Damir A. Gubaidullin, Yuri V. Fedorov
Laboratory of Continuum Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics and Engineering, FRC Kazan Scientific Center,Russian Academy of Sciences, Kazan, Russia
Abstract: In this paper, a modified Rayleigh-Lamb equation is derived that takes into account the radial vibrations of a gas bubble coated with a viscoelastic shell and located in an elastic medium. For small oscillations of inclusion, the problem of heat exchange between a gas, a liquid phase, a viscoelastic shell, and an elastic medium is solved. The energy integral is determined. In the case of small disturbances, the dispersion relation is found from the Rayleigh-Lamb equations, energy, and the known wave equation for the bubbly medium. An analytical expression of the equilibrium speed of sound is written out and its dependence on the size of the viscoelastic shell and the disturbance frequency is established. An example of a mixture of polydimethylsiloxane with air bubbles coated with a rubber shell illustrates the influence of the elasticity of the carrier medium and the shell of the bubbles on the dependence of the phase velocity and attenuation coefficient on the perturbation frequency. For a mixture of water with air bubbles coated with a rubber shell, the influence of the dependences of the shear modulus and viscosity of butyl rubber on the frequency of disturbances at different temperature on the dispersion curves is shown. A comparison of the theory with experimental data is given.
Key words: Acoustic wave, gas bubbles, viscoelastic medium and shell, shear modulus, dispersion equation
The study of wave propagation in complex bubbly media is still of current interest, as evidenced by recent publications[1-4]. The influence of the size distribution functions of bubbles on the dynamics of acoustic waves in a liquid with gas bubbles was considered[1], the pulsations of vapor or vapor-gas bubbles in a liquid were studied and the role of mass transfer on the wave propagation velocity and its attenuation in a bubbly liquid was studied[2-4]. The effect of phase transformations on the propagation of weak waves in a liquid with vapor-gas bubbles is also presented[5-6]. In particular, good agreement between the theory and experimental data was found[6]. The reflection of a low-frequency acoustic wave from the boundary of a gas-vapor-liquid mixture was considered[7], where the monotonic dependence of the reflection coefficient on the vapor concentration for a bubbly liquid was found using simplified formulas for the speed of sound[5-6]. The difference in the interaction of small disturbances with a layer of bubbly liquid and a layer of a gas-droplet mixture is indicated[8]. To date, there are many experimental studies on the acoustic properties of bubbly media.Here are just a few of them[9-11], where the frequency dependences of the phase velocity and attenuation coefficient are determined. For example, the main theoretical models are published[1,12-14]. A large number of publications can be found in the reviews[15-16].
Elastically coated bubbles are found in many areas. But they found their main application in biomedicine, where they are used as contrast medium for ultrasound diagnostics[17-18]. Knowledge of the properties of coated bubbles formed the basis for the creation of microrobots, which have great potential in medical practice: from drug delivery to the diagnosis of diseases. In particular, the work[19]describes a microrobot capable of moving in a liquid medium in the following way. On the surface of the device, gas bubbles are fixed in special capsules. Under the influence of ultrasonic vibrations, the bubbles begin to expand and contract alternately, exerting pressure on the wall to which they are attached. The oscillation frequency depends on the size of the bubbles, and the closer it is to their resonant frequency, the more efficient the movement of the microrobot occurs.Existing theoretical models are based on various forms of writing equations of oscillation of spherical bubbles, taking into account the elasticity and viscosity of the surface layer. A modified Rayleigh-Plesset equation was obtained[20], taking into account the radial vibrations of a gas bubble with a viscoelastic shell of finite thickness in a liquid based on the Kelvin-Voigt rheological equation. The influence of shell parameters is analyzed. Subsequently, the model[20]was simplified for the case when the thickness of the viscoelastic shell of the bubbles is close to zero[21]. Here, theoretically and experimentally, the effect of the polymer shell of micro bubbles on the attenuation of a pulsed disturbance is shown. Based on the results[20], a mathematical model is presented[22]that determines the propagation of acoustic waves in a liquid with gas bubbles coated with a viscoelastic shell in the approximation of interacting and interpenetrating continua[23]. Under real conditions, coated bubbles can be in a viscoelastic medium. In this regard, in this paper, we study the propagation of acoustic waves in a viscoelastic medium with bubbles covered by shells.
Let us consider a gas cavity coated with a thin spherical viscoelastic shell inside an array of a stationary viscoelastic medium (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1 Scheme of inclusion (g is the gas, s is the shell, l is the liquid)

Fig. 2 Dependences of the phase velocity on the disturbance frequency for polydimethylsiloxane with air bubbles(1-Without taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium, 2-Taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium, 3-Taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium and in the presence of a viscoelastic shell of the bubbles, (circles are experimental data[28])

Fig. 3 Dependences of the attenuation coefficient on the disturbance frequency for polydimethylsiloxane with air bubbles (1-Without taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium, 2-Taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium, 3-Taking into account the elasticity of the carrier medium and in the presence of a viscoelastic shell of the bubbles) (circles are experimental data[28])
Due to the impermeability of the shell, the velocity of change of its radiuscoincides with the radial speed of movement of the surface u( R1, t), where t is the time. The continuity equation in a spherical coordinate system {r,,θ φ} in the presence of central symmetry has the form

where r is the radial coordinate. The solution to this equation has the form

The equation of conservation of momentum in spherical coordinates is taken in the form

where ρ is the density, p is the pressure, τ are the stress tensor components. For a sphere, the tensor components are related by the relation[24]:. We integrate Eq. (2) from R1to∞, taking into account (1). In this case, the interval from R1to R2will correspond to the parameters of the bubble shell (index s), from R2to ∞ parameters of the viscoelastic medium (index l).

We write down the boundary conditions between two moving media with allowance for surface tension forces[24]

where1σ is the surface tension of the bubble/shell boundary,2σ is the surface tension of the shell/liquid boundary. Note that the magnitude τrr,gis smaller in order than τrr,l, since the viscosity of the gas is less than the viscosity of the liquid, therefore,this value can be neglected in the future. If shear stresses are absent τ=0, then the simple Laplace equation takes place[25]. The viscoelasticity of the medium is taken into account on the basis of the Kelvin-Voigt rheological model; therefore, the stress tensor is given by the following relation[26]

Here μ is the dynamic viscosity, G is the shear modulus, R20is the equilibrium radius. The stress tensor is also set similarly for the viscoelastic bubble shell[20]

In view of Eqs. (4)-(6), after algebraic transformations and the condition of incompressibility of the shellEq. (3) will finally take the form


In the case when the viscoelastic shell of the bubbles is absent, i.e., R20= R10, ρl= ρsand the elasticity of the carrier phase is not taken into account Gl=0, as well as the surface tension, then δs=0, X=0 and the Rayleigh equation takes the standard form.
Let us consider interphase heat transfer of a spherical gas bubble coated with a viscoelastic shell in a carrier liquid. The region inside the bubble r < R1is filled with perfect gas and there are no phase transformations at the boundary of the bubble. We assume that in a wide range of bubble sizes and,therefore, disturbance frequencies, the wavelength is much larger than the size of the bubbles. This statement let to assume that the pressure in the bubble is uniform. Taking this into account, we write the heat conduction equations for the gas and viscoelastic shell[23,27]

Here cpis the specific heat, λ is the thermal conductivity, T is the temperature. In the absence of an external supply of heat, the mass-average temperature of the liquid will be considered constant. In Eq. (9), pressure pgis considered only a function of time pg(t), that is, the condition of homobaricity is fulfilled[23]. This assumption will allow us to avoid solving the gas equation of motion inside the bubble and thereby simplify the system of equations. When setting the problem, it is necessary to set the boundary conditions,which for temperatures have the form

Here, the condition (11) means the absence of heat flow to the center of the spherical bubble, the remaining conditions (12), (13) characterize the equality of temperatures and flows at the boundaries.The solution of the above problem (9)-(13) for the case of small oscillations of a bubble with a small amplitude we look for in the form of real parts of complex functions

where ω is the frequency of disturbances. Substituting a solution of the form Eqs. (14) into Eq. (9), we obtain

The general solution of the second-order differential equation (15) can be obtained as the sum of a particular solutionand a linear combination of two independent solutions of the homogeneous equation

Here A1, A2are unknown variables. The solution of Eq. (10) is written in the same way

Unknown variables A1, A2, B1, B2are determined from the boundary conditions (11)-(13). We obtain the energy integral for the gas bubble. It is assumed that the region inside the bubble is filled with perfect gas;therefore, the equation of state is taken in the form

Here R is the gas constant, γ is the adiabatic exponent. The equation of continuity in spherical coordinates has the form

Differentiating Eq. (16) with respect to time t and taking into account Eq. (17), we have

Integrating the heat inflow equation for the gas phase Eq. (9) from 0 to R10and taking into account Eq.(18), the linearized energy integral takes the form



At the limit transition ω→0, from the dispersion relation (26), the expression for the equilibrium (low-frequency) sound speed is obtained

For the case of gas bubbles without shells X=0, the equilibrium speed of sound takes the well-known expression

The results of measuring the phase velocity and attenuation coefficient of the disturbance frequency in an elastic medium with polydisperse air bubbles are presented[28]. Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS RTV-615),a silicone rubber material with the addition of hardeners, was chosen as the carrier medium. And the following size distribution function of bubbles was constructed


Figures 2 and 3 shows the effect of the elasticity of the carrier phase and the viscoelastic shell of the bubbles (shell thickness rs=1.6× 1 0-5m ) on the dependences of the phase velocity and attenuation coefficient on the disturbance frequency.
For an elastic medium with air bubbles, the theory is compared with experimental data[28](curve 2). The figure shows that accounting the elasticity of the carrier phase leads to a shift of the resonance frequency of the disturbances, which is also well confirmed by experimental data. From formula (24)for the resonant frequency of inclusions in the absence of a bubble shell (R10= R20, ρl= ρs) and neglecting surface tension, we obtain

It is seen from formula (29) that for an elastic medium,the resonant frequency of the bubbles exceeds the Minnaert frequency by an amountAccounting the viscoelastic shell along with the elastic carrier phase leads to an even larger value of the resonant frequency (curve 3). The presence of a bubble shell can also lead to the disappearance of the opacity band at the phase velocity (the phase velocity does not exceed the speed of sound in the carrier phase in the entire frequency range) and a decrease in the maximum attenuation coefficient. This is due to the fact that the shell of the bubbles restrains the pulsation of inclusions. Bubbles behave more like elastic particles and, therefore, less scattering of the acoustic wave occurs compared to conventional bubbly media.
The reference manual[33]gives empirical formulas by which it is possible to calculate the dependences of the shear modulus and viscosity of butyl rubber on the disturbance frequency at various temperatures, which is shown in Fig. 4.

Fig. 4 Shear modulus Gs and viscosity sμ for butyl rubber as a function of frequency for three temperatures: 1 K-283 K, 2 K- 293 K, 3 K- 303 K

Fig. 5 Frequency dependences of the phase velocity for various functions of the shear modulus and viscosity of rubber(the notation is the same as in Fig. 4) (4-Without taking into account the elastic shell, dashed lines show the asymptotic behavior of the phase velocity according to the formula (27))

Fig. 6 Frequency dependences of the attenuation coefficient for various functions of the shear modulus and viscosity of rubber (the notation is the same as in Fig. 4) (4-Without taking into account the elastic shell)
It is seen that with increasing temperature, the viscosity and shear modulus of butyl rubber decrease.In this case, with an increase in the perturbation frequency, the shear modulus monotonously increases,and the viscosity of the rubber has a nonmonotonic character. At low frequencies, an increase in viscosity is observed, and then, as the frequency of disturbances increases, it decreases.
The work[34]reported experimental data on the attenuation coefficient as a function of frequency for a mixture of water with air bubbles coated with butyl rubber at temperature T0=303 K and pressure p=1.21× 105Pa . The radius of the bubbles was0m , the thickness of the rubber shell. Volumetric content α = 0.0053.The wavelength in the experiment varies from 3 m to 22 m, which makes it possible not to take into account the interaction processes directly between the bubbles and apply the obtained theoretical model to the experimental results.
Figures 5 and 6 shows the dependences of the phase velocity and attenuation coefficient on the perturbation frequency for a mixture of water with air bubbles coated with a rubber shell.
For the attenuation coefficient, a comparison with experimental data[34]is made. It can be seen that taking into account the elastic shell of the bubbles leads to an increase of the resonance frequency of inclusion, which is also well confirmed by experimental data. With an increase of temperature from 283 K to 303 K, there is an increase in the attenuation coefficient and a decrease in the natural vibration frequency of the bubbles. Physically, this is explained as follows. At a higher temperature, the rubber becomes softer (viscosity decreases, Fig. 4), so the radial vibrations of the bubbles pass more intensively and there is a greater scattering of the acoustic wave than with a more rigid rubber shell,which inhibits the pulsation of inclusions. As for the decrease in the natural vibration frequency of the bubbles, it is obvious from formula (24) that with a decrease in the shear modulus of the elastic shell, the resonant frequency0ω decreases.
As follows from Fig. 5, as well as comparing expressions (27) and (28), we also conclude that for bubbles without a shell, the equilibrium sound speed does not depend on the perturbation frequency and bubble size (dashed line 4), and for encapsulated bubbles the opposite situation is observed (monotonously increasing dashed curves 1, 2 and 3). Here, the equilibrium velocity noticeably depends on the size of the bubbles, as well as the shear modulus of the elastic shell, which in turn depends on the frequency of perturbations (Fig. 4). Thus, these examples show a significant difference in the acoustics of elastic media with encapsulated bubbles from the acoustics of ordinary bubbly liquids.
It is shown that the presence of an elastic carrier phase and an elastic shell of the bubbles leads to an increase of the resonant frequency of the bubbles and a decrease of the maximum attenuation coefficient,and can also lead to the fact that the phase velocity does not exceed the speed of sound in the carrier phase in the entire range of perturbation frequencies.The dependence of the equilibrium (low-frequency)speed of sound on the size of the viscoelastic shell of the bubbles and also on the perturbation frequency is demonstrated. A satisfactory agreement between the theory and known experimental data was found for a mixture of water with air bubbles coated with butyl rubber and for a mixture of polydimethylsiloxane with air bubbles.