Divjot KOUR,Kusam Lata RANA,Tanvir KAUR,Neelam YADAV,Ajar Nath YADAV,Manish KUMAR,Vinod KUMAR,Harcharan Singh DHALIWAL and Anil Kumar SAXENA
1Department of Biotechnology,Dr.Khem Singh Gill Akal College of Agriculture,Eternal University,Baru Sahib,Sirmour 173101(India)
2Gopi Nath P.G.College,Veer Bahadur Singh Purvanchal University,Ghazipur 275201(India)
3Amity Institute of Biotechnology,Amity University,Gwalior 474005(India)
4Biochemistry,Forage Section,College of Agriculture,CCS Agricultural University,Haryana 125004(India)
5ICAR-National Bureau of Agriculturally Important Microorganisms,Kusmaur 275103(India)
(Received November 4,2019;revised December 30,2019)
ABSTRACT As one of the most important and essential macronutrients next to nitrogen,phosphorus(P)is important for plant development,but it is the least mobile nutrient element in plant and soil.Globally,P is mined from geological sediments and added to agricultural soils so as to meet the critical requirements of crop plants for agronomic productivity.Phosphorus exists in soil in both organic and inorganic forms.The various inorganic forms of the element in soil are salts with calcium,iron,and aluminum,whereas the organic forms come from decaying vegetation and microbial residue.There is a huge diversity of plant microbiomes(epiphytic,endophytic,and rhizospheric)and soil microbiomes that have the capability to solubilize the insoluble P and make it available to plant.The main mechanism for the solubilization of inorganic P is by the production of organic acids,which lowers soil pH,or by the production of acid and alkaline phosphatases,which causes the mineralization of organic P.The P-solubilizing and-mobilizing microorganisms belong to all three domains,comprising archaea,bacteria,and eukarya.The strains belonging to the genera Arthrobacter,Bacillus,Burkholderia,Natrinema,Pseudomonas,Rhizobium,and Serratia have been reported as efficient and potential P solubilizers.The use of P solubilizers,alone or in combination with other plant growth-promoting microbes as an eco-friendly microbial consortium,could increase the P uptake of crops,increasing their yields for agricultural and environmental sustainability.
Key Words:crop improvement,gene expression,microbial diversity,organic acid production,P mineralization,P solubilizer,phosphatase production,plant growth-promoting traits
The most vital macroelements required for plant growth is phosphorus(P),which builds up about 0.2% of plants on a dry weight basis.It is known to have both structural and metabolic functions in plants.It is a constituent of the nucleic acids and phospholipids present in biomembrane,and it is involved in the energy transfer mechanism in biological systems.In addition,it also makes an important contribution to seed formation,root elongation,disease tolerance,and cold tolerance in plants.The quality of fruits,grain crops,and vegetables is significantly influenced by the P uptake(Wiwartet al.,2009).Although the total amount of P in the soil may be high,it is often present in unavailable forms or in forms that are only available outside of the rhizosphere.Mineral forms of P include apatite,hydroxyapatite,and oxyapatite,and their characteristic feature is that they are poorly soluble.The organic P fraction is formed because of phosphodiesters,phospholipids,phosphotriesters,and nucleic acids(Piiet al.,2015;Jhaet al.,2018)and found in higher concentrations in fine-textured soils than in coarse-textured soils.The major reason for P unavailability is its precipitation with various metals such as aluminum,calcium,and iron in soil(Igualet al.,2001).
With scientific development and modernization in agricultural practices,the use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers is increasing so that high yields of crops can be obtained.The nutritional requirements of plants are easily fulfilled by chemical fertilizers,which can provide an array of macronutrients and micronutrients.Phosphatic fertilizers are used in recommended doses,as excessive use will harm the environment(Khanet al.,2007).However,the production of chemical fertilizers is a costly and highly energy-intensive process,requiring huge amounts of energy to meet the global demand.Furthermore,mining rates are so high that the depletion of the reserves will occur in about 500-600 years(Sharmaet al.,2013).Beyond this time,the processing of lower grade rock will be required for the production of Pbased fertilizers(Isherwood,2000).Thus,environmentalists and researchers are focusing on finding alternative strategies to address the problems associated with P solubilization in soil(Krishnaraj and Dahale,2014).There is a huge diversity of P-solubilizing microbes belonging to all three domains,comprising archaea,bacteria,and eukarya.They have the ability to solubilize insoluble P and make it available for the plants(Yadavet al.,2017a,2020).Their population accounts for 20%-40% of the total population of the rhizosphere and about 10%-15% of the total population of the bulk soil.Present review deals with the biodiversity of P-solubilizing microbes,mechanisms of P solubilization and mobilization,genes that are responsible for P solubilization and the important role these microbes play in the crop improvement for sustainable agriculture.
The solubilization of insoluble P by microbes was reported by Pikovskaya(1948).There is a vast diversity of bacterial,archaeal,and fungal strains with P-solubilizing capabilities.They are ubiquitous,but vary in their P-solubilizing capabilities.In soil,it has been estimated that 1%-50%of bacteria and 0.1%-0.5% of fungi can carry out P solubilization.They have been isolated from the rhizosphere,rhizoplane,phyllosphere,rock phosphate deposit areas,and even stressed soils and characterized using various culturable and unculturable techniques(Wakelinet al.,2004;Zaidiet al.,2009).Archaeal,bacterial,and fungal isolates that exhibit P-solubilizing activities are detected by the formation of clear halo zones,which indicate P solubilization around the colonies(Vermaet al.,2013,2015;Yadavet al.,2017b).However,the formation of halo zones on a solid agar medium should not be considered the only test for assessing the Psolubilizing capabilities of microbes;it is also important to perform additional tests in liquid media.Furthermore,after confirming in liquid medium,selected isolates could be tested for the production of different organic acids.Finally,isolates fulfilling the above-mentioned criteria should be tested on a model plant for ultimate confirmatory test of their P-solubilizing capability(Bashanet al.,2013).Viable microbial preparations exhibiting P-solubilizing activity are generally termed microphos(Zaidiet al.,2009).Factors such as the concentration of the iron ore,temperature,and availability of carbon and nitrogen(N)sources can affect the P-solubilizing potential of these microbes.Ammonium salts are known as best N sources for these microbes;other sources include asparagine,sodium nitrate,potassium nitrate,urea,and calcium nitrate(Ahujaet al.,2007).The P-solubilizing microbes that show great P solubilization underin vitroconditions may be selected further for bulk production so that they can be ultimately used by farmers.For instance,the fungiPenicillium bilaiae(Jump Start,Philom Bios,Saskatoon,Canada)andPenicillium radicum(PR-70 RELEASE,Bio-Care Technology,Somersby,Australia)have already been commercially released for improving P availability to plants(Zaidiet al.,2009).The isolation of P-solubilizing microbes from diverse habitats,characterization of their plant growth-promoting attributes,mechanisms of P solubilization,and possible biotechnological applications for agricultural sustainability are shown in Fig.1.
Phosphorous-solubilizing microbes can belong to diverse phyla,such as Actinobacteria,Ascomycota,Bacteroidetes,Basidiomycota,Euryarchaeota,Firmicutes,Mucoromycota,and Proteobacteria.One percent of P solubilizers belong to Bacteroidetes,and 6% belong to Actinobacteria.The most dominant phylum among bacteria is Proteobacteria(38%),followed by Firmicutes(22%).Nine percent of P-solubilizing archaea also belong to Euryarchaeota.Among P-solubilizing fungi,the least represented phyla are Mucoromycota(1%)and Basidiomycota(3%),whereas 20% of P-solubilizing fungi belong to Ascomycota(Fig.2a).In this review,about 551 P solubilizers have been reviewed from various sources(Table SI,see Supplementary Material for Table SI).The most predominant genus among P-solubilizing bacteria isBacillus,followed byPseudomonas,Acinetobacter,Streptomyces,Burkholderia,Serratia,Enterobacter,Paenibacillus,Stenotrophomonas,Staphylococcus,Arthrobacter,Pantoea,Methylobacterium,Alcaligenes,Azotobacter,Ochrobactrum,Rhizobium,Acetobacter,Achromobacter,Brevibacterium,Brevundimonas,Klebsiella,Leclercia,Lysinibacillus,Rhodococcus,Sphingomonas,Aeromonas,Azospirillum,Ensifer,Exiguobacterium,Microbacterium,Planococcus,Ustilago,andXanthomonas.Among the Psolubilizing fungi,most of the species belong to the genusAspergillus,followed byPenicillium,Fusarium,Trichoderma,Talaromyces,Meyerozyma,Candida,Pseudozyma,Arthroderma,Cryptococcus,Pichia,Eupenicillium,Paecilomyces,Rhodosporidium,Rhodotorula,Saccharomyces,andSporidiobolus.However,few P-solubilizing fungal species belonged toAgromyces,Bradyrhizobium,Corynebacterium,Erwinia,Herbaspirillum,Lecanicillium,Oceanobacillus,Psychrobacter,Rhodobacter,Sinorhizobium,andStreptococcus(Fig.2b).

Fig.1 A systemic representation for the isolation of P-solubilizing microbes from diverse habitats and characterization of their plant growth-promoting attributes,mechanisms of P solubilization,and possible biotechnological applications for agricultural sustainability.PEG=polyethylene glycol;ACC=aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid;PGP=plant-growth promotion.
Furthermore,regarding the phylogenetic profiling of P-solubilizing microbes,the most dominant phylum among bacteria is Proteobacteria,followed by Firmicutes.Proteobacteria consist of 49 diverse species belonging to 30 different genera,includingAeromonas,Acinetobacter,Acetobacter,Achromobacter,Alcaligenes,Azospirillum,Azotobacter,Bradyrhizobium,Brevundimonas,Burkholderia,Cronobacter,Cupriavidus,Delftia,Dyella,Ewingella,Herbaspirillum,Inquilinus,Methylobacterium,Ochrobactrum,Pantoea,Pseudomonas,Rahnella,Raoultella,Rhizobium,Rhodobacter,Serratia,Sphingomonas,Stenotrophomonas,Vibrio,andXanthomonas.Firmicutes consist of 43 species belonging to seven genera:24 belong toBacillus;8 toPaenibacillus;6 toStaphylococcus;2 toPlanococcus;and 1 each toBrevibacillus,Exiguobacterium,andOceanobacillus.Actinobacteria consist of 28 species which belong to 10 genera;the most dominant genera isStreptomyces(12 species),followed byArthrobacter,Brevibacterium,Microbacterium,Rhodococcus,Agromyces,Clavibacter,Corynebacterium,Micrococcus,andNocardiopsis.Another important phylum of P solubilizers is Euryarchaeota,comprising 18 species of archaea belonging to 10 genera,i.e.,Haloarcula,Halobacterium,Halococcus,Haloferax,Halolamina,Halostagnicola,Haloterrigena,Natrialba,Natrinema,andNatronoarchaeum.The lowest diversity of P-solubilizing bacteria is found in the phylum Bacteriodetes,consisting of five different species belonging to four genera:Chryseobacterium,Flavobacterium,Flexibacter,andSphingobacterium.Among P-solubilizing fungi,Ascomycota is the most dominant phylum with 16 species belonging to 7 genera,i.e.,Aspergillus,Curvularia,Eupenicillium,Paecilomyces,Penicillium,Sarocladium,andTrichoderma,followed by the phylum Basidiomycota with 11 species belonging to 8 genera,i.e.,Crytococcus,Pseudozyma,Rhodosporodium,Rhodotorula,Sporidiobolus,Symmetrospora,Trichosporon,andUstilago.Mucoromycota include only three species belonging to two genera,i.e.,AbsidiaandMucor(Figs.3-6).

Fig.2 Abundance of P-solubilizing microbes belonging to diverse phyla(a)and diversity and distribution of different predominant genera with P-solubilization attributes implicated in the P cycle.
Phosphorus-solubilizing microbes play an important role in the mitigation of different abiotic stresses(Yadav Aet al.,2015;Vermaet al.,2016,2019;Biswaset al.,2018).A review of literature shows that P-solubilizing microbes from extreme habitats,such as high/low-temperature,drought,salinity,heavy metal-contaminated,and acidic/alkaline environments,exhibit P-solubilizing and-mobilizing activities(Table SI).The highest diversity of P solubilizers is observed in high temperature environments,with 37 species belonging to 17 genera,i.e.,Achromobacter,Alcaligenes,Aneurinibacillus,Aspergillus,Bacillus,Chaetomium,Delftia,Fusarium,Methylobacterium,Mucor,Penicillium,Pseudomonas,Rhodobacter,Salmonella,Streptococcus,Streptomyces,andTrichoderma,followed by drought-and salinity-affected areas,each with 24 species.Drought-tolerant P solubilizers belong to 10 diverse genera:Alcaligenes,Aneurinibacillus,Aspergillus,Bacillus,Fusa-rium,Paenibacillus,Penicillium,Pseudomonas,Talaromyces,andTerribacillus.The P-solubilizing microbes from saline environments belong to 11 different genera:Acinetobacter,Aspergillus,Bacillus,Chaetomium,Delftia,Enterobacter,Penicillium,Pichia,Pseudomonas,Talaromyces,andTerribacillus.Seventeen species of P-solubilizing microbes have been observed from low-temperature conditions;they belong to eight genera:Acinetobacter,Aspergillus,Bacillus,Exiguobacterium,Paecilomyces,Pantoea,Pseudomonas,andTrichoderma.Sixteen species have been obtained from acidic and alkaline soils;they belong to nine genera:Achromobacter,Acinetobacter,Aspergillus,Bacillus,Exiguobacterium,Methylobacterium,Pichia,Pseudomonas,andTrichoderma.Fifteen species belonging to eight genera,i.e.,Azotobacter,Brevundimonas,Bacillus,Enterobacter,Pseudomonas,Fusarium,Methylobacterium,andMucor,have been obtained from heavy metal-contaminated soils.The generaBacillusandPseudomonashave been obtained from all stress environments(Fig.7,Table SI).
Phosphorus solubilizers have been reported to be isolated from plants including cereals(Vermaet al.,2015;Kouret al.,2019a;Yadav,2019),oil crops(Shahidet al.,2015),medicinal plants(Raiet al.,2018),fruit crops(Mehtaet al.,2015),and spice crops(Mishraet al.,2015;Panchami and Karthikeyan,2017).Among them,Acinetobacter,Azotobacter,Bacillus,Enterobacter,Paenibacillus,Pseudomonas,andSerratiaare common to all crops(Table SI),whereasChaetomiumandMicrobacterium,are only from barley,OchrobactrumandAgromycesfrom bitter gourd,MicrococcusandNocardiopsisfrom ginger,Brevibacterium,Lysobacter,andMethylobacteriumfromJatropha curcas,Candida,Clavispora,Eupenicillium,Ewingella,Meyerozyma,Rahnella,Rhizomucor,andSarocladiumfrom maize,RhizobiumandKlebsiellafrom pea,Aeromonas,Alcaligenes,andBrevibacteriumfrom rice,SinorhizobiumandAcremoniumfrom soybean,Cupriavidus,Chlorella,Flexibacter,Labrys,andMicrobisporafrom sugarcane,Cronobacter,Kocuria,andMucorfrom tomato,Rhodococcus,Brevundimonas,andCorynebacteriumfrom walnut,andExiguobacterium,Planococcus,andPlanomicrobiumfrom wheat(Fig.8).Phosphorus-solubilizing microbes can be endophytes,epiphytes,and inhabitants of both rhizospheric and bulk soils(Sumanet al.,2016;Vermaet al.,2017;Yadavet al.,2018;Kouret al.,2019c).Some of the isolates are niche specific,while others are present in more than one niche.Seventeen percent of them are only endophytic,10.6% epiphytic,7% rhizospheric soil,and 3% from bulk soil.Furthermore,1.1% are endophytic and from bulk soil,2% endophytic and rhizospheric,4.3% epiphytic and rhizospheric,5.3%epiphytic and from bulk soil,and 12.8% both rhizospheric and from bulk soil.Sixteen percent are present in all four niches mentioned above(Fig.9).
A huge diversity of bacteria isolated from alpine and sub-alpine regions are both tolerant to low temperature and can solubilize P.These includeAchromobactersp.,Acinetobacter rhizosphaerae,Bacillus megaterium,Bacillus subtilis,Burkholderia vietnamiensis,Exiguobacterium acetylicum,Mycobacterium phlei,Mycoplana bullata,Pantoea agglomerans,Pantoea dispersa,Pseudomonas corrugata,Pseudomonas fluorescens,Pseudomonas fragi,Pseudomonas lurida,Pseudomonas putida,Rahnellasp.,Serratia marcescens,andTetrathiobactersp.Among them,strains ofE.acetylicumare emerging as potential candidates for effi-cient bioinoculants in mountainous regions(Table SI).These strains have been also isolated from extreme environments,e.g.,Siberian permafrost,a glacial ice core sample in Greenland,and hot springs(Vishnivetskayaet al.,2009).Vazquezet al.(2000)reported nine strains of phosphate-solubilizing bacteria from the arid mangrove ecosystem in Mexico,including those isolated from the roots ofAvicennia germinans(black mangrove),Bacillus amyloliquefaciens,Bacillus atrophaeus,Enterobacter aerogenes,Enterobacter asburiae,Enterobacter taylorae,Kluyvera cryocrescens,Paenibacillus macerans,Vibrio proteolyticus,andXanthobacter agilis,and those isolated from the roots ofLanguncularia racemosa(white mangrove),Bacillus licheniformis,Pseudomonas luteola,andPseudomonas stutzeri.The halophilic P-solubilizing bacteriaKushneria sinocamishas been also observed in sediments of the Daqiao Saltern and could be used as an inoculant in salt-affected agricultural soils(Zhuet al.,2011).

Fig.3 Phylogenetic tree showing the relationships among different phyla of P-solubilizing microbes isolated from different hosts worldwide(a)and that with species of the phylum Actinobacteria listed(b).

Fig.4 Phylogenetic tree showing the relationships among different phyla of P-solubilizing microbes isolated from different hosts worldwide with species of the phylum Firmicutes listed.
Widawati and Suliasih(2001)reportedB.megateriumandPseudomonassp.as dominant P solubilizers from the rhizosphere of different plants in Gunung Halimun National Park,Indonesia,whereas Chenet al.(2006)showed tricalcium phosphate(TCP)solubilizingArthrobacter,Bacillus,Chryseobacterium,Delftia,Gordonia,Phyllobacterium,Rhodococcus,andSerratiain sub-tropical soils and reported four strains,Arthrobacter ureafaciens,Delftiasp.,Phyllobacterium myrsinacearum,andRhodococcus erythro-polis,for the first time as P solubilizers.Jianget al.(2008)reported a heavy metal-and antibiotic-resistant bacterial strain,Burkholderiasp.J62,from heavy metal-contaminated soils possessing the capability to solubilize inorganic P,producing siderophores,indole acetic acid(IAA),and 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid(ACC)deaminase,and increasing the biomass of maize and tomato plants.Naiket al.(2008b)reportedPseudomonas aeruginosa,P.fluorescens,Pseudomonas fulva,Pseudomonas mosselii,Pseudomonas monteilii,Pseudomonas plecoglossicida,Pseudomonas alcaligenesandPseudomonas pseudoalcaligenesfrom the rhizospheric soil of banana to be P solubilizers based on genotypic,phenotypic,and 16S rRNA gene phylogenetic analyses.In the study of Chang and Yang(2009),thermotolerant P-solubilizing bacteria,actinomycetes,and fungi were isolated from compost and biofertilizers,includingAspergillus fumigatus,Bacillus coagulans,B.licheniformis,Bacillus smithii,Brevibacillus borstelensis,Streptococcus thermophilus,andStreptomyces thermonitrificans.Kunduet al.(2009)reportedAeromonas,Enterobacter,Klebsiella,andPseudomonasas predominant P-solubilizing genera from the rhizosphere of chickpea,mustard,and wheat grown in different areas of Haryana,India.

Fig.5 Phylogenetic tree showing the relationships among different phyla of P-solubilizing microbes isolated from different hosts worldwide with species of the phyla Bacteroidetes and Proteobacteria listed.

Fig.6 Phylogenetic tree showing the relationships among different phyla of P-solubilizing microbes isolated from different hosts worldwide with species of the phyla Euryarchaeota,Basidiomycota,Mucoromycota,and Ascomycota listed.

Fig.7 Diversity and distribution of different niche-specific P-solubilizing microbes isolated from diverse extreme habitats.

Fig.8 Niche-specific P-solubilization microbes isolated from host plants.
Symbiotic N-fixing bacteria also have shown P-solubilizing activity(Zaidiet al.,2009).Liuet al.(2011)isolated P-solubilizing bacteriumP.fluorescensand P-mineralizing bacteriaBacillus cereusandB.subtilisfrom the rhizosphere of poplar from different regions of China.Ndung’u-Magiroiet al.(2012)studied the occurrence of P-solubilizing bacteria in soils of varied chemical properties in Kenya and identified several species includingArthrobacter,Bacillus,Burkholderia,Curtobacterium,Microbacterium,Micrococ-cus,Paenibacillus,andPseudomonas,withArthrobactersp.,B.megaterium,andPaenibacillussp.being the most abundant.The study of Ambrosiniet al.(2012)has found thatBurkholderiastrains associated with sunflower plants solubilize TCP.Yanget al.(2012)isolated 1 328 bacteria from P-rich soil in the drainage area of Dianchi Lake,China,with 377 isolates exhibiting TCP solubilization of 33.48-69.63 mg L−1and 123 isolates showing TCP solubilization of more than 54.00 mg L−1.Their analysis of restriction fragment length polymorphism(RFLP)revealed 32 unique RFLP patterns;on the basis of these patterns,they selected 62 representative isolates for 16S rRNA sequencing.Furthermore,on the basis of phylogenetic analysis,they found 123 P-solubilizing bacteria belonging to three phyla,Proteobacteria,Firmicutes,and Actinobacteria,107 isolates represented by 26 RFLP patterns being associated with the generaAcinetobacter,Burkholderia,Cedecea,Enterobacter,Klebsiella,Leclercia,Pseudomonas,Pantoea,Raoultella,andSerratia,with Firmicutes being the subdominant group,13 isolates being associated with the generaBacillusandBrevibacterium,and the remaining three isolates being identified as a species of the genusArthrobacter.
Inui-Kishiet al.(2012)identifiedArthrobactersp.,Burkholderia gladioli,Burkholderiasp.,Chlorella protothecoides,Enterobacter homaechei,Enterobactersp.,Flexibacter sancti,andLabrys portucalensisas P solubilizers from the rhizosphere of sugarcane.Nabtiet al.(2013)isolated halophilicB.licheniformisandBacillussp.from the rhizosphere of potato and reported their P-solubilizing ability and other plant growth-promoting attributes.de Souzaet al.(2013)observed thatBurkholderia,Cedecea,Cronobacter,Enterobacter,Pantoea,andPseudomonasassociated with rice plants could solubilize TCP.KumarVet al.(2013)isolated phytase-producingAchromobactersp.,Tetrathiobactersp.,andBacillussp.from soil samples collected from the Uttarakhand region of India,with the capacity to mineralize and solubilize P.Harinathanet al.(2014)identifiedEnterobacter cancerogenusas an efficient P solubilizer from the rhizospheric soil ofMorinda tinctoriaandProsopis juliflora.
Bumunang and Babalola(2014)isolated rhizobacteria from field-grown genetically modified and non-genetically modified maize in South Africa after 30 d of sowing and post-harvest,screened the isolates for various plant growthpromoting attributes,including P solubilization,ammonia,IAA,and hydrogen cyanide(HCN)production,and catalase and antifungal activities,and reported 90.6% of the isolates as P solubilizers,includingBurkholderia cepacia,P.luteola,P.putida,Sphingomonas paucimobilis,andStenotrophomonas maltophiliafrom genetically modified maize andAchromobacter xylosoxidans,Bacillus safensis,B.cepacia,Ewingella americana,P.putida,P.stutzeri,S.maltophilia,andS.paucimobilisfrom non-genetically modified maize.Nandiniet al.(2014)isolated P-solubilizingAlcaligenes faecalisfrom the rhizospheric soil of upland rice.Shahidet al.(2015)identified the P-solubilizing bacteriaA.faecalisandBacillussp.from sunflower plants and soils collected from various locations in Pakistan on the basis of 16S rRNA.In the study of Mishraet al.(2015),P-solubilizing bacteria were isolated from rhizospheric soils of fennel(Foeniculum vulgareMill.)from Rajasthan,India,withBacillussp.andPseudomonassp.being the dominant genera.Aarabet al.(2015a)found 136 TCP solubilizers,out of 305 rhizobacteria isolated from the rhizospheric soil of rice in Northern Morocco,withAeromonas,Pseudomonas,andEnterobacterbeing the dominant genera as revealed by analysis of 16S rDNA.Aarabet al.(2015b)also isolated 283 bacteria belonging to the genusPseudomonasfrom the rhizospheric soil of rice,with 67.14% of the isolates possessing the capability to solubilize P.
Yadav Aet al.(2015)isolated P-solubilizing haloarchaea from sediment,water,and rhizospheric soil in Rann of Kutch,Gujrat,and identified them asHaloarculasp.,Halobacteriumsp.,Halococcussp.,Haloferaxsp.,Halolaminasp.,Halosarcinasp.,Halostagnicolasp.,Haloterrigenasp.,Natrialbasp.,Natrinemasp.,andNatronoarchaeumsp.Midekssaet al.(2015)isolated 41 P-solubilizing rhizobacteria from lentil,including generaAcinetobacter,Agrobacterium,Bacillus,Burkholderia,Chryseomonas,Enterobacter,Pseudomonas,Ralstonia,andSphingomonas,and evaluated their effects on the growth of lentil under greenhouse conditions.Chauhanet al.(2017)isolated the Psolubilizing strainAneurinibacillus aneurinilyticusCKMV1 from the rhizosphere ofValeriana jatamansiand found P solubilization of 260 mg L−1.Bashiret al.(2018)isolated P-solubilizing rhizobacteria from apple and characterized them on a morphological and biochemical basis.
A few studies have been carried out on yeasts for their capability to solubilize P includingYarrowia lipolytica,Schizosaccharomyces pombe,andPichia fermentans(Vassilevet al.,2001).Among the filamentous fungi,the dominant P-solubilizing genera includeAspergillusandPenicillium(Feniceet al.,2000;Khan and Khan,2002).Some strains ofTrichoderma(Altomareet al.,1999)andRhizoctonia solani(Jacobset al.,2002)have also been reported to be P solubilizers.Duponnoiset al.(2006)reported the nematophagous fungusArthrobotrys oligosporato be a P solubilizer both underin vitroandin vivoconditions.Pandeyet al.(2008)identified the P solubilizersPenicillium citrinum,Penicillium janthinellum,Penicillium oxalicum,Penicillium pinetorum,Penicillium pinophilum,Penicillium purpurogenum,andPenicillium raistrickiiisolated from soils of Indian Himalayan region.Yasseret al.(2014)isolatedTrichoderma harzianum,Trichoderma koningii,Penicillium variable,P.purpurogenum,Penicillium funiculosum,Penicillium expansum,Aspergillus niger,andAspergillus japonicasfrom Egyptian soils to solubilize inorganic phosphate.Potshangbamet al.(2017)isolated endophytic P-solubilizing fungi,includingAcremoniumsp.,Aspergillus ustus,Fusarium oxysporum,Penicillium simplicissimum,Rhizomucorsp.,Sarocladium strictum,andTrichoderma koningiopsis,from maize and rice plants.
The ability of actinomycetes to solubilize P has attracted great attention.Hamdaliet al.(2008)reported that 20%of actinomycetes solubilize P,and the dominant genera areStreptomycesandMicromonospora.Joget al.(2014)isolated P-solubilizingStreptomyces cellulosae,Streptomyces cheonanensis,Streptomyces lomondensis,andStreptomyces werraensisfrom the rhizosphere of wheat.Gangwaret al.(2015)isolated endophyticStreptomyces cinereusandStreptomyces griseofuscus,P solubilizers,from Indian gooseberry plants.
The important processes affecting P concentrations are dissolution-precipitation and sorption-desorption.The main mechanisms employed for P solubilization by soil microorganisms consist of the release of complexing or mineral-dissolving compounds,such as organic acid anions,siderophores,protons,hydroxyl ions,and CO2,and the liberation of various extracellular enzymes(Table I).
High-molecular-weight organic forms of P cannot be taken up by the plants directly and are usually transformed into inorganic forms after being mineralized.Organictransformation and mineralization are catalyzed by different soil enzymes.The phosphatases in soil hydrolyze soil organic P into its inorganic forms,such as HPO−4and H2PO−4,before it can be utilized and taken up from the soil solution by the plant roots.Phosphatases are capable of hydrolyzing both phosphate ester and anhydride bonds,including acid and alkaline phosphatases,diadenosine tetraphosphatases,exonucleases,phosphoprotein phosphatases,phosphodiestrases,5′-nucleotidases,phytases,and acid phosphomonoesterases(Nannipieriet al.,2011).The mineralization of organic P by microbes is strongly influenced by the environmental parameters;in fact,mineralization is mostly favored in environments with moderate alkalinity.There are non-specific acid phosphatases,which can cause dephosphorylation of the phosphoester or phosphoanhydride bonds present in the organic matter.Many soil microbial species,includingAspergillus,Bacillus,Mucor,Penicillium,Rhizopus,Pseudomonas,and mycorrhizal hyphae,are known to produce phosphatases(Beheraet al.,2014;Shrivastavaet al.,2018).

TABLE IOrganic acids produced during the solubilization process by P-solubilizing microbes
Acid phosphatases dominate in acidic soils,whereas alkaline phosphatases dominate in neutral and alkaline soils(Yuet al.,2006).The release of the orthophosphate ions HPO−4and H2PO−4from organic forms of P in soil is mediated by both plants and phosphatases,with an indication that the phosphatases produced by the microbes are more efficient(Tarafdaret al.,2001).There are a number of acid phosphatase genes isolated and characterized from Gramnegative bacteria.One example is the geneacpA,isolated fromFrancisella tularensis,expressing an acid phosphatase with optimum activity at pH 6 and a wide range of substrate specificity(Reillyet al.,1996).A gene fromB.cepaciafacilitating phosphatase activity has also been isolated(Rodríguezet al.,2000).Additionally,two non-specific periplasmic acid phosphatase genes,napDandnapE,fromSinorhizobium melilotihave also been cloned(Denget al.,1998,2001).Acid phosphatases have also been reported to be from the fungusAspergillus tubengensis(Achalet al.,2007).
Most phytases are high-molecular-weight acid phosphatases catalyzing the release of P from phytate,which is an ester of inositol and the major stored P form in seeds and pollens(Rodríguezet al.,2006).The capability of the plants to directly obtain P from phytate is very limited.The study of Richardsonet al.(2001b)demonstrates the enhancement in growth and P nutrition ofArabidopsisgenetically modified with the genephyAfromA.nigerwith supply of phytate.It has also been reported that the enhanced utilization of inositol phosphate by plants occurs in the presence of soil microorganisms(Richardsonet al.,2001a).The phytase genesappAandappA2fromEscherichia coliwere also isolated and characterized(Golovanet al.,1999;Rodrıìguezet al.,1999).Neutral phytase genes fromB.subtilisandB.licheniformishave also been cloned(Tyeet al.,2002).The genephyAfrom the plant growth-promoting bacteriaB.amyloliquefaciens(Idrisset al.,2002)possesses the highest extracellular phytase activity;additionally,diluted culture filtrates of these strains stimulate the growth of maize seedlings when grown under limited P conditions in the presence of phytate.Kumar Vet al.(2013)reported growth promotion ofBrassica junceaand increase in its P content with phytase-producing bacteria such asTetrathiobactersp.andBacillussp.
In the study of Yadav and Tarafdar(2003),Aspergillus,Emmericella,andPenicilliumisolated from arid and semiarid regions of India showed phytin-and glycerophosphatehydrolyzing activity.In the study of Zhaoet al.(2017),Trichoderma asperellumQ1 isolated from the rhizosphere of cucumber produced acid and alkaline phosphatases and showed high P-solubilizing activity and purified acid phosphatases contributed to the growth ofArabidopsis thaliana.This study is the first report on purification of acid phosphatase fromT.asperellumand its role in stimulating the growth of plants under salt stress.
All of these reports mentioned above directly confirm that phytase activity plays an important role in stimulating plant growth on limited-P soil,thus supporting the potential use of phytase genes for the improvement or transfer of P-solubilizing traits to plant growth-promoting bacterial strains used as agricultural bioinoculants.Furthermore,there are a number of bacteria that have been isolated from the rhizospheric soils of different plants,such asAvena sativa,Lolium perenne,Lupinus luteus,andTrifolium repens;they have been reported to be helpful in both the production of organic acids for the solubilization of inorganic P and the production of phytase to mineralize phytate(Jorqueraet al.,2011).
A broad range of mechanisms exist in nature for P solubilization by bacteria and fungi.The major mechanism for the solubilization of inorganic P is the production of organic acids by microbes,which lowers the pH of the rhizospheric soil or chelates the cations that are responsible for P precipitation.They may compete with P for sorption sites on the soil or may form the soluble complexes with metal ions associated with insoluble P compounds,such as phosphates of aluminum,calcium,and iron(Shrivastavaet al.,2018).Thus,the produced organic acids directly dissolve the mineral P(Omar,1997).Organic acids commonly produced by P solubilizers include aspartic acid,citric acid,gluconic acid,lactic acid,oxalic acid,and tartaric acid(Venkateswarluet al.,1984;Kimet al.,1997;Di Simineet al.,1998;Bar-Yosefet al.,1999).Rodrıìguezet al.(2004)studied the formation of acid and phosphate solubilization byAzospirillum brasilenseandAzospirillum lipoferum.Both species were found to produce gluconic acid when grown in a sparingly soluble calcium phosphate medium,reducing the pH of the medium and releasing soluble P.Vilcramet al.(2007)tested P-solubilizing bacteria for the production of organic acids,such as fumaric,citric,gluconic,maleic,tartaric,and succinic acid,as well as other unidentified acids and found production of all the six organic acids by the strain PSBV-9 and only five organic acids by PSBV-10,PSBV-25,and PSBV-16.Hariprasad and Niranjana(2009)reported the increased growth inLycopersicon esculentumbecause of the presence ofEnterobactersp.,which produced gluconic acid,solubilizing calcium phosphate.However,acidification alone is not the universal mechanism of solubilization;there are some reports that show microbial P solubilization without the production of organic acids.For example,Altomareet al.(1999)showed thatT.harzianumsolubilizes P without the detection of organic acids.Moreover,NitrosomonasandThiobacillusproduce only nitric and sulfuric acids,which may solubilize P(Teotiaet al.,2016;Bahaduret al.,2017).
Exopolysaccharides are carbohydrates polymers that are excreted by some bacteria and fungi outside their cell walls.They may either be homopolysaccharides or heteropolysaccharides and may have numerous different organic and inorganic substituents.Exopolysaccharides can form complexes with metals in soil.Yiet al.(2008)reported that P solubilizers such asArthrobactersp.,Azotobactersp.,andEnterobactersp.produce a significant amount of exopolysaccharides.Takteket al.(2017)showed that exopolysaccharide-producing rhizobacteria solubilize igneous phosphate rock by secreting viable biofilm cells and organic acids.
Arbuscular mycorrhizal(AM)fungi.Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi are greatly beneficial to the majority of plant cultivars and play an important role in the conservation of the environment by acting as biofertilizers,biocontrol agents,and bioprotectors(Azcón-Aguilaret al.,2002;Thilagar and Bagyaraj,2015).These soil fungi are known to aid in the uptake of diffusion-limited nutrients(particularly P)and increase crop production(Joner,2000;Gaur and Adholeya,2002).According to Joneset al.(1998),the efficiency of mycorrhizal plants in the uptake of P is about 3.1-4.7 times higher than that of nonmycorrhizal plants.The AM fungi in agriculture can reduce the use of chemical fertilizers and help in sustaining plant productivity and retaining soil quality(Surendran and Vani,2013).Hence,one of the best alternatives to increase the P supply to plants is using AM fungi as inoculants(Osorio and Habte,2001).Thilagar and Bagyaraj(2015)inoculated chilly plants with diverse species of AM fungi,such asAcaulospora laevis,Gigaspora margarita,Glomus bagyarajii,Glomus etunicatum,Glomus fasciculatum,Glomus intraradices,Glomus leptotichum,Glomus macrocarpum,Glomus monosporum,Glomus mosseae,andScutellospora calosporaand found thatG.mosseaeis the best in terms of bio-volume index,fruit yield,P uptake,and plant biomass.Kumar Aet al.(2016a)concluded that AM fungal inoculation can potentially increase system productivity and profitability,decreasing the inorganic P requirement by about 25% in an okra-pea production system on Himalayan acid Alfisol.Furthermore,it has been well demonstrated that the combined inoculation of arbuscular mycorrhizas and Psolubilizing microbes results in an improved uptake of both native P from soil and P from phosphatic rock(Cabelloet al.,2005).Rattiet al.(2001)inoculatedCymbopogon martiniiwith the AM fungusGlomus aggregatum,the P-solubilizing rhizobacteriumBacillus polymyxa,and the N2-fixing bacteriumA.brasilense.They found that these rhizobacteria behave as mycorrhiza helper bacteria and increase root colonization byG.aggregatumin the presence of TCP.Dutta and Neog(2017)evaluated the roles that AM fungi and plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria play in modulating P dynamics in the rhizosphere of turmeric.
Piriformospora indica.Piriformospora indica,a basidiomycete fungal endophyte,has attained significant interest as a potential growth-promoting agent(Chhabra and Dowling,2017).This endophyte was originally reported to be from the roots of xerophytic woody shrubs such asP.julifloraandZizyphus nummulariain the Thar Desert,India(Varmaet al.,1999;Johnsonet al.,2014).It is easily cultivable and endophytically colonizes the roots of many agricultural,floricultural,horticultural,medicinal,and agroforestry plants(Oelmülleret al.,2009;Johnsonet al.,2014).It can promote plant growth,stimulate seed production,and possesses broad host-range specificity(Singhet al.,2000,2011).It has many properties similar to AM fungi and possesses the capability to colonize the roots of a broad range of higher plants,including those that cannot form symbioses with AM fungi,thus promoting nutrient uptake,disease resistance,stress tolerance,and growth of their hosts(Hosseiniet al.,2017;Hussinet al.,2017;Xuet al.,2017;Wuet al.,2018).It could act as a model system to study the mechanisms responsible for host growth or fitness;it is capable of mobilizing unavailable P for plant uptake by producing extracellular phosphatases(Singhet al.,2000;Thilagar and Bagyaraj,2015).This endophyte can solubilize P from inorganic sources by decreasing the pH of the medium(Ngweneet al.,2016).The high-affinity phosphate transporter PiPT isolated from an endophyte has been identified and functionally characterized as being essential for the transport of P to the host plant(Yadavet al.,2010).However,the mechanism of P transport from the fungus to the host is not clear;it has been hypothesized that the transfer process may occur at the plant-fungus interface and requires two transporters,one enabling the P efflux from the fungus and the other mediating the P uptake by the host plant(Rausch and Bucher,2002).It has been suggested thatP.indicacould be used in the field as a biocontrol agent,biofertilizer,bioregulator,or growth and yield stimulator(Mallaet al.,2004).
The mineral P-dissolving ability of bacteria is associated with the production of organic acid(Rodrıguez and Fraga,1999).The direct oxidation of glucose to gluconic acid has been proposed by Goldstein(1994)as the main mechanism for mineral phosphate solubilization in Gram-negative bacteria.The biosynthesis of gluconic acid is carried out by the enzyme glucose dehydrogenase(GDH),which is a quinoprotein enzyme and requires pyrroloquinoline quinone(PQQ)as a redox co-factor.There are two types of GDHs,GDH-A and GDH-B.Various bacterial species,such asAcinetobacter calcoaceticus,Acinetobacter lwoffii,E.coli,Gluconobacter suboxydans,Klebsiella aerogenes,andP.aeruginosa,can contain GDH-A,which is a membrane-bound enzyme,whereas GDH-B,a soluble enzyme,is only reported inA.calcoaceticus(Cleton-Jansenet al.,1988).
Various genes involved in mineral phosphate solubilization have been isolated from different species(Table II).Expression of genes involved in mineral phosphate solubilization fromErwinia herbicolainE.coliHB101 allows the production of gluconic acid and confers the capacity to solubilize hydroxyapatite(Liuet al.,1992).Kimet al.(1998)cloned genes(mps)expressing the mineral phosphatesolubilizing trait fromRahnella aquatilisinE.coliHB101,resulting in higher amounts of soluble phosphate and gluconic acid thanR.aquatilis.Kimet al.(2003)included the genepqqfrom rhizobacteriaEnterobacter intermedium60-2G,expressing the capability to solubilize insoluble P into the genome ofE.coliDH5α,ultimately conferring the capability to solubilize P from hydroxyapatite by decreasing its pH.Sashidhar and Podile(2009)induced the GDH gene(gcd)fromE.coliinto the genome ofAzotobacter vinelandiiAvOP,and bacterized seeds of sorghum with transgenicAzotobacterexpressing the genegcd,increasing the mineral phosphate solubilization potential.Milleret al.(2010)screened a transposon mutant library ofP.fluorescensF113 for mutants with a reduced capacity of solubilizing TCP.They found that mutations in thegcdandpqqEgenes greatly reduce the capability to solubilize P,whereas mutations in the genepqqBonly moderately affect the P-solubilizing capacity.Their study revealed that changes in thepqqbiosynthetic genes and the presence or absence of the gluconate dehydrogenase gene(gad)essentially affect the P-solubilizing capability of strains ofP.fluorescens.
In the study of Kumar Cet al.(2013),Enterobacter asburiaePS13,an efficient P solubilizer,was modified to express the gluconate dehydrogenase operon(gad)ofP.putidaKT2440 so that it could produce 2-ketogluconic acid,and the modifiedE.asburiaePSI3 harboring the operongadsecreted about 11.63 mmol L−1of 2-ketogluconic and 21.65 mmol L−1of gluconic acids and solubilized 0.84 mmol L−1of P from rock phosphate.Waghet al.(2014)over-expressed the genepqqEofE.herbicolaand thepqqgene clusters ofP.fluorescensB16 andA.calcoaceticusinthe genome ofHerbaspirillum seropedicaeZ67 and found that the transformants ofH.seropedicaeZ67 wild-type strain pSS2 and pOK53 attain a high GDH activity and secret about 33.46 mmol L−1of gluconic acid and 125.47 and 168.07µmol L−1of P,respectively.

TABLE IIGenes and gene expression in P solubilization attributes from P-solubilizing microbes
Diverse novel species of P-solubilizing microbes has been reported from various sources,such as rhizosphere soils(Madhaiyanet al.,2015),medicinal plants(Suarezet al.,2014;Nguyenet al.,2015),cereal crops(Loganathan and Nair,2004;Witzelet al.,2012),fresh water(Liet al.,2017),and bulk soils(Leeet al.,2011;Toroet al.,2013;Guoet al.,2015;Kanget al.,2019)(Table III).
The genome sequences may be analyzed to obtain the complete genetic information,obtain insight into beneficial traits,and thus elucidate plant-microbe interactions.In the last few decades,we have obtained information on the genome sequences of diverse P-solubilizing microbes,such asR.aquatilisHX2,Raoultella ornithinolyticaTNT,Pantoeasp.3.5.1,andOchrobactrum intermediumSA148 isolated from soil(Guoet al.,2012;Thijset al.,2014;Suleimanovaet al.,2015;Lafiet al.,2017),P.putidaMTCC5279 fromCicer arietinum(Chaudhryet al.,2013),Pantoeasp.AS-PWVM4 andParaburkholderia tropicaP-31 fromPunica granatum(Khatriet al.,2013;Kauret al.,2016),Arthrobacter agilisL77 from a subglacial lake(Singhet al.,2016),Enterobacter cloacaeGS1,Bacillus altitudinisLc5,andPantoea ananatis1.38 fromOryza sativa(Shankaret al.,2012;Megíaset al.,2018;Potshangbamet al.,2018),Serratia fonticolaAU-AP2C fromPisum sativum(Deviet al.,2013b),andCaulobacter flavusRHGG3TfromCitrullus lanatus(Yanget al.,2019)(Table IV).
Phosphorus-solubilizing microbes can enhance plant growth by changing the concentrations of various phytohormones such as IAA(Waniet al.,2007a,b),carrying out symbiotic or asymbiotic N fixation and soil conditioning by synthesizing siderophores(Vassilevet al.,2006),exhibiting biocontrol activity(Pandeyet al.,2006),producing antibiotics and HCN(Yanget al.,2008),synthesizing ACC deaminase(Anandhamet al.,2008;Poonguzhaliet al.,2008),and reducing the toxicity of heavy metals(Khanet al.,2009).All of these growth-promoting abilities of Psolubilizing microbes vary under different ecological niches(Table V).The microbes that solubilize P can simultaneously produce IAA;a few genera ofRhizobiacan both solubilize P and secrete IAA(Pandey and Maheshwari,2007;Badawiet al.,2011);they act as biocontrol agents and suppress various soil-borne phytopathogens,thereby enhancing the growth of plants(Anbuselviet al.,2015;Ndungu-Magiroiet al.,2015;Kouret al.,2019b,2020).For example,P-solubilizing microbes can simultaneously synthesize and release various pathogen-suppressing metabolites,such as siderophores and lytic enzymes(Pandeyet al.,2006;Raneet al.,2008).Various P-solubilizing bacteria,such asChromobacteriumviolaceum,P.aeruginosa,andP.fluorescens,can secreteantibiotics(Yanget al.,2008),thus providing protection to plants against soil-borne pathogens(Vassilevet al.,2006).Phosphate-solubilizing filamentous fungi show biocontrol activity againstFusariumwilt in tomato,andP.putidaalso shows antifungal activity and produces chitinase,β-1,3-glucanase,salicylic acid,siderophore,and HCN(Khan and Khan,2001).Furthermore,in a maize-based bioassay under greenhouse conditions,it was demonstrated that bacterial inoculation increases the plant biomass,stimulating bacterial and suppressing fungal abundance in the rhizosphere(Pandeyet al.,2006;Zaidiet al.,2009).

TABLE IVGenome sequencing data of P-solubilizing microbes isolated from diverse habitats worldwide
Chang and Yang(2009)reported that thermotolerant Psolubilizing microbes,such asB.coagulans,B.licheniformis,B.smithii,B.borstelensis,Streptomyces thermophilus,S.thermonitrificans,andA.fumigatus,possess different hydrolytic enzyme activities,except forS.thermophilusJ57,which lacks pectinase activity.Naiket al.(2008a)observed that P-solubilizing bacteria,such asP.fulva,P.fluorescens,P.mosselii,P.monteilii,P.plecoglossicida,andP.putida,produce siderophores,some show the production of IAA,ACC deaminase,chitinase,pectinase,and cellulase,and some have both proteolytic and antifungal activities.Selvakumaret al.(2009)found thatE.acetylicum(1P)isolated from the rhizosphere ofMalus domesticashows growth from at temperature from 4 to 42°C,can tolerate pH from 4 to 10 and up to 8% salt,produces IAA,HCN,and siderophores simultaneously at 4°C,and shows P-solubilizing ability at this suboptimal temperature.

TABLE VDiverse sources for and amount of P solubilized by P-solubilizing microbes isolated worldwide

TABLE V(continued)
The phytase-producing and P-solubilizing bacteriaAchromobactersp.,Tetrathiobactersp.,andBacillussp.can grow at wide ranges of pH,temperature,and salt and produce IAA and siderophores(Kumar Vet al.,2013).Bumunang and Babalola(2014)screened the rhizobacteria isolated from genetically and non-genetically modified maize for various plant growth-promoting attributes,including P solubilization,ammonia production,catalase activity,IAA production,HCN production,and antifungal activity,and found that 90.6% of the isolates are P solubilizers:those isolated from genetically modified maize,B.cepacia,P.luteola,S.maltophilia,P.putida,andS.paucimobilis,all show IAA,ammonia,and catalase production,with some showing antifungal activity;those isolated from non-genetically modified maize,A.xylosoxidans,B.safensis,B.cepacia,E.americana,P.stutzeri,P.putida,S.paucimobilis,andS.maltophilia,all produce IAA,ammonia,and catalase,with two showing antifungal activity.
Chauhanet al.(2017)reported that the P-solubilizingA.aneurinilyticusCKMV1 shows multiple plant growthpromoting traits,such as N fixation,the production of IAA,siderophores,and HCN,and antifungal activity againstAlternariasp.,Dematophora necatrix,F.oxysporum,Phytophthorasp.,R.solani,andSclerotium rolfsii.Afzalet al.(2017)isolated endophytic bacteria,belonging to the generaAgrococcus,Bacillus,Brevundimonas,Inquilinus,Microbacterium,Pseudomonas,Rhizobium,Stenotrophomonas,Streptomyces,andXanthomonas,fromDodonaea viscose;they found that some of the isolates solubilize P and produce cellulase,pectinase,protease,siderophores,HCN,and ACC deaminase and some show antifungal activity,with all isolates being IAA and ammonia producers.Sánchez-Cruzet al.(2019)isolatedSerratiasp.andEnterobactersp.fromMimosa pudicaroot nodules;they found that these bacteria possess P-solubilizing capabilities and other plant growth-promoting attributes,including the production of IAA,siderophores,chitinase,and cellulase,as well as N fixation.Singhet al.(2019)isolatedA.calcoaceticus,Azotobactersp.,Bacillus aerius,B.amyloliquefaciens,Bacillus mucilaginous,B.subtilis,Ralstoniasp.,andS.maltophiliafromMomordica charantia;they found that these strains all possess P-solubilizing capabilities and produce IAA and ammonia and some of them also produce siderophores and HCN.
To increase the growth and yield of crops,large amounts of chemical fertilizers are demanded.However,the increases in the costs of these chemical fertilizers and environmental concerns regarding them have led to the development of alternative strategies,i.e.,the use of beneficial soil microbes.Thus,P-solubilizing microbes with diverse plant growth-promoting attributes can be used as inoculants for the mobilization of P from poorly available sources in soil.Thus,screening potential P-solubilizing isolates and using them as bioinoculants to increase plant growth and yield is recognized as an area of interest.
Extensive studies have been performed to demonstrate the effect of inoculating of crops with P-solubilizing bacteria and fungi isolated from different environments.Of these,the pseudomonads are by far the most pertinent cold-tolerant P solubilizers that have been identified and tested so far,followed by species ofBacillus.These cold-tolerant P solubilizers possess attractive traits,for instance,N fixation and antagonism against phytopathogens(Pandeyet al.,2006;Mishraet al.,2008;Bashanet al.,2016).Accordingly,the growth-promoting capabilities ofPseudomonasisolates have been tested on an array of crops,including mung bean,wheat,rice,and lentil(Egamberdiyeva and Höflich,2003;Katiyar and Goel,2003;Trivedi and Sa,2008;Mishraet al.,2008,2009;Selvakumaret al.,2011).Cold-tolerantBacillusstrains have also been used to promote the growth of lentil,rice,millet,and Indian mustard(Malviyaet al.,2012;Kumar Vet al.,2013).
The improved growth ofC.arietinumandHordeum vulgare,as well as increased N and P contents in them,has been observed after inoculation withMesorhizobium mediterraneumpossessing N2-fixing as well as P-solubilizing capabilities,with further improvements after concomitant application ofM.mediterraneumand Ca3(PO4)2(Peixet al.,2001).Wakelinet al.(2004,2005)reported that inoculation withP.radicumincrease wheat growth on neutral-to-alkaline sandy soils.Duponnoiset al.(2006)observed an increase in the P uptake and shoot dry weight ofAcacia holosericeawhen inoculated with the fungusA.oligospora,with further increase in plant P uptake and growth after addition of rock phosphate with P-solubilizing microbes.Shinet al.(2006)reported that inoculation withP.oxalicum,either alone or with fused phosphates and rock phosphate,increases the growth and N and P contents ofZea maysplants.Ganesan(2008)reported that inoculation withP.aeruginosa,a cadmium-resistant P solubilizer with other plant growthpromoting traits,reduces metal toxicity in black gram grown on soil treated with a gradient of CdCl2concentrations.Ekin(2010)showed that inoculation with P-solubilizingBacillussp.improves the P mobilization in sunflower,as well as the seed quality and oil yield.
Viruelet al.(2014)studied the effect of inoculation with P-solubilizing bacteria,such asE.aerogenes,P.agglomerans,Pantoea eucalypti,Pseudomonas koreensis,Pseudomonas tolaasii,andS.marcescens,on the growth and yield of maize.They found significant increases in height and shoot dry weight,as well as P content,of plants treated withP.tolaasiicompared to those of the uninoculated control.The study of Midekssaet al.(2015)indicates that inoculation withBacillussp.,B.subtilis,Enterobacter kobei,Enterobactersp.,andP.fluorescensimprove the growth,nodulation,and N and P contents of lentil shoots.Chauhanet al.(2017)isolated the P-solubilizing rhizobacterial strainA.aneurinilyticusCKMV1 fromV.jatamansi,characterized its production of IAA,siderophores,and HCN,as well as its antifungal activity,and assessed its plant growth-promoting traits using tomato under net house conditions.They observed significant increases in seed germination,shoot length,root length,shoot dry weight,and root dry weight,along with N,P,and K contents.Hassanet al.(2017)observed increases in the plant height,branches per plant,leaves per plant,pods per plant,seeds per plant,pod length,1 000-seed weight,number of effective nodules,nodule density,chlorophyllaandbcontents,carotenoid content,protein content,and proline content of mung bean inoculated with two P solubilizers,B.polymyxaandPseudomonas striata,with increased P and N contents in soil and the uptake of macronutrients,including N,P,K,Ca,and Mg,in the roots and shoots of the plant,compared to those in the non-inoculated control.
There are several reports on the application of Psolubilizing microbes in agronomic practices,either individually or in combination,to assess their effects on the growth and biomass production of several crops(Table VI).A biofertilizer product under the trade name Phosphobacterin,which actually containsB.megateriumvar.phosphaticum,has soon been introduced to Eastern Europe and India after its commercialization in former Soviet Union(Khanet al.,2007).Similarly,a consortium with efficient P solubilizers,such asP.striata,B.polymyxa,Aspergillus awamori,A.niger,andPenicillium digitatum,termed the Indian Agricultural Research Institute(IARI)microphos culture(Gaur,1990),was developed in India(Khanet al.,2010).
Chlorophyll content in barley increases after application of mycorrhiza along withP.putida(Bartholdyet al.,2001).Bareaet al.(2002)reported an increased P uptake in several legumes fertilized with rock phosphate and inoculated with P-solubilizing rhizobacteria,mycorrhizal fungi,andRhizobiumin combination.Sonet al.(2006)studied the effect of inoculation withBradyrhizobium japonicumand P-solubilizing bacteriaPseudomonassp.with different rates of inorganic N fertilizer and biofertilizer on soybean in rotational system.Akhtar and Siddiqui(2009)studied the effects of P-solubilizing microorganisms,A.awamori,G.intraradices,P.aeruginosa,P.alcaligenes,P.putida,andRhizobiumsp.,on the growth,nodulation,yield,and root-rot disease complex of chickpea under field conditions and found root galling was reduced mostly by inoculation withP.putidafollowed byP.aeruginosa,P.alcaligenes,G.intraradices,andA.awamori,withRhizobiumsp.showing a similar reduction in galling toP.putida.
Malviyaet al.(2011)reported that inoculation of ground nut(Arachis hypogaea)plants with the P-solubilizing fungiA.nigerandPenicillium notatumin combination significantly increases the dry matter,yield,protein and oil percentages,and N and P contents of ground nut plants.The inoculation with P-solubilizing bacteriaB.megateriumalong with the potential N-fixerAzotobactersp.can induce resistance against the harmful effects of salinity while simultaneously improving the growth and yield of wheat(Krishnaraj and Dahale,2014).The inoculation of foxtail millet withA.lipoferumand P-solubilizing bacteria alone or in combination can increase the plant height,root and shoot dry weights,and panicle and seed weights(Rafiet al.,2017).The inoculation of mung bean with the P-solubilizing isolatesP.agglomeransPSB-1andBurkholderia anthinaPSB-2 would enhance the shoot and root lengths,shoot and root dry matter,and P uptake of the plant(Charana Walpola and Yoon,2013).The synergistic effect of the P-solubilizing bacteriaP.fluorescensandB.cepaciawith the AM fungusG.etunicatumwas studied using wheat plants grown in pots with nutrient-deficient soils and amended with TCP,and significant increases in the growth,yield,and nutrient uptake of the plants were observed(Minaxiet al.,2013).

TABLE VIMultifarious plant growth-promoting attributes of P-solubilizing microbes

TABLE VI(continued)
Maize inoculated withBacillussp.,Burkholderiasp.,andFlavobacteriumsp.shows significant increases in plant height,biomass,root length,and grain yield,compared to the uninoculated control(Iqbal Hussainet al.,2013).Nandiniet al.(2014)isolated P-solubilizingA.faecalisfrom the rhizospheric soil of upland rice and further studied the effect of the isolate alone or in combination withB.megateriumandB.japonicumon soybean growth.They found increases in plant height,number of leaves,number of pods,dry weight,and grain yield of the inoculated plants compared to the control plants.Saxenaet al.(2014)evaluated the synergistic effect of the AM fungusG.etunicatumwith the indigenous P-solubilizing bacterial strainB.cepaciaon wheat plants.They found that dual inoculation withG.etunicatumandB.cepaciaincreases all studied growth and yield parameters compared to individual inoculations.Royet al.(2017)studied the individual and synergetic effects of the free-living diazotrophic bacteriaA.brasilense,Azotobacter chroococcum,andClostridium pasteurianumwith the P-solubilizing bacteriaPseudomonas denitrificansandRhizobiumsp.on the growth of rice cultivar NDR-359.They reported that inoculated strains,both individually and in combination,increase the shoot length,number of tillers per plant,number of leaves per tiller,root length,and root volume.
Most of the soils worldwide are deficient in plantavailable P;this necessitates the use of expensive P fertilizers.Thus,scientists and microbiologists are greatly focusing on finding alternate solutions to this P deficiency.There is a huge diversity of microbes in soil,some of which have already been reported and some of which remain to be explored,for their capability to solubilize P and make it available to plant.Generally,P-solubilizing microbes also possess other plant growth-promoting attributes,including the production of various plant growth regulators,siderophores,HCN,ammonia,and hydrolytic enzymes;these compounds also protect the plants from various abiotic stresses.Thus,these plant growth-promoting P-solubilizing microbes can be used as biofertilizers,not only to promote the plant growth or increase P availability,but also to restore soil fertility and reduce the use of chemical fertilizers,which is the key to sustainable agriculture.The combined inoculation of AM fungi with P-solubilizing microbes can make native soil P available to plant.However,further research is needed to evaluate the P-solubilizing stability and performance of both natural and genetically modified strains applied to soil-plant systems.The understanding of the genetics behind the solubilization of P is important,and chromosomal insertion of the PQQ synthase gene would be beneficial.Finally,it is very essential that researchers and microbiologists continue to learn about P-solubilizing microbes and transfer their knowledge into bio-based inoculants that could be made easily available to farmers;awareness must also be created among farmers to use inoculants that make sustainable agriculture possible.
CONTRIBUTION OF AUTHORS
Divjot Kour and Kusam Lata Rana contributed equally to this review.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors are grateful to the Department of Biotechnology,Akal College of Agriculture,Eternal University and the Department of Environment,Science & Technology(DEST),India-funded project“Development of Microbial Consortium as Bio-inoculants for Drought and Low Temperature Growing Crops for Organic Farming in Himachal Pradesh”for providing the facilities and financial support to undertake the investigations.There are no conflicts of interest.
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL
Supplementary material for this article can be found in the online version.