Yan-Yuan Lei, Yuan Zhou, Ning Wang, Li Zhu,Yao Sun, Xiang-Shu Cui
The effects of cognitive behavioral therapy on negative emotions in nursing students: a meta-analysis
Yan-Yuan Lei1, Yuan Zhou1, Ning Wang1, Li Zhu1,Yao Sun1, Xiang-Shu Cui1*
1School of Nursing, Yanbian University, Yanji, Jilin, China.
Recently, cognitive behavioral therapy interventions have been extensively applied in the field of nursing education. However, no consensus has been reached on whether these interventions can reduce negative emotions in nursing students.This meta-analysis was designed to systematically discuss the effect of cognitive behavioral therapy interventions on levels of anxiety, fear of denial, social avoidance and social distress for nursing students.The following Chinese and English databases were searched for relevant articles: PubMed, Embase, Cochrane library, Web of Science, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wangfang Database, VIP Database and Chinese Biomedical Literature Database. The search encompassed the establishment of these databases up until May 2021. Two reviewers separately entered the data into Review Manager Software 5.3.A total of 6 studies were reviewed. It was found that cognitive behavioral therapy interventions significantly lowered levels of anxiety (SMD = −0.98, 95% CI: −1.46 to −0.50,< 0.001), fear of denial (MD = −3.22, 95% CI: −5.60 to −0.84,< 0.01), social avoidance (MD = −1.74, 95% CI: −2.32 to −1.16,< 0.001), and social distress (MD = −2.15, 95% CI: −2.81 to −1.49,< 0.001) in nursing students.Cognitive behavioral therapy could effectively decrease anxiety, fear of negation, and social negative emotions of nursing students as well as enhance their mental health level. However, more studies are needed to verify whether internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy has an impact on nursing students’ negative emotions.
Cognitive behavioral therapy, Nursing students, Negative emotions, Meta-analysis, Stress
Anxiety, depression, and stress are the main factors that affect the mental health of college students [1]. Nursing students in college face even greater pressure, with some studies suggesting that anxiety and other negative emotions are common in nursing students because of numerous exams[2], high internship pressure[3], and fierce employment competition[4]. Various studies[5] have shown that the comprehensive prevalence of depression among nursing students is 34.0%, and the prevalence of depression among younger nursing students is even higher (41.0%). In China, nursing students have different degrees of anxiety, depression, and other emotions across the educational and vocational stages, which not only can seriously affect their physical and mental health and employment choice but also is not conducive to the vigorous development of their entire careers[6–8]. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is a short-term psychotherapy method that combines cognitive and behavioral technologies to alter thinking, beliefs, and behaviors through cognitive reconstruction and behavioral training, thus altering negative cognition and eliminating negative emotions and behaviors[9, 10]. Compared with other psychotherapies, CBT mainly focuses on the cognitive and psychological aspects of irrationality using verbal or nonverbal communication to correct patients’ irrational cognition and thinking so as to change their negative mental state and establish a correct, positive cognitive level of understanding[11]. At present, many national and international clinical studies have confirmed that CBT has positive effects on mental health issues[12]. However, the research results differ, and a systematic evaluation of the improvement of nursing students’ mental health function using CBT is lacking. Therefore, this meta-analysis evaluates the intervention effects of CBT on nursing students’ negative emotions so as to provide an evidence-based reference.
Inclusion criteria.The inclusion criteria for this meta-analysis were as follows. (1) Population: all nursing students were included, regardless of grades or educational background. (2) Intervention: the intervention group applied cognitive behavioral therapy for nursing students in an organized and systematic way; (3) Comparison: the control group applied routine therapy or no intervention measures; (4) Outcome: nursing students’ negative emotions such as anxiety, fear of negation, social avoidance and social distress. (5)Research design: a randomized controlled trial.
Exclusion criteria. (1) Repeated literature and reports. (2) Insufficient data report or no measurement data.
Retrieval of databases. This study systematically retrieved randomized controlled trials published in Chinese and foreign databases, including China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wangfang Database, VIP Database and Chinese Biomedical Literature Database, PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Library and Embase, as far as possible to reduce the missing document, references of related studies were further included in the retrieval in this study, in addition to topic review, system evaluation and meta-analysis, references included in the research were tracked in the literature retrieval. Specific retrieval steps: firstly, search whether there was meta-analysis or systematic evaluation related to the topic in the databases, and further searched the references of the included studies;secondly, by carefully analyzing the titles, keywords, and abstract contents of relevant papers in the database, the keywords to be retrieved were determined.
Search terms. Finally, the keywords were searched comprehensively in the database and all references that met the inclusion criteria were further tracked. The deadline was set up until May 30, 2021, The studies were limited to publish in English and Chinese. The keywords were the following:(cognitive behavioral therapyORcognitive therapyORcognitive psycho-therapy)AND (negative emotionORdepressionORanxiety OR stress) AND (nursing studentsORnursing interns).
All retrieved records were imported into EndNote X9 software for classification. After scanning the titles and abstracts and reading the full texts of the remaining studies, the studies that met the inclusion criteria of this meta-analysis were selected. This process was carried out by two researchers independently. In the case of disagreement, a decision was made in consultation with a third researcher.
Literature screening and evaluation were conducted by two researchers independently. The following information was extracted after careful reading of the full text: author, year, participants, sample size(experimental group/control group), intervention period/week, intervention measures/content, outcomes and measurement scale. Any differences were addressed through consultation with a third researcher.
The quality assessment of the included literature was conducted independently by two researchers according to the Cochrane Handbook(5.1.0) quality evaluation criteria[13].“Low-risk bias”, “unclear”and “high-risk bias” were used to indicate the degree of bias risk. In case of uncertainly, a third researcher was invited to discuss it together. Quality grade A indicated that the included study’s bias was low risk and all met the above criteria; quality grade B indicated the possibility of bias in the included study and partially met the above criteria; quality grade C indicated a high risk of bias in the study which can be eliminated[14].
Meta-analysis was performed using Revman5.3. The included studies were expressed as 95% confidence interval (CI), and inter-study heterogeneity was determined by chi-square test (α=0. 05). If≥0.1 and2< 50%, there was no statistical heterogeneity, and the fix effect model was used for analysis. If< 0.1and2≥50%, there was clinical homogeneity, then the random effect model was used for analysis, and the subgroup analysis was conducted to find the source of possible heterogeneity[15]. For each included literature, the standardized mean difference(SMD) value or mean difference (MD) with 95% CI value were examined with different effect models, and the results of meta-analysis after the large sample study were removed were examined to verify the stability of the result of this study.
A total of 882 English and Chinese studies were preliminarily retrieved, 30 of which were duplicates. After reading the titles and abstracts, 820 studies were excluded. Following a reading of the full text, 26 studies were excluded. Finally, 6 studies were involved in this meta-analysis. The literature screening process is illustrated in Figure1 and the basic characteristics of the studies are shown in Table 1.

Figure 1 Flow diagram of study selection

Table 1 Basic characteristics of the included literature
E, experimental group; C, control group; ①anxiety; ②fear of negation; ③social avoidance;④social distress; TAS, interpersonal anxiety scale; FNE, fear of negation rating scale; SAD, social avoidance and distress scale; SAS, Zung self-rating anxiety scale.
A total of six studies involving 279 participants were included. The quality evaluation results of the six included studies are shown in Table 2. Of the six trials included in this review, all nursing students were randomly assigned to either an intervention group or a control group, whereas one study described detailed random-sequence generation[19]. In addition, only one study was randomized and blinded [20]. Furthermore, the quality grade of these studies was B. All six studies reported an intention-to-treat approach, and the expected outcomes were stated in all trials. The risk-of-bias assessment is shown in Figure 2.

Table 2 Literature quality assessment

Figure 2 Risk of bias graph
Effect of cognitive-behavioral therapy on the anxiety of nursing students. Six studies[16–21] reported the anxiety level of nursing students. A total of 279 subjects were included in the study, 141 in the intervention group and 138 in the control group. These six studiesexhibited high heterogeneity(2= 67%,< 0.001), meaning the random effects model was applied to merge the results. The results showed that CBT could significantly decrease nursing students’ anxiety levels compared to the control group, and the difference was statistically significant (SMD = -0.98, 95%CI(-1.46,-0.50),< 0.001) (Figure 3).

Figure 3 Effect of CBT on the anxiety of nursing students. CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy.
Three studies[17,19, 20] reported the effect of CBT on nursing students’ fear of negation. A total of 110 subjects were included in the study, 57 in the intervention group and 53 in the control group. These three studies exhibited low heterogeneity (2= 0%,< 0.01), so fixed effects model was applied, the result showed that CBT could significantly reduce nursing students’ fear of negation, and the difference was statistically significant (MD = -3.22, 95%CI(-5.60,-0.84), P < 0.01) (Figure 4).

Figure 4 Effect of CBT on fear of negation of nursing students. CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy.
Four studies reported the effect of CBT on the social avoidance of nursing students (170 students, including 86 in the experimental group and 84 in the control group) [17–20]. These four studies exhibited low heterogeneity (2= 0%,< 0.001), so the fixed effects model was applied to merge the results. The results showed that CBT could significantly reduce nursing students’ social avoidance compared to the control group, and the difference was statistically significant (MD= -1.74, 95%CI (-2.32,-1.16),< 0.001)(Figure 5).

Figure 5 Effect of CBT on social avoidance of nursing students. CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy.
Four studies reported the effect of CBT on the social distress of nursing students [17–20]. A total of 170 subjects were included in the study, 86 in the intervention group and 84 in the control group. These four studies exhibited low heterogeneity(2= 0%,< 0.001), meaning the fixed effects model was applied. The results showed that CBT could significantly reduce nursing students’ social distress, and the difference was statistically significant (MD= -2.15,95%CI (-2.81,-1.49),< 0.001) (Figure 6).

Figure 6 Effect of CBT on social distress of nursing students. CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy.
Fewer studies were included in this study and the funnel plot was relatively symmetrical, which indicated that the possibility of publication bias in this study was low.
Excluding a large sample, studies had no substantial effect on the results of this meta-analysis, which indicated that the result of this study was reliable.
CBT was proposed by an American psychologist Beck in 1976. It is a holistic, short-term, and cognition-oriented psychological therapy method[22, 23], which has significant intervention effects on anxiety, depression, and other psychological problems[24]. The results of this meta-analysis show that CBT can significantly reduce the levels of anxiety, fear of negation, and social negative emotions among nursing students as well as can improve their mental health. At present, CBT has been widely used in the field of clinical nursing. For example, CBT effectively prevented the occurrence of postpartum depression[25], and CBT for insomnia had a significant effect on the treatment of insomnia and depression[26]. The results of the meta-analysis of this study revealed that CBT could effectively reduce nursing students’ anxiety, fear of social interaction, and other negative emotions and can help them develop a positive psychological attitude. Therefore, CBT plays a positive role in the mental health of nursing students.
With the development of the internet and the combination of network and CBT, internet-based CBT has emerged as an innovative method to treat patients with depression[27].At present, countries such as the United Kingdom[28], Canada[29], and Sweden[30] have applied internet-based CBT as an intervention method for treating patients with clinical depression. These studies have shown that internet-based CBT can effectively reduce patients’ negative mood, with no differences between the depression scores of patients receiving conventional medication and psychological treatments. Therefore, the effective development of internet-based CBT globally can provide a reference for using internet-based CBT in China. Furthermore, because this meta-analysis shows the positive effects of CBT on the negative emotions of nursing students, future researchers could apply internet-based CBT on these students to obtain more extensive findings.
Due to the limited conditions, this study has certain limitations. (1)In this study, only Chinese and English databases were searched. Literature from other languages was not included, which may lead to language bias. (2) In this study, only one study described the randomization method but others did not explain it clearly, which is a limitation for this meta-analysis to some extent. (3)The quality grade of six studies was B, which will affect the authenticity and reliability of the research conclusion to some extent. Therefore, more large samples and high-quality studies are needed to verify the effects of interventions for nursing students.
This study shows that CBT could effectively decrease anxiety, fear of negation, and social negative emotions of nursing students as well as enhance their mental health level. However, more studies are needed to verify whether internet-based CBT has an impact on nursing students’ negative emotions. It is suggested that future researchers should pay attention to the negative emotions of nursing students and apply innovative intervention methods in extensive nursing teaching and clinical practice to contribute to the healthy development of nurses.
1. Hua WQ. Prevalence of depression, anxiety and stress among college students.Jilin University;2020.
2. Son HK, So WY, Kim M. Effects of aromatherapy combined with music therapy on anxiety, stress, and fundamental nursing skills in nursing students: arandomized controlled trial.. 2019;16(21):4185. Available: 10.3390/ijerph16214185; https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph16214185
3. Yu Y, Shen ZQ, Sun TW, et al. Qualitative study on negative emotional psychological experience of nursing students during CCU internship.. 2016;22(16):2284–2286,2287. Available: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.1674-2907.2016.16.016;https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1674-2907.2016.16.016
4. Jiang M, Jiang XX, Zhang YP. Investigation and analysis of anxiety and depression status andinfluencing factors among college nursing students..2016;45(28):4027–4029.Available:10.3969/j.issn.1671-8348.2016.28.051;https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-8348.2016.28.051
5. Tung YJ, Lo KKH, Ho RCM, Tam WSW. Prevalence of depression among nursing students:a systematic review and meta-analysis..2018;63:119–129. Available: 10.1016/j.nedt.2018.01.009; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2018.01.009
6. Song XY. The status and Influencing factors of depression and anxiety among nursing students in a higher vocational college. Anhui Medical University;2014.
7. Jiang H, Cheng YJ, Wang T. A survey on information anxiety of nursing students under the current new media environment..2017;14(9):700–702. Available: 10.3761/j.issn.1672-9234.2017.09.015; https://doi.org/10.3761/j.issn.1672-9234.2017.09.015
8. Xie YP, Zhao HF, Huang FF, et al. Mental health status of nursing interns and its influencing factors.. 2021;40(7):1167–1171. Available: 10.3760/cma.j.cn221370-20200330-00341; https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn221370-20200330-00341
9. Chen ML, Wang YY. Research progress of cognitive behavioral therapy on alleviating jobburnout of nurses.. 2017;15(23):2854–2856. Available: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-4748.2017.23.015; https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-4748.2017.23.015
10. Shi BB, Zhu ZP, Jiang JL, et al. A review of brief cognitive behavioral therapy in application to depressive disorder.. 2017;31(9):670–676. Available: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2017.09.002; https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2017.09.002
11. Stefan S, Cristea IA, Szentagotai Tatar A, David D. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for generalized anxiety disorder: contrasting various CBT approaches in a randomized clinical trial.. 2019;75(7):1188–1202. Available: 10.1002/jclp.22779; https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.22779
12. Wang J, Cui X, Zhou CX, et al. Application of cognitive behavior therapy.. 2013(9):834–838. Available: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-9771.2013.09.010; https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-9771.2013.09.010
13. Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ, et al. Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews: a new edition of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions.2019;10:ED000142. Available: 10.1002/14651858.ED000142; https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.ED000142
14. Hu Y.. Beijing: People’s Medical Publishing House;2012.
15. Wang F, Zhong WJ, Liu LM, et al. A meta-analysis of the effect of cognitive behavioral therapy on clinical nurses’ negative emotion intervention.. 2020;6(9):48–53. Available: 10.11997/nitcwm.202009010; https://doi.org/10.11997/nitcwm.202009010
16. Tang Y, Fan XQ, Chen X, et al. The effect of cognitive behavioral group therapy on social anxiety of vocational nursing students..2021;20(6):57–59. Available: 10.3969/j.issn.1673-5641.2021.06.028; https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5641.2021.06.028
17. Li M, Zhen YQ, Lin XL. Intervention of group counseling with cognitive behavioral therapy on operation anxiety in college nursing students.. 2020;30(30):47–48. Available: 1004-7484-(2020)30-0047-02; https://doi.org/1004-7484-(2020)30-0047-02
18. Gao Q.The Intervention study of cognitive behavioral group counseling on social anxiety in internship nursing students. Jiangsu University;2020.
19. Huang AH, Zhang SR, Li L, et al. Group intervention study of cognitive behavioral therapy on social anxiety of vocational nursing students.. 2014(4):73–74. Available: 10.3969/j.issn.2095-1752.2014.04.060; https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-1752.2014.04.060
20. Li J. An intervention study:to evaluate the effect of CBGT to relieve nursing students’social anxiety before clinical practice. Beijing University of Chinese Medicine;2013.
21. Yuan M, Wang J, Cheng BY. Effects of rational-emotional therapy on anxiety of nursing students practicing in operating room.. 2011;26(14):79–80. Available: 10.3870/hlxzz.2011.14.079; https://doi.org/10.3870/hlxzz.2011.14.079
22. Wang L, Bai H, Wang FJ, et al. Comparative study on the effect of cognitive behavioral therapy in patients with depression disorder.. 2019,46(1):161–163,171. Available: 10.13479/j.cnki.jip.2019.01.048; https://doi.org/10.13479/j.cnki.jip.2019.01.048
23. Borza L. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for generalized anxiety.. 2017;19(2):203–208. Available: 10.31887/DCNS.2017.19.2/lborza; https://doi.org/10.31887/DCNS.2017.19.2/lborza
24. Bandelow B, Sagebiel A, Belz M, Görlich Y, Michaelis S, Wedekind D. Enduring effects of psychological treatments for anxiety disorders: meta-analysis of follow-up studies.. 2018;212(6):333–338. Available: 10.1192/bjp.2018.49; https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2018.49
25. Lv LF, Wang L. The application of cognitive behavioral therapy in postpartum depression in China.. 2020;18(3):302–304. Available: 10.12104/j.issn.1674-4748.2020.03.014; https://doi.org/10.12104/j.issn.1674-4748.2020.03.014
26. Huang ZJ, Han Q, Lu YA, et al. Effect of cognitive behavioral therapy on improving insomnia and depression in patients with insomnia and depression:a meta-analysis.. 2021;35(1):80–85. Available: 10.12102/j.issn.1009-6493.2021.01.014; https://doi.org/10.12102/j.issn.1009-6493.2021.01.014
27. Cui Q, Zhang Y, Zou HO. The application of Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy in patients with depression.. 2021;48(1):10-12. Available: 10.13479/j.cnki.jip.2021.01.004; https://doi.org/10.13479/j.cnki.jip.2021.01.004
28. Eriksson MCM, Kivi M, Hange D, et al. Long-term effects of Internet-delivered cognitive behavioral therapy for depression in primary care - the PRIM-NET controlled trial.. 2017;35(2):126–136. Available: 10.1080/02813432.2017.1333299; https://doi.org/10.1080/02813432.2017.1333299
29. Xiang X, Wu S, Zuverink A, Tomasino KN, An R, Himle JA. Internet-delivered cognitive behavioral therapies for late-life depressive symptoms: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Aging Ment Health. 2020;24(8):1196–1206. Available: 10.1080/13607863.2019.1590309; https://doi.org/10.1080/13607863.2019.1590309
30. Johansson O, Bjärehed J, Andersson G, Carlbring P, Lundh LG. Effectiveness of guided internet-delivered cognitive behavior therapy for depression in routine psychiatry: a randomized controlled trial.. 2019;17:100247. Available: 10.1016/j.invent.2019.100247; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.invent.2019.100247
thanks Mary George Varghese and other anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this paper.
:
CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy; CI, confidence interval;SMD, standardized mean difference;MD, mean difference.
:
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
:
Lei YY, Zhou Y, Wang N, Zhu L,Sun Y,Cui XS. Effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy on negative emotions in nursing students: ameta-analysis.. 2021;4(3):27. doi: 10.53388/life2021-0610-310.
:Shan-Shan Lin.
: 10 June 2021,
09 July 2021,
:25 July 2021
© 2021 By Authors. Published by TMR Publishing Group Limited. This is an open access article under the CC-BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/BY/4.0/).
Xiang-Shu Cui.School of Nursing, Yanbian University,977 Park Road, Yanji City,133000, Yanbian Prefecture, JilinProvince, China. E-mail: 752141095@qq.com.