014).The brown rice of the over-expression lines ofOsHMA3only contained 0.3 mg kg−1Cd,in contrast to 6 mg kg−1Cd in that of the wild-type rice,when grown on a Cd-contaminated soil(Fig.1d),and the contents of Zn and Fe were not affected in the over-expression lines(Uenoet al.,2010).Overexpression ofOsHMA3in anindicarice cultivar decreased Cd content in brown rice by 94% to 98% compared to the wild type,without loss of grain yield(Luet al.,2019).A recent study(Caiet al.,2019)showed thatOsHMA3is also responsible for vacuolar sequestration of Zn in the root cells of rice(Sasakiet al.,2014).Zinc homeostasis in the shoots appears to be maintained by the up-regulation of five genes related to Zn transport(Sasakiet al.,2014).IncreasedHvHMA3expression in barley plays a similar role in sequestration of Cd in the roots asOsHMA3(Leiet al.,2020),but little is known concerning the effect ofHMA3over-expression on Cd accumulation in other cereal crops.

Knockout ofOsHMA2significantly decreases Cd accumulation in rice grains(Yamajiet al.,2013),but the knockout lines showed decreased yields becauseOsHMA2is also required for Zn transport(Yamajiet al.,2013).OsHMA2is highly expressed in the nodes and the roots;expression ofOsHMA3under the control ofOsHMA2effectively and selectively reduces Cd accumulation in rice grains through increased vacuolar sequestration of Cd in the roots and nodes before loading to the grains(Shaoet al.,2018).Knockout ofOsCAL1decreases root-to-shoot translocation,but does not affect Cd accumulation in the grains(Luoet al.,2018).

Manipulation of transporters involved in Cd distribution in the nodes has also been found to successfully reduce Cd content in rice grains.For example,knockout ofOsCCX2decreases the Cd content in rice grains by approximately 50%(Haoet al.,2018).Knockdown ofOsLCT1also decreases the Cd accumulation in rice grains(Uraguchiet al.,2011).

CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PROSPECTIVES

During the last decade,great progress has been made in elucidating the molecular mechanisms of Cd accumulation in rice.Several transporters involved in the uptake,vacuolar sequestration,translocation,and distribution of Cd have been identified in rice.However,little is known about the molecular mechanisms of Cd accumulation in barley,maize,and wheat,and the molecular mechanisms underlying Cd accumulation in rice is not yet fully understood.Many transporters involved in the process remain to be identified:for example,Cd efflux transporters in the root exodermis and endodermis cells have not been functionally characterized,and the transporters involved in xylem unloading and phloem loading of Cd are also unknown.

Cadmium is a non-essential element for plant growth,and no transporter specifically for Cd has yet been identified.Transport of Cd in plants is likely entirely mediated by transporters for essential metals.For example,Cd uptake is mediated by OsNramp5,an Mn transporter(Sasakiet al.,2012),while OsHMA2 and OsHMA3 are transporters for Zn(Uenoet al.,2010;Yamajiet al.,2013;Caiet al.,2019).Therefore,knockout ofOsNramp5andOsHMA2inhibits growth due to deficiencies of these essential metals,and these genes cannot be utilized for breeding rice cultivars with low Cd accumulation.Although over-expression ofOsHMA3effectively and selectively reduces Cd accumulation in the rice grains(Uenoet al.,2010;Shaoet al.,2018),there is a persistent public acceptance issue with transgenic plants.Screening of new alleles with different selectivity for Cd and essential metals may provide useful material for the breeding of low-Cd cultivars in the future.There are wide genotypic variations in Cd accumulation in rice,barley,wheat,and maize(Uenoet al.,2009;Wuet al.,2015;Zaidet al.,2018;Zhaoet al.,2018).Several QTLs for Cd accumulation have been detected(Uenoet al.,2009;Zaidet al.2018;Zhaoet al.,2018;Wang X Ket al.,2019).Identification and pyramiding of these QTL genes into elite cultivars will contribute to the development of safe cereal crops with low Cd accumulation through marker-assisted selection in the future.A recent study in barley by introgression of a good allele ofHvHMA3to an elite barley cultivar provides a good example for this approach(Leiet al.,2020).

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

Some work introduced in this paper was supported by the Grant-in-Aid for Specially Promoted Research,Japan(JSPS KAKENHI Grant No.16H06296 to J.F.Ma.),the grants from the Scientific Research Development Foundation of Zhejiang A&F University for the Talents,China(No.2019FR002),and the Major Special Science and Technology Project of Zhejiang Province,China(No.2016C02G2101016).


登录APP查看全文