汪韶军

关键词:道德;仁义;儒道关系
摘 要:老子不认同仁义,甚至要绝弃仁义。但绝弃仁义,不是向下沉沦为不仁不义,而是上达于大道。《老子》又名《道德经》,本来就在“言道德之意”。与仁义相比,道德不会沦为伪善,不会临人以德,不会事事干预,不会依贵贱亲疏而爱有差等,甚至不知道自己合乎道德。道家认为,仁义如果只用作个人修德,那就可以拥有一块存身之地;如果越出个人修德的铁门限来“矫”天下,那就失去存在的合法性。世人需要做的只是不相为害,圣人则需要达到比仁义更高的道德,两种场合都用不着仁义。在学派初创时期,老、孔只是就如何重建秩序提出各自的方案,孔子欲恢复传统,老子则批评传统,两人基本上属于自说自话,没有相互攻讦。
中图分类号:B223.1文献标志码:A文章编号:1001-2435(2020)02-0039-07
Daode and Renyi—on Laozis Attitude towards Renyi and the Original Relation between Confucianism and Taoism
WANG Shao-jun(College of Humanities & Communication,Hainan University,Haikou 570228,China)
Key words:Daode;Renyi;relation between Confucianism and Taoism
Abstract:Laozi does not approve of Renyi,even claims to discard it. However,discarding Renyi is not becoming inhumane,but attaining the realm of Dao. Laozi is also called Daodejing. It is always discussing Daode. Compared with Renyi,Daode will not decay into hypocrisy. Those who cherish Daode will not be critical of other peoples morality,nor interfere with other peoples affairs. They will not apply benevolence of various degrees according to peoples status,and they even do not know that their behaviors are in accordance with Daode. Lao-Zhuang assert,if Renyi is limited to personal morality cultivating,it may exist;if Renyi is used to control others,it will lose its rationality. What ordinary people need to do is not to hurt each other,while sagas should attain the realm of Daode which is superior to Renyi. Under the two circumstances,Renyi is redundant. Originally,Laozi and Confucius only propose their respective solution to the issue of order rebuilding. Confucius wants to restore the tradition,while Laozi criticizes the tradition. They have not attacked each other.
古今人们多持非此即彼、非黑即白的思维方式,以为老子既然要绝弃仁义,便是主张不仁不义,而儒道两家也就水火不容。《老子》5章开篇又有:“天地不仁,以万物为刍狗;圣人不仁,以百姓为刍狗。”(拙文所引《老子》经文皆笔者参互诸本校订而成,下同)古今很多人望文生义,比如钱锺书先生就把“不仁”等同于麻木乃至残暴:“然天地无心,其不仁也,‘任或‘不相关而已。圣人虽‘圣,亦‘人也;人有心也,其不仁也,或由麻木,而多出残贼,以凶暴为乐。人与天地合德者,克去有心以成无心,消除有情而至‘终无情,悉化残贼,全归麻木。”[1]420这委实是厚诬古人。
当然,古今也常有人为老子受诬而叫屈,比如唐代陆希声嗔怪世人不得其旨,实则“孔、老之术不相悖”[2]121-122。……