摘要:自2021年新修订的《行政处罚法》第九条第1项新增行政处罚种类通报批评以来,学界普遍认同应以通报批评统括实质上具有相同法律效果的声誉罚,而统括观点的一个重要矛盾即是与通报批评并列之警告势必不能纳入通报批评的涵射范围。为了厘清两者的边界,通过比较通报批评与警告的性质和界限范围发现,两者虽具有一定共性,但在性质倾向、适用对象、制裁力度、处罚方法方面均有一定差异,同时,以处罚方法上的差异为核心界限使得两者得以明确区分。
关键词:通报批评;警告;声誉罚;行政处罚种类;界限
中图分类号:D922.11文献标识码:A文章编号:2095-6916(2023)14-0091-05
A Brief Analysis of the Boundary Between
Name and Shame and Warning
Wu Jianyuan
(China University of Geosciences, Wuhan 430000)
Abstract: Since the introduction of name and shame,a new type of administrative penalty, in Item 1, Article 9 of the newly revised Administrative Punishment Law in 2021, the academic community generally agreed that it should include the reputational punishment which has the same legal effect. And an important contradiction in the view of inclusion is that warnings, which are listed alongside with the circulation of notice of criticism, will not be able to be included in its scope. In order to clarify the boundary between the two, this paper contrasts the nature and scope of name and shame and warning, discovering that the two share some similarties but differ in the nature tendency, suitable object, sanction and punishment method. At the same time, the two are distinguished clearly by the differences in punishment method as the core boundary.
Keywords: name and shame; warning; reputation penalty; types of administrative punishment; boundary
2021年新修的《行政處罚法》在第九条第1项中新增“通报批评”这一行政处罚类型并与警告并列。学界主流观点认同应以作为一般种类行政处罚的通报批评统括声誉罚,将实质上具有相同法律效果、形式上以公开为处罚方法的处罚种类纳入通报批评的范畴,进而通过《行政处罚法》予以统一规制。然而,新《行政处罚法》将“警告”与通报批评并列意味着两者虽具有一定的共性,但却是两种彼此独立的行政处罚种类。因此,若将同属声誉罚的警告纳入通报批评的涵射范围加以统括显然是有失妥当的。所以,区分通报批评与警告,厘清两者的边界就变得非常重要,对通报批评的内涵解析和正确适用都有重要意义。
一、通报批评之内涵明晰
2021年新修的《行政处罚法》第二条对行政处罚的概念作出了规定,“行政处罚是指行政机关依法对违反行政管理秩序的公民、法人或者其他组织,以减损权益或者增加义务的方式予以惩戒的行为”。……