The Influence of Mesoscopic Characteristics of Mineral Powders Fillers on the Rutting Factor(G*/sinδ) of Asphalt Mortar

2023-10-07 13:56:44LIAOJunDENGTaoGONGHongweiLIZhenTANGYongtaoCHENKaiSHILeiQIANXiaolongDONGQian

LIAO Jun,DENG Tao,GONG Hongwei,LI Zhen,TANG Yongtao,CHEN Kai,SHI Lei,QIAN Xiaolong,DONG Qian

(College of Environment and Civil Engineering , Chengdu University of Technology, Chengdu 610059, China)

Abstract: This study aims to investigate the effect of the mesoscopic characteristics of mineral powder fillers on the rutting resistance of asphalt mortar.Extraction and sieving tests were used to obtain the buton rock asphalt (BRA) ash with particle size smaller than 0.075 mm,which is consistent with that of the conventional mineral powder.The mesoscopic characteristics of BRA ash and conventional mineral powder were measured by SEM image analysis and the osmotic free pressure water method.Mesoscopic structure models of structural and free asphalts in mortar were obtained.The 70# matrix asphalt was used to prepare two kinds of asphalt mortar with BRA ash and conventional mineral powders fillers.The rutting factor of the two asphalt mortars was tested by dynamic shear test (DSR).Test results show that the ash extracted from BRA has a similar mesoscopic classification with the conventional mineral powder.Still,its fractal dimensions are larger,indicating the particles in BRA ash have more complex shapes and rougher surfaces,which is beneficial for forming structural asphalt and subsequently increasing the rutting factor (G*/sinδ),i e,improving the rutting resistance of the asphalt mortar.

Key words: asphalt mortar;mineral powder fillers;mesoscopic characteristic;rutting factor(G*/sinδ)

1 Introduction

The mineral powder fillers,including conventional mineral powder,cement and fly ash,are dispersed in the asphalt medium to form asphalt mortar.The macro and microscopic properties of mineral powder filler usually affect the performance of asphalt mortar under high and low temperatures,which have been noticed by many scholars.Zhang and Wang[1]studied the powder-to-rubber ratio and how the fiber improves the performance of asphalt mortar and asphalt mixture.Sherre and Liao[2]found that HCB powder significantly improved moisture,rutting,and crack resistance in HMA.Xuet al[3]have proved by experiments that increasing the filler-asphalt ratio can improve the hightemperature stability of asphalt mortar,reduce the temperature sensitivity of asphalt mortar.Linet al[4]found that the effect of specific surface area of mineral powder on rheological properties of mortar is greater than that of acid-base components.Lvet al[5]analyzed the mesoscopic characteristics of three mineral powder fillers and their effect on the low-temperature bond strength of asphalt mortar.Zhenget al[6]obtained measures to improve the low-temperature performance of asphalt mortar by studying the effect of mineral powder-powder ratio and mesoscopic characteristics on structural asphalt in asphalt mortar.Zhanget al[7]used chemical methods to change the mesoscopic structure of fly ash to improve the rutting resistance and low temperature crack resistance of asphalt mortar.Zhanget al[8]believed that diorite ore powder has advantages over limestone ore powder in improving the viscosity of asphalt mortar.Yanget al[9]found that activated coal gangue with a well-developed and uniform pore structure can improve the viscosity and shear resistance of asphalt mortar than conventional mineral powder.Xuet al[10]pointed out that the fineness of mineral powder in mesoscopic state would affect the strength and life of asphalt.Tanet al[11]obtained that the use of less flat-elongated and more angular FA can increase both the overall stiffness and elastic component of asphalt mortar by analyzing the geometric characteristics of aggregate.Fenget al[12]found that the filler with more complex micro pore structure can improve the adhesion with asphalt and improve the high temperature stability of asphalt mortar.Liet al[13]found that the freeze-thaw cycle weakened the interaction ability of asphalt mastic and destroyed the micro interface between asphalt and mineral powder filler.Yanet al[14]pointed out that because fly ash had the characteristics of small particle size,developed pore structure,large specific surface area and containing a variety of transition elements with large activity,it was conducive to the adsorption with asphalt medium and significantly improved the high temperature performance of asphalt mortar.The US SHRP proposed to use the rutting factor (G*/sinδ)to evaluate the high-temperature performance and antirutting ability of asphalt mixtures[15].In recent years the rock asphalt,an asphalt mortar composed of ash and natural asphalt,has been noticed showing excellent performance and often added in ordinary asphalt as a modifier to improve its high-temperature performance and rut resistance[16-22].

The ash in BRA is dispersed in the asphalt mortar by mixing.Compared with the conventional mineral powder,the ash in BRA has different mesoscopic characteristics,which can affect the performance of asphalt mortar and has been studied wildly.Zhaet aland Liuet al[23-24]measured ash particle sizes in BRA using the screening test and found they were mainly concentrated below 0.3 mm.In contrast,from the findings of Liuet al[24],the particles of conventional ore powder are mostly smaller than 0.075 mm,indicating a big difference in the mesoscopic size between the ash in BRA and the ordinary ore powder.Zhaet al[23]measured the specific surface area in BRA and conventional ore powder by physical adsorption instrument,and the results were 4.46 and 0.41 m2/g,respectively.Wuet al[25]used SEM images to analyze the ash content in BRA and the morphology of conventional mineral powder particles.The findings proved that the ash content in BRA is more complex and rougher than conventional mineral powder particles.Through the DSR test,Wanget al[26]analyzed the specific surface area and surface characteristics of the mesoscopic properties of BRA ash and ordinary mineral powder.They suggested that the asphalt mortar made of BRA ash with medium size has a higher rutting factor than those made of ordinary mineral powder.

This study selects the ash in BRA as the object and aims to carry out a detailed study on the influence of the mesoscopic properties of mineral powder fillers on the rutting factor of asphalt mortar.Mesoscopic classification,fractal dimension,specific surface area,and mesoscopic void characteristics of the BRA ash and common ore powder were tested through extraction and scanning tests.The mesoscopic properties of two kinds of asphalt mortars,which were respectively made of the BRA ash and conventional mineral powder combing the 70# matrix asphalt,were compared,and their high-temperature performances were studied using the DSR test.With the results,this study built a mesoscopic structure model and evaluated the effect of the mesoscopic properties of the mineral powder filler on the rutting factor (G*/sinδ).

2 Experimental

2.1 Test Materials

The test materials used in this study are ash in BRA,conventional mineral powder,and 70# road asphalt,whose performance parameters meet the test requirements and are given in Tables 1 and 2.The BRA ash used in the test was obtained from an extraction test.Trichloroethylene was used to dissolve BRA,and the dissolving solution separated ash from the asphalt by static precipitation,filtration,rotary extraction and other test processes.

Table 1 70# asphalt performance indicators

Table 2 BRA performance indicator

The performance parameters of the conventional mineral powder are given in Table 3.A sieve with a mesh size of 0.075 mm was selected to screen the ash in the BRA and the conventional mineral powder to ensure the particles sizes obtained are desired.

Table 3 Conventional mineral powder performance index

2.2 Test Method

We used electron microscope images to study the mesoscopic properties of the mineral powder filler particles[5,26],and the mesoscopic void properties of the mineral powder were obtained through the free pressure water penetration method[6].With the development of mathematics,the fractal theory,as a new mathematical theory,can be used to describe the surface features of substances with complexity and randomness[27,28].The specific test processes of the mesoscopic properties of the mineral powder filler particles,the mesoscopic structure and the rutting factor (G*/sinδ) of the asphalt mortar are as follows.

a) The Hitachi S-3000N scanning electron microscope image was used to analyze the mesoscopic properties of the mineral powder filler and obtain the mesoscopic classification,specific surface area and fractal dimension.Before testing,we used a sampler to conduct multi-point sampling in the container to make the sample more representative.

Analyzing the electron microscope image is a good approach to obtain the mesoscopic classification of the mineral powder filler.According to the known massMand densityρof the mineral powder filler,the total volumeVof the mineral powder filler can be calculated.By selecting the volume mean diameter of the filler particles as the representative particle size,we can calculate the volumeV′ and surface areaS′ of a single particle,which can then be used to estimate the specificS:

whereSis the specific surface area,Vis the total area,V′ is the volume of a single particle,S′ is the surface area of a single particle.

Based on the basic conceptions of stereology,we measured the fractal dimension of mineral powder particles,selected the micron scale consistent with the fractal hierarchy,and used the slit island method for the mesoscopic image of mineral powder[29].By using the perimeter-area relationship to calculate the fractal dimension of the perimeter curve,the following correlation between the perimeter and area of the fractal island can be speculated:

Transforming Eq.(2) into the logarithmic form gives:

In the above two equations,PEis the perimeter of the fractal island,Ais the plane area of the fractal island,Dis the fractal dimension,andCis a constant.

b) The mesoscopic void characteristics of mineral powder fillers were measured.The dry mineral powder sample (10 g) was placed in a 25 mL measuring cylinder and to determine the initial volume.10 mL distilled water was prepared in another graduated cylinder.A dropper was used to infiltrate the mineral powder sample with free pressure water.When a constant water film was formed on the surface of the mineral powder sample,the mesoscopic void size of the mineral powder sample was obtained by measuring the reduced amount of distilled water.

c) The ash in BRA and conventional mineral powder were respectively mixed with 70# matrix asphalt to prepare two asphalt slurries.Based on the dynamic shear rheological test (DSR),we conducted quantitative tests on the rutting resistance (G*/sinδ) of the two asphalt slurries at different temperatures (64,70,76,82 ℃).

3 Test results

Hitachi S-3000N scanning electron microscope was used to scan the BRA ash and conventional mineral powder (Fig.1),and the obtained electron microscope images were used to analyze the mesoscopic characteristic parameters of the fillers.The test results include mesoscopic classification,fractal dimension and specific surface area.

Fig.1 Mesoscopic analysis image of mineral powder fillers

3.1 Mesoscopic classification

The mesoscopic classification of mineral powder filler is an important mesoscopic characteristic parameter,which affects the other mesoscopic characteristic parameters such as mesoscopic void characteristics.According to the test results shown in Figs.5 and 6,the size ranges of the particles in the BRA ash and the conventional mineral powder were 1.25 to 74.67 μm,and 1.05 to 66.52 μm,respectively.

3.2 Fractal dimension

Thirty groups of particle electron microscope images of the two fillers were selected randomly and processed by commercial software to outline the particle boundaries.The perimeter and surface area of the two-dimensional image of the particles were measured (Fig.2).According to the perimeters{P1,P2,...,P30} and areas {A1,A2,...,A30} of the mineral powder particles,the fractal dimensions were calculated.

Fig.2 Particle image analysis of two mineral powder fillers

Fig.3 Perimeter-area double logarithm fit line of particles in Bra ash

Fig.4 Perimeter-area double logarithm fitting line of particles in conventional mineral powder particle

Fig.5 Particle size distribution of mineral powder fillers based on interval fraction

Fig.6 Particle size distribution of mineral powder fillers based on cumulative fraction

The perimeter-area double logarithmic fitting lines of the two mineral powder fillers are shown in Figs.3 and 4,and the test results of fractal dimensions are listed in Table 4.

Table 4 Double logarithmic fitting results of the perimeter-area of the mineral-powder fillers

3.3 Specific surface area

The specific surface area is an important parameter in the mesoscopic properties of the mineral powder fillers.The specific surface area test result is shown in Fig.7,with 1.407 m2/g for ash particles in BRA and 0.371 m2/g for the conventional mineral powder particles.

Fig.7 The specific surface area of two mineral powder fillers

3.4 Mesoscopic void characteristics

The ratio of the void volume to the mass is used to describe the mesoscopic void characteristics of the mineral powder,which is very important as it directly shows the anti-rut performance of asphalt mortar.This parameter can also be used to estimate the ratio of structural asphalt to free asphalt in asphalt slurries.The mesoscopic void characteristics of mineral powders were measured by using the free pressure water penetration method.Affected by mesoscopic characteristic parameters,the initial volumes were different between the ash and the conventional ore powder.In the second test,the initial volumes of the ash in BRA and the conventional mineral powder obtained from 10 g samples were 13 and 7.75 mL,respectively.The mesoscopic pore test results of the two mineral filler powders are listed in Table 5.The mesoscopic void per unit mass was measured as 0.317 mL/g for ash in the BRA and 0.250 mL/g for the conventional mineral powder.

Table 5 The test results of the mesoscopic void characteristics of the studied mineral powder filler

3.5 Rutting factor(G*/sinδ)

The two mineral powder fillers were mixed with 70# matrix asphalt respectively to prepare asphalt slurries of the same ratio.Their rutting factorsG*/sinδwere quantitatively tested using a dynamic shear rheometer.The test results are listed in Table 6.

Table 6 DSR test results of four asphalt cements at different temperature

4 Analysis and discussion

4.1 Mesoscopic properties of mineral powder f illers

In this study,the mesoscopic properties of the BRA ash and conventional mineral powder are studied.The mesoscopic properties,including mesoscopic classification,fractal dimension,specific surface area and void structure characteristics,were tested.The sieving process guaranteed that the BRA ash and the conventional mineral powder had the same maximum particle size of 0.075 mm.Figs.5 and 6 respectively plot the particle size distributions based on the interval fraction and cumulative fraction of the mineral powder fillers.The test results show that the two specimens have similar mesoscopic classification.

Many scholars use the fractal dimension to describe the shape and surface roughness of particles.It shows that the larger the fractal dimension,the more complex the particle shape and the rougher the surface andvice versa[30-32].The fractal dimension (D) of ash particles in BRA measured by the slit island method was 1.8,which was larger than that of the conventional mineral powder particles (D=1.596 6),(Table 4),indicating that the shape of ash in BRA is more complicated.Fig.7 shows the test results of the specific surface area of mineral powder particles,which shows the ash content in BRA has a larger specific surface area than conventional mineral powder.Fig.8 plots the results of the mesoscopic pore per unit mass of the two mineral powder fillers,in which the mesoscopic pore of ash in BRA is larger than that of the conventional mineral powder.The relationships between the fractal dimension,specific surface area and mesoscopic voids of the particles are shown in Fig.9.One can notice the fractal dimension is positively correlated with the specific surface area and mesoscopic.The results indicate that particles in BRA ash are more complex in shape and have rougher surfaces,resulting in larger specific surface areas and mesoscopic voids.

Fig.8 Comparison of the void per unit mass among the three kinds of mineral powder fillers

Fig.9 Comparison of the fractal dimension of mineral powder fillers with specific surface area and mesoscopic voids

Considering the specific surface area and mesoscopic void characteristics of the particles are obviously affected by their shape and surface morphology,mineral powder fillers with complex shapes and rough surface gaps can help improve the specific surface area and the medium surface of the asphalt motar.

4.2 Mesoscopic structural characteristics of asphalt mortar

Studies have shown that the ratio of structural asphalt and free asphalt affects the strength of asphalt slurries[33].On the other hand,some scholars believe that the proportion distribution of structural asphalt and free asphalt in asphalt mortar can be estimated by the mesoscopic void characteristics of mineral powder filler[34,35].Thus the mesoscopic void characteristics of mineral powder filler are important to the performance of asphalt mortar.Based on previous studies,the particle shape and surface morphology of the mineral powder filler are described with a complex rough surface type and a simple smooth surface type.During the mixing process of the mineral powder filler and asphalt,the mesoscopic voids between the mineral powder filler are filled with asphalt,leading to the formations of structural asphalt and free asphalt.The foregoing research shows that mineral powder filler with complex rough surfaces is rich in mesoscopic voids.Therefore,the asphalt mortar composed of the mineral powder filler with complex rough surface type contains more structural asphalt.The mesoscopic structural model of asphalt mortar is established,as shown in Fig.10.

Fig.10 Schematic model of mesoscopic structure of asphalt mortar

4.3 Effect of high temperature on the rutting factor of asphalt mortar

Fig.11 plots the rutting factors (G*/sinδ) of the ash in BRA and conventional mineral powder under various mesoscopic void characteristics and temperature conditions.In Fig.12,we consider the combined effects between the specific surface area of the mineral powder filler and temperature on the rutting factors.One can notice the rutting performance of the asphalt mortar made of BRA ash is better.The reason is that the particles in BRA ash have larger specific surface areas and form more mesoscopic voids,causing more structural asphalt to be created and thereby enhancing the rut resistance of the asphalt mortar.

Fig.11 G*/sinδ comparison between two asphalt mortars at various mesoscopic voids and temperature

Fig.12 G*/sinδ comparison between two asphalt mortars at various specific surface area and temperature

The effects of temperature on the rutting factor(G*/sinδ) is shown in Fig.13.As the temperature increases,the rutting factors (G*/sinδ) in both asphalt mortars decrease,and the rutting resistance of the one with BRA ash is better.It further proves that the mineral powder filler with complex shapes and rough surfaces is beneficial to the formation of structural asphalt and plays an important role in improving the rutting resistance of asphalt mortar.

Fig.13 Comparison of G*/sinδ between two types asphalt mortars at different temperatures

5 Conclusions

a) The ash in BRA and the conventional mineral powder with the same particle size distribution have a similar mesoscopic classification,but the former has a larger fractal dimension with more complex and rougher particle surfaces.Compared with conventional mineral powder,the ash in BRA has larger specific surface areas and more mesoscopic voids.

b) The mesoscopic structure model of asphalt mortar containing structural asphalt and free asphalt was established.The mineral powder filler with complex particle surfaces,like the ash in BRA,has many mesoscopic voids,which is beneficial in forming structural asphalt and improving the rutting resistance of the asphalt mortar.

c) The main purpose of this study is to consider the influence of mesoscopic characteristics of mineral powders fillers on the rutting factor (G*/sinδ) of asphalt mortar.However,in addition to the influence of temperature and vehicle,there is also a very important factor,time.Therefore,the long-term stability of BRA needs to be further studied in the future.

Conflict of interest

All authors declare that there are no competing interests.


登录APP查看全文